Created by clsim
First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
Post Reply Best Katana master
Member
17097 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F
Offline
Posted 3/25/08
Chose The best one




4444 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / M / In your dreams...
Offline
Posted 3/25/08

clsim wrote:

Chose The best one



None of those are Katana though.
There's some funky lame Shirasaya Ninja Tachi, a Zanpakuto, and a Sakabatou.
I present you an informative article by myself: http://www.crunchyroll.com/forumtopic-129397/What-is-a-Katana.html#8127867
Member
17097 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F
Offline
Posted 3/25/08

Ice_Blue_Eyes wrote:


clsim wrote:

Chose The best one



None of those are Katana though.
There's some funky lame Shirasaya Ninja Tachi, a Zanpakuto, and a Sakabatou.
I present you an informative article by myself: http://www.crunchyroll.com/forumtopic-129397/What-is-a-Katana.html#8127867


it that true jc-san????

if so.. i'm really sorry nê... i wanted to help you... but it seems like
Creator
1687 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / North Carolina
Offline
Posted 3/25/08

clsim wrote:


Ice_Blue_Eyes wrote:


clsim wrote:

Chose The best one



None of those are Katana though.
There's some funky lame Shirasaya Ninja Tachi, a Zanpakuto, and a Sakabatou.
I present you an informative article by myself: http://www.crunchyroll.com/forumtopic-129397/What-is-a-Katana.html#8127867


it that true jc-san????

if so.. i'm really sorry nê... i wanted to help you... but it seems like


if we are lookin at the materials then they are not REAL katanas. they are just replicas made out of probably stainless steel. but, they are katanas in some way. dont worry clsim, u did help, and i appreciate that.
10476 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / I go where Ryu go...
Offline
Posted 3/25/08

Ice_Blue_Eyes wrote:


clsim wrote:

Chose The best one



None of those are Katana though.
There's some funky lame Shirasaya Ninja Tachi, a Zanpakuto, and a Sakabatou.
I present you an informative article by myself: http://www.crunchyroll.com/forumtopic-129397/What-is-a-Katana.html#8127867


You dont have to be quite so literal, this is just for fun- if people are a little oblivious to the exact specifications of a katana, then let them be.

So their not katanas- this is an anime website- swords from anime that resemble katanas are going to show up here. Its just part of the fanbase. I am not saying that your wrong- but you really shouldnt trash something so completely before it gets a chance to take off.

And now a little trashing of my own :P. I think Gin and that crazy samurai from the end of samurai champloo are the best katana masters.
4444 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / M / In your dreams...
Offline
Posted 3/25/08

Macedonian wrote:

You dont have to be quite so literal, this is just for fun- if people are a little oblivious to the exact specifications of a katana, then let them be.

So their not katanas- this is an anime website- swords from anime that resemble katanas are going to show up here. Its just part of the fanbase. I am not saying that your wrong- but you really shouldnt trash something so completely before it gets a chance to take off.

And now a little trashing of my own :P. I think Gin and that crazy samurai from the end of samurai champloo are the best katana masters.


Just for fun or not, A katana is a katana. That's like calling an Axe a Hammer. Groups like these have "Katana" and such in their name are specifying not just japanese swords but katana themselves.

I'm not trashing anything. Simply pointing out some facts.

Good topic though, I didn't mean to discourage anyone.
Creator
1687 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / North Carolina
Offline
Posted 3/25/08

Ice_Blue_Eyes wrote:


Macedonian wrote:

You dont have to be quite so literal, this is just for fun- if people are a little oblivious to the exact specifications of a katana, then let them be.

So their not katanas- this is an anime website- swords from anime that resemble katanas are going to show up here. Its just part of the fanbase. I am not saying that your wrong- but you really shouldnt trash something so completely before it gets a chance to take off.

And now a little trashing of my own :P. I think Gin and that crazy samurai from the end of samurai champloo are the best katana masters.


Just for fun or not, A katana is a katana. That's like calling an Axe a Hammer. Groups like these have "Katana" and such in their name are specifying not just japanese swords but katana themselves.

I'm not trashing anything. Simply pointing out some facts.

Good topic though, I didn't mean to discourage anyone.


You certainly can't compare an axe with a hammer, and yes, they may be fake but they are still katanas. It's like saying that a clone is not a human being. They are just copies, but still are katanas.

I know your purpose is not to discourage anyone here, but there are people that don't know as much as you or I do. Not knowing is not a sin, so I politely ask you, try to be more kind when responding. You may not do it on purpose, but some people may find it offensive.

I have nothing against you, I'm just trying to maintain peace in the group.

Thank you for understanding, and please do not feel offended.
Creator
1687 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / North Carolina
Offline
Posted 3/25/08

Macedonian wrote:


Ice_Blue_Eyes wrote:


clsim wrote:

Chose The best one



None of those are Katana though.
There's some funky lame Shirasaya Ninja Tachi, a Zanpakuto, and a Sakabatou.
I present you an informative article by myself: http://www.crunchyroll.com/forumtopic-129397/What-is-a-Katana.html#8127867


You dont have to be quite so literal, this is just for fun- if people are a little oblivious to the exact specifications of a katana, then let them be.

So their not katanas- this is an anime website- swords from anime that resemble katanas are going to show up here. Its just part of the fanbase. I am not saying that your wrong- but you really shouldnt trash something so completely before it gets a chance to take off.

And now a little trashing of my own :P. I think Gin and that crazy samurai from the end of samurai champloo are the best katana masters.


you're right haha, i forgot about gin and the other dude, which name's i can't remember

they are pretty good though. but for some reason i still believe kenshin is more talented just my personal opinion ^-^ haha
4444 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / M / In your dreams...
Offline
Posted 3/26/08
I'm sorry, you're words are reasonable but if I'm offending something by simply stating a fact, what has the world come to?
I didn't mean that they are copies, I meant that one is a sakabato, one is a zanpakuto and one is a shirasaya tachi. (Tachi is the proverbial opposite of a Katana. It's the thing that the Naruto kid is holding.)

If you'd like a reason as to why I take it on myself to correct certain misrepresentations and innacuracies, perhaps you can check out the thread I made. I don't want to mess up this thread any longer.


On the subject; I'd have to say Kenshin. He has some grace to what he does. I know Ichigo swings his sword around like a bat. hahaha

Though I never understood the point of having a reversed blade. Those hits would kill someone as easy as a sword would. Heck a bokken could kill someone with one strike.

Why not an Iaito? That's what I am wondering.
If he vows not to cut again, why not use an unsharpened katana; An Iaito?
Member
5745 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
33 / F / dont know.....
Offline
Posted 3/26/08
...... if we are talking if one is good at fight i will choose kenshin....
in bleach there is nothing about katana per se..... the show some kendo "the way of the sword"

in naruto..... well i cant see anithing realted to a katana... just sasuke... but i dont think he can use it well...
10476 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / I go where Ryu go...
Offline
Posted 3/26/08

Ice_Blue_Eyes wrote:


Macedonian wrote:

You dont have to be quite so literal, this is just for fun- if people are a little oblivious to the exact specifications of a katana, then let them be.

So their not katanas- this is an anime website- swords from anime that resemble katanas are going to show up here. Its just part of the fanbase. I am not saying that your wrong- but you really shouldnt trash something so completely before it gets a chance to take off.

And now a little trashing of my own :P. I think Gin and that crazy samurai from the end of samurai champloo are the best katana masters.


Just for fun or not, A katana is a katana. That's like calling an Axe a Hammer. Groups like these have "Katana" and such in their name are specifying not just japanese swords but katana themselves.

I'm not trashing anything. Simply pointing out some facts.

Good topic though, I didn't mean to discourage anyone.


It's not a problem, I do not defy that fact, just please be a little gentler next time. Maybe add to the article which one you like the best even if you dont agree- that way other people wont feel stupid if they post in here, just beacause you said that the thread was wrong. People in this group will listen to you because it would seem that you have a greater knoledge of the weapon in question. Even the slightest bit of power must be handled well.

I do not mean to offend so If I said something wrong- your welcome to call me on it.
10476 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / I go where Ryu go...
Offline
Posted 3/26/08

jc-san wrote:


Macedonian wrote:


Ice_Blue_Eyes wrote:


clsim wrote:

Chose The best one



None of those are Katana though.
There's some funky lame Shirasaya Ninja Tachi, a Zanpakuto, and a Sakabatou.
I present you an informative article by myself: http://www.crunchyroll.com/forumtopic-129397/What-is-a-Katana.html#8127867


You dont have to be quite so literal, this is just for fun- if people are a little oblivious to the exact specifications of a katana, then let them be.

So their not katanas- this is an anime website- swords from anime that resemble katanas are going to show up here. Its just part of the fanbase. I am not saying that your wrong- but you really shouldnt trash something so completely before it gets a chance to take off.

