Thirteen Thousand Otaku Name The Most Disappointing Hit Anime Series

Much talked about show wins by a landslide

In a recent poll, over 13,000 otaku responded to a Biglobe Anime Ranking poll asking which hit anime only evoked "huh?!" bewilderment. The list of disappointments is different from the previous poll of overrated anime, since the earlier one was about disagreeing with the consensus opinions of others, while the new ranking is about personal reaction.

 

1. Madoka Magica - 2016 votes

2. K-on! - 835 votes

3. Sword Art Online - 751 votes

4. Mobile Suit Gundam SEED - 615 votes

5. Fate/Zero - 606 votes

6. Lucky Star - 602 votes

7. Bakemonogatari - 570 votes

8. Saki - 525 votes

9. Horizon on the Middle of Nowhere  - 504 votes

10. AnoHana - 496 votes

11. IS <Infinite Stratos>

12. Tiger & Bunny

13. Neon Genesis Evangelion

14. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya

15. Hayate the Combat Butler

16. Angel Beats!

17. Toradora!

18. A Certain Scientific Railgun

19. CLANNAD

20. Minamike

21. Nyarko-san

22. Shakugan no Shana

23. Uta no Prince-sama

24. Familiar of Zero

25. Higurashi - When They Cry

26. Hyōka

27. Oreimo


What anime did you personally find disappointing? 


-------
Scott Green is editor and reporter for anime and manga at geek entertainment site Ain't It Cool News. Follow him on Twitter at @aicnanime.

Tags
poll
Other Top News

350 Comments
Sort by: