First  Prev  1  2  3  4  Next  Last
Post Reply List of Dramas Indonesia Has Copied
Member
4902 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / Shah Alam, Selangor
Offline
Posted 5/26/08
but some of the copied Indonesian dramas also broadcast on Malaysian television stations, too.
Member
15556 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / Malaysia,South Ea...
Offline
Posted 6/8/08
Pacarku Pendek Sekali = Lovely Complex (J-movie)

lol i seriusly wanna laugh when i read this...Pacarku pendek sekali means my boyfriend is really short XD


Member
8839 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / malaysia (althoug...
Offline
Posted 6/17/08
*shock at the long list of the plagiarized drama*

.............................................
*speechless*

i wonder, is it bcoz they like their language so much that they decide to make a version of their own? there's always an alternative way you know...like DUBBING the original version into ur own language? save all the cost of producing a new drama...

*shrugs*
Member
23012 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / my bed
Offline
Posted 6/18/08

joechenglover wrote:

1. Buku Harian Nayla = 1 Litre Of Tears (J-dorama)
2. Impian Cinderella = Frog Prince (T-drama)
3. Bintang = Putri Huan Zhu / princess Huan Zhu Ge Ge(T-drama)
4. Legenda Ular Putih = White Snake Legend (T-drama)
5. Cincin = Beautiful Days (K-drama)
6. Siapa Takut Jatuh Cinta = Meteor Garden (T-drama)
7. Ciuman Pertama = Itazura Na Kiss (J-dorama)
8. Cowok Impian = It Started With A Kiss (T-drama)
9. Demi Cinta = Endless Love (K-drama)
10. Jangan Pisahkan Kami=Endless Love (K-drama)
11. Liontin = Glass Shoes (K-drama)
12. Pangeran Penggoda = Devil Beside You (T-drama)
13. Benar2 Cinta = Devil Beside You (T-drama)
14. Cinta Sejati = Stairway To Heaven (K-drama)
15. Opera SMU = Great Teacher Naomi (J-dorama)
16. 100 hari mencari cinta = mr arogan (K-movie)
17. Istri Untuk Suamiku = Chori Chori Chupke Chupke (Mencintaimu Diam Diam) - Indian Series
18. Kesatria Banjaran = Mulan (Disney's Animation)
19. Bukan Diriku = Anything For You (J-dorama)--> 5 first eps, after that they change the whole story.
20. Dua Hati = Snow Angel (T-drama) + Le Robe De Mariage Des Cieux (?)
21. Putri Kembar = Twins/100% Senorita (T-drama)
22. Benci Bilang Cinta = Princess Hours (K-drama)
23. Benci Jadi Cinta = My Girl (K-drama)
24. Sumpah Gue Sayang Elo = Smiling Pasta (T-drama)
25. Pengantin Remaja = My Little Bride aka Sweet 18 (K-drama)
26. Bawa aku ke Surga = Fly Me to Polaris (T-movie)
27. Putri Yang Terbuang = Putri Bunga Persik (Classic Chinese Series)
28. Intan = Be Strong Geum Soon (K-drama)
29. Idola = High School Musical (Disney's Movie)
30. I love you, Boss! = Bright Girl's Success Story (K-drama)
31. Janji Jaya = My name is Kim Sam Soon (K-drama)
32. Darling = My name is Kim Sam Soon (K-drama)
33. Penyihir Cinta = Magician Of Love (T-drama)
34. Kau Masih Kekasihku = At the Dolphin Bay (T-drama)
35. Atas Nama Cinta = Stairway To Heaven (K-drama)
36. Katakan Kau Mencintaiku = Sad Love Song (K-drama)
37. Cinta Kelas Atas = the OC (Hollywood Series)
38. Terpikat = Kuch-Kuch Hota Hai (India Movie)
39. Rahasia Pelangi = Love a part a moment (T-drama)
40. Pelangi di matamu 1 = Hoshi no Kinka (J-dorama)
41. Pelangi di matamu 2 = kamisama mou sukoshