Created by mrsentimental
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next  Last
Which Harem Guy Deserves a Bigger Beat Down?
1480 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Philippines
Offline
Posted 3/3/08

kyomeister wrote:

lol.......

why is it MAKOTO's not in the list! ! ! !

ahahaha.... the one that deserves not just a Beat Down...

But lets not say bad things to people who had already PASS away... ahahha

lol... got his head off...


Meh, he doesn't deserve the tranquility of death. Even the nice boat. The boat is too good for him.
1745 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
34 / M / Hueco Mundo
Offline
Posted 3/3/08
I hate the wishy-washy guys that act like total nimwits more than I hate motoko. At least he grew a pair.
9383 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / LuzViMinda
Offline
Posted 3/3/08

comradered wrote:


kyomeister wrote:

lol.......

why is it MAKOTO's not in the list! ! ! !

ahahaha.... the one that deserves not just a Beat Down...

But lets not say bad things to people who had already PASS away... ahahha

lol... got his head off...


Meh, he doesn't deserve the tranquility of death. Even the nice boat. The boat is too good for him.


He's too dead to enjoy the boat. It's all Kotonoha and her psychosis, but what she sees in him (or his dead head) even after he screws with every significant female character (including her sister), I shall never know.
1480 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Philippines
Offline
Posted 3/3/08

BushidoBlaque wrote:

I hate the wishy-washy guys that act like total nimwits more than I hate motoko. At least he grew a pair.


He didn't grew jack shit. If he did, he wouldn't have taken Sekai's invitation to 'practice' touching someone's boobs. If he did realize that he was 'despicable', he would have stopped screwing every girl that he met. He didn't even take responsibility for getting Sekai pregnant. I didn't see any sign of redeeming qualities in him.
he's like the Harem-guys evil evolved form.
9383 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / LuzViMinda
Offline
Posted 3/3/08

comradered wrote:


BushidoBlaque wrote:

I hate the wishy-washy guys that act like total nimwits more than I hate motoko. At least he grew a pair.


He didn't grew jack shit. If he did, he wouldn't have taken Sekai's invitation to 'practice' touching someone's boobs. If he did realize that he was 'despicable', he would have stopped screwing every girl that he met. He didn't even take responsibility for getting Sekai pregnant. I didn't see any sign of redeeming qualities in him.
he's like the Harem-guys evil evolved form.


Not all Harem-guys are evil, nor are all of them retarded wishy-washy emo wannabes.

Tomoya and Hiroyuki ended their respective series with no broken hearts, but still retaining a lot of fond (non-sexual) memories. But other than them...
1745 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
34 / M / Hueco Mundo
Offline
Posted 3/3/08

comradered wrote:


BushidoBlaque wrote:

I hate the wishy-washy guys that act like total nimwits more than I hate motoko. At least he grew a pair.


He didn't grew jack shit. If he did, he wouldn't have taken Sekai's invitation to 'practice' touching someone's boobs. If he did realize that he was 'despicable', he would have stopped screwing every girl that he met. He didn't even take responsibility for getting Sekai pregnant. I didn't see any sign of redeeming qualities in him.
he's like the Harem-guys evil evolved form.


He's the first harem guy in a long time to act on desire. These guys have boobs flying at them 24/7 but they're too scared, too whiny, too stupid to get with any of these girls because they have crushes for the perfect girl to tuck them in at night. Sorry that's lame.

This guy grew a pair. He capitalized on every available opportunity after he found out how to treat the girls. I mean lets be real, no other harem guy would ever have to deal with pregnency because for some reason they have no idea how to get laid. People are just bagging on him because they don't like his methods.

But the fact of the matter is he got realized that he wasn't getting any from the first chick, and went to another. After than he woke the hell up and realized that getting laid was easy.
1480 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Philippines
Offline
Posted 3/3/08

gadeel wrote:


comradered wrote:


BushidoBlaque wrote:

I hate the wishy-washy guys that act like total nimwits more than I hate motoko. At least he grew a pair.