And now a little trashing of my own :P. I think Gin and that crazy samurai from the end of samurai champloo are the best katana masters.


you're right haha, i forgot about gin and the other dude, which name's i can't remember

they are pretty good though. but for some reason i still believe kenshin is more talented just my personal opinion ^-^ haha



Mugen ^_^ !! Do you remember the name of the samurai at the end? He was cool.
Creator
1687 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / North Carolina
Offline
Posted 3/26/08

Macedonian wrote:


jc-san wrote:


Macedonian wrote:


Ice_Blue_Eyes wrote:


clsim wrote:

Chose The best one



None of those are Katana though.
There's some funky lame Shirasaya Ninja Tachi, a Zanpakuto, and a Sakabatou.
I present you an informative article by myself: http://www.crunchyroll.com/forumtopic-129397/What-is-a-Katana.html#8127867


You dont have to be quite so literal, this is just for fun- if people are a little oblivious to the exact specifications of a katana, then let them be.

So their not katanas- this is an anime website- swords from anime that resemble katanas are going to show up here. Its just part of the fanbase. I am not saying that your wrong- but you really shouldnt trash something so completely before it gets a chance to take off.

And now a little trashing of my own :P. I think Gin and that crazy samurai from the end of samurai champloo are the best katana masters.


you're right haha, i forgot about gin and the other dude, which name's i can't remember

they are pretty good though. but for some reason i still believe kenshin is more talented just my personal opinion ^-^ haha



Mugen ^_^ !! Do you remember the name of the samurai at the end? He was cool.


oh, you were talkin about mugen. i did remember his name, i thought u were talkin about the guy that wore that hat, that killed fuu's father.
10476 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / I go where Ryu go...
Offline
Posted 3/26/08

jc-san wrote:


Macedonian wrote:


jc-san wrote:


Macedonian wrote:


Ice_Blue_Eyes wrote:


clsim wrote:

Chose The best one



None of those are Katana though.
There's some funky lame Shirasaya Ninja Tachi, a Zanpakuto, and a Sakabatou.
I present you an informative article by myself: http://www.crunchyroll.com/forumtopic-129397/What-is-a-Katana.html#8127867


You dont have to be quite so literal, this is just for fun- if people are a little oblivious to the exact specifications of a katana, then let them be.

So their not katanas- this is an anime website- swords from anime that resemble katanas are going to show up here. Its just part of the fanbase. I am not saying that your wrong- but you really shouldnt trash something so completely before it gets a chance to take off.

And now a little trashing of my own :P. I think Gin and that crazy samurai from the end of samurai champloo are the best katana masters.


you're right haha, i forgot about gin and the other dude, which name's i can't remember

they are pretty good though. but for some reason i still believe kenshin is more talented just my personal opinion ^-^ haha



Mugen ^_^ !! Do you remember the name of the samurai at the end? He was cool.


oh, you were talkin about mugen. i did remember his name, i thought u were talkin about the guy that wore that hat, that killed fuu's father.


Yup, that was who I was talking about- I just thought you forgot Mugens name, sry. That guy was badass. I almost felt bad when he died. It was an interesting series, don't you think?

I hope they come out with a movie or something...

Creator
1687 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / North Carolina
Offline
Posted 3/26/08

Macedonian wrote:


jc-san wrote:


Macedonian wrote:


jc-san wrote:


Macedonian wrote:


Ice_Blue_Eyes wrote:


clsim wrote:

Chose The best one



None of those are Katana though.
There's some funky lame Shirasaya Ninja Tachi, a Zanpakuto, and a Sakabatou.
I present you an informative article by myself: http://www.crunchyroll.com/forumtopic-129397/What-is-a-Katana.html#8127867


You dont have to be quite so literal, this is just for fun- if people are a little oblivious to the exact specifications of a katana, then let them be.

So their not katanas- this is an anime website- swords from anime that resemble katanas are going to show up here. Its just part of the fanbase. I am not saying that your wrong- but you really shouldnt trash something so completely before it gets a chance to take off.

And now a little trashing of my own :P. I think Gin and that crazy samurai from the end of samurai champloo are the best katana masters.


you're right haha, i forgot about gin and the other dude, which name's i can't remember

they are pretty good though. but for some reason i still believe kenshin is more talented just my personal opinion ^-^ haha



Mugen ^_^ !! Do you remember the name of the samurai at the end? He was cool.


oh, you were talkin about mugen. i did remember his name, i thought u were talkin about the guy that wore that hat, that killed fuu's father.


Yup, that was who I was talking about- I just thought you forgot Mugens name, sry. That guy was badass. I almost felt bad when he died. It was an interesting series, don't you think?

I hope they come out with a movie or something...


i agree with you, that guy was extremely talented, but most importantly, samurai champloo was an awesone series. it's bad that it's short. i loved it soooo much that i downloaded every episode and put it in my ipod so y could watch anytime time i wanted hahaha
First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.