First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
criticize your favorite manga!
Posted 5/30/08 , edited 5/30/08
I'm going to assume I'm allowed to pick more than one.

NANA:
Ai Yazawa, and I say this with all due respect, draw faster damn it! And the anime ended at a bad time in the story.

Skip Beat:
The art is not the best and I'm really not a fan of the age difference between Ren and Kyoko and how Kyoko still has no idea that Ren is Corn. I also wish the manga would start talking more about Shota.

Ouran High School Host Club:
The art gets a bit messy at times, chapters come out too slow, Haruhi and Tamaki's relationship develops too slowly and Hikaru is becoming more and more easy to hate. The ending in the anime was complete crap. This is why they should always stick to the manga instead of fucking it up like they did with this one.

Doubt:
Chapters come out way too slow.

Glass Mask:
Art is mediocre, annoying when the mangaka goes into too much detail about the plays and actually draws it out when I really don't care about the play inside the story and I really hate Maya's love interests. I mean, Masumi is 11 years older than her (and that purple rose thing is getting really old), Yu is on the verge of being emo when it comes to Maya and I just can't bring myself to like either Yu or Masumi at all.
633 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / The Manga World
Offline
Posted 5/30/08

BE_LOVED wrote:

I'm going to assume I'm allowed to pick more than one.

NANA:
Ai Yazawa, and I say this with all due respect, draw faster damn it! And the anime ended at a bad time in the story.

Skip Beat:
The art is not the best and I'm really not a fan of the age difference between Ren and Kyoko and how Kyoko still has no idea that Ren is Corn. I also wish the manga would start talking more about Shota.

Ouran High School Host Club:
The art gets a bit messy at times, chapters come out too slow, Haruhi and Tamaki's relationship develops too slowly and Hikaru is becoming more and more easy to hate. The ending in the anime was complete crap. This is why they should always stick to the manga instead of fucking it up like they did with this one.

Doubt:
Chapters come out way too slow.

Glass Mask:
Art is mediocre, annoying when the mangaka goes into too much detail about the plays and actually draws it out when I really don't care about the play inside the story and I really hate Maya's love interests. I mean, Masumi is 11 years older than her (and that purple rose thing is getting really old), Yu is on the verge of being emo when it comes to Maya and I just can't bring myself to like either Yu or Masumi at all.


NANA:
with all due respect, I know the chapters are coming out slow, but if you think of it... over 40 pages in each chapter, someone have to draw the manga too. I don't think Ai Yazawa is lazy, it would be unrealistic that it would come out like one chapter a week... But you are right the one that translate the manga should be faster, I don't know if the chines translations are out yet and after that comes the English once...


Ouran High School Host Club:

Yeah, aren't they slow, they are long chapters too, but I heard that ch 62 isn't coming this month, we have to wait till next month... it is anoying...
And I can't hate Hikaru at all .. I think Tono maybe won't relise his love feelings for haruhi, and Hikaru and haruhi is a better match..
7004 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / The Silent Sun
Offline
Posted 5/30/08
Special A

I think the characters' faces are a bit too sharp and Hikari is too slow in love but other wise...perfect!
16324 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Bangalore,India
Offline
Posted 5/30/08
WORST

Where are the new chapters(if they get released at all)?
I want to see Amachi's plan!
1803 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / phil....
Offline
Posted 9/22/08

-mixmich- wrote:

just want to know what can you say about:

the story...
the drawing...
the episodes...
the translations...
the characters...
the originality of the story...

something like that..

and if ever the manga that you've read was made into anime, what can you say?? which is better?? is the story different from the manga?? what are the deleted scenes??

just feel free to share!!




your right... they deleted some part of the story...
like in ouran host club......
but other that i like the way they made it anime...
just hoping that they wont cut any on the next season...
11116 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / College
Offline
Posted 9/22/08
buso renkin awesome series the ending was a little rediculous
hellsing book 8 seemed to be heading towords a dramatic conclusion but then i could'nt find the rest also it was horriffically gory i mean the main charecter kills over 3000 people i mean geez desu~
391 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F
Offline
Posted 9/22/08
i'm critisizing the AUTHOR OF TAIL OF THE MOON! ok, it's one of my favorite series... and.. uh.. dang.. (SPOILER AHEAD)






1958 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 9/23/08

kattilisen wrote:


BE_LOVED wrote:

I'm going to assume I'm allowed to pick more than one.

NANA:
Ai Yazawa, and I say this with all due respect, draw faster damn it! And the anime ended at a bad time in the story.


NANA:
with all due respect, I know the chapters are coming out slow, but if you think of it... over 40 pages in each chapter, someone have to draw the manga too. I don't think Ai Yazawa is lazy, it would be unrealistic that it would come out like one chapter a week... But you are right the one that translate the manga should be faster, I don't know if the chines translations are out yet and after that comes the English once...


Ouran High School Host Club:

Yeah, aren't they slow, they are long chapters too, but I heard that ch 62 isn't coming this month, we have to wait till next month... it is anoying...
And I can't hate Hikaru at all .. I think Tono maybe won't relise his love feelings for haruhi, and Hikaru and haruhi is a better match..


I agree..I don't think Ai Yazawa is a lazy mangaka...in fact just the opposite, she's one of the most productive mangakas I've ever known. In comparison w/ other mangakas, she has completed a great deal of works, and every chapter of those works aren't the 20-30 pgs you usually see in other mangas..they're long and beautifully drawn.

I used to LOVE Ouran..but now it's just ok..it's obvious where the author's steering ahem..Haruhi and Tamaki...ahem. So as a Hikaru x Haruhi fan girl, I'm a lil disappointed. I also don't like how now the author focuses the entire possibilities to just down to two: Tamaki and Hikaru. I mean what are the other guys there for? Aren't they supposed to be stirring up ambiguity so that the readers won't know who she's gonna end up w/ ? Or maybe the author decided to go towards a more realistic route...
32215 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
33 / F / Denver
Offline
Posted 9/23/08 , edited 9/23/08
Kaori Ozaki, you take too long drawing Immortal Rain. I want volume #9 NOW!!!!
18 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / M / Rotherham, UK
Offline
Posted 9/23/08 , edited 9/23/08
Love School Rumble in its various incarnations (while not being my ultimate favorite manga/anime), but... for god sake JK get Harima Kenji and Sawachicka Eri together

8000 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
77 / M / california
Offline
Posted 9/23/08
naruto

chapters are too short and i ahev to wait one full weak to read it
164 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Right behind you
Offline
Posted 11/23/08
I liked death note a lot.
I wasnt a fan of the drawing thoo.
=]
2470 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Half-Blood Camp
Offline
Posted 12/6/08
yeah!
everything has its flaws and even your fave manga has one too ^^
2470 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Half-Blood Camp
Offline
Posted 12/6/08

mhitzz wrote:


-mixmich- wrote:

just want to know what can you say about:

the story...
the drawing...
the episodes...
the translations...
the characters...
the originality of the story...

something like that..

and if ever the manga that you've read was made into anime, what can you say?? which is better?? is the story different from the manga?? what are the deleted scenes??

just feel free to share!!




your right... they deleted some part of the story...
like in ouran host club......
but other that i like the way they made it anime...
just hoping that they wont cut any on the next season...


there's a second season?!
oh yeah, i heard it a lot but its not true,i guess
14887 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / Dri Thru
Offline
Posted 12/6/08
Bleach

When the hell will the Ulqui vs Ichi fight start?
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.