He didn't grew jack shit. If he did, he wouldn't have taken Sekai's invitation to 'practice' touching someone's boobs. If he did realize that he was 'despicable', he would have stopped screwing every girl that he met. He didn't even take responsibility for getting Sekai pregnant. I didn't see any sign of redeeming qualities in him.
he's like the Harem-guys evil evolved form.


Not all Harem-guys are evil, nor are all of them retarded wishy-washy emo wannabes.

Tomoya and Hiroyuki ended their respective series with no broken hearts, but still retaining a lot of fond (non-sexual) memories. But other than them...


There were some other non-wishy washy emo characters.. Although the one I'm talking about is extremely pathetic, has the thickest, impenetrable plot-armor I've ever seen on an anime character (yes, he tops the guys from SeedDestiny), and stubborn as hell. I'm talking about Keitaro of Love Hina fame. He was after Naru right from the beginning till the end, so I think he's not wishy-washy. But the guy is extremely idiotic, though.
Posted 3/3/08

wickedsponger20 wrote:

Tenchi was an asshole!


well put.
2944 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / M / "The World"
Offline
Posted 3/3/08
*MANkoto facepalm.jpg*

I'm gonna do the Impossible now and give out reasons why MANkoto is NOT an a-hole:

1) He never physically hurt any of the girls (Slap, Punch, Grab by wrist, etc.)

2) Aside from the last 2 episodes where everything was starting to fall apart, he never insulted or emotionally degraded (intentionally) any of the girls (Call them bitch, retard, slut, etc.)

3) To be fair, most of the girls were the ones who took the initiative with MANkoto. If Sekai hadn't kissed him in the 1st episode and subsequently gave him "Practices", things might have ended differently. Besides, you can't really blame the guy for acting like....well....a guy! Most of the guys here would probably do the same thing given the same situation. And it wouldn't have hurt for Kotonoha to have been more open to MANkoto about her feelings.

4) I'm not saying that what MANkoto did was right, but he was brave enough to set the bar for everyone in the future on what NOT to do in a relationship. For that alone, he deserves some respect.

5) People have complained for years when it comes to harem style anime saying that the guy is a WUSS for not making a move and taking advantage of the girls that like him. Well, now we finally have a guy that DOES make moves of the girls and takes advantage of them and people STILL complained! I mean...C'mon!

6) And last but not least....MANkoto has one of the most Photoshop-able heads in anime history!

159 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / M / usa
Offline
Posted 3/3/08
makoto ha s 2 b #1
1480 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Philippines
Offline
Posted 3/3/08

BushidoBlaque wrote:


comradered wrote:


BushidoBlaque wrote:

I hate the wishy-washy guys that act like total nimwits more than I hate motoko. At least he grew a pair.


He didn't grew jack shit. If he did, he wouldn't have taken Sekai's invitation to 'practice' touching someone's boobs. If he did realize that he was 'despicable', he would have stopped screwing every girl that he met. He didn't even take responsibility for getting Sekai pregnant. I didn't see any sign of redeeming qualities in him.
he's like the Harem-guys evil evolved form.


He's the first harem guy in a long time to act on desire. These guys have boobs flying at them 24/7 but they're too scared, too whiny, too stupid to get with any of these girls because they have crushes for the perfect girl to tuck them in at night. Sorry that's lame.

This guy grew a pair. He capitalized on every available opportunity after he found out how to treat the girls. I mean lets be real, no other harem guy would ever have to deal with pregnency because for some reason they have no idea how to get laid. People are just bagging on him because they don't like his methods.

But the fact of the matter is he got realized that he wasn't getting any from the first chick, and went to another. After than he woke the hell up and realized that getting laid was easy.


Naah, it isn't lame. Rather, it gives me some more insight to his character. Be that as it may, though, you'll have to excuse me for not hating him any less. So I concede that he did grew a pair. The wrong pair, though. Just because you aren't getting any from your first, doesn't mean you should get it on with others. And he continued growing awkward pairs of something when he continued getting laid. Just because you realize that it's so easy to get laid, doesn't mean you should. But considering his predisposition to lust, I guess that its his character in the first place.

All in all, IMO he came to realize the bad things, he nurtured those ideas of his, and in the end he got what he deserved. At least, in the anime.

It's different in the game though. As the player you can opt to salvage his perdicament by actually choosing someone over the others. Most of the time, he screws everyone, though....
159 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / M / usa
Offline
Posted 3/3/08
even though hes the most realistic
5789 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / San Clemente, Cal...
Offline
Posted 3/3/08
Tenichi hes such a player >.<
5789 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / San Clemente, Cal...
Offline
Posted 3/3/08

blackraptor00 wrote:

*MANkoto facepalm.jpg*

I'm gonna do the Impossible now and give out reasons why MANkoto is NOT an a-hole:

1) He never physically hurt any of the girls (Slap, Punch, Grab by wrist, etc.)

2) Aside from the last 2 episodes where everything was starting to fall apart, he never insulted or emotionally degraded (intentionally) any of the girls (Call them bitch, retard, slut, etc.)

3) To be fair, most of the girls were the ones who took the initiative with MANkoto. If Sekai hadn't kissed him in the 1st episode and subsequently gave him "Practices", things might have ended differently. Besides, you can't really blame the guy for acting like....well....a guy! Most of the guys here would probably do the same thing given the same situation. And it wouldn't have hurt for Kotonoha to have been more open to MANkoto about her feelings.

4) I'm not saying that what MANkoto did was right, but he was brave enough to set the bar for everyone in the future on what NOT to do in a relationship. For that alone, he deserves some respect.

5) People have complained for years when it comes to harem style anime saying that the guy is a WUSS for not making a move and taking advantage of the girls that like him. Well, now we finally have a guy that DOES make moves of the girls and takes advantage of them and people STILL complained! I mean...C'mon!

6) And last but not least....MANkoto has one of the most Photoshop-able heads in anime history!





wat anime is that from?
please tell me >.<
1480 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Philippines
Offline
Posted 3/3/08

blackraptor00 wrote:

*MANkoto facepalm.jpg*

I'm gonna do the Impossible now and give out reasons why MANkoto is NOT an a-hole:

1) He never physically hurt any of the girls (Slap, Punch, Grab by wrist, etc.)

2) Aside from the last 2 episodes where everything was starting to fall apart, he never insulted or emotionally degraded (intentionally) any of the girls (Call them bitch, retard, slut, etc.)

3) To be fair, most of the girls were the ones who took the initiative with MANkoto. If Sekai hadn't kissed him in the 1st episode and subsequently gave him "Practices", things might have ended differently. Besides, you can't really blame the guy for acting like....well....a guy! Most of the guys here would probably do the same thing given the same situation. And it wouldn't have hurt for Kotonoha to have been more open to MANkoto about her feelings.

4) I'm not saying that what MANkoto did was right, but he was brave enough to set the bar for everyone in the future on what NOT to do in a relationship. For that alone, he deserves some respect.

5) People have complained for years when it comes to harem style anime saying that the guy is a WUSS for not making a move and taking advantage of the girls that like him. Well, now we finally have a guy that DOES make moves of the girls and takes advantage of them and people STILL complained! I mean...C'mon!

6) And last but not least....MANkoto has one of the most Photoshop-able heads in anime history!



Hmm..

1.) Well, I guess that gives him something. Emotionally scarring Kotonoha and refusing to take responsibility with Sekai's problem hurts more though.

2.) Can't argue there.

3.) I guess no one could have predicted that Makoto would suddenly lunge at Sekai like that. And yeah, acting on lust isn't farfetched, even in real life.. No, especially in real life.

4.) That's one of the things he has done right though.

5.) I guess people finally realized that someone acting on lust in a harem-anime is just as worse with those who don't.

6.) If that's what floats your boat
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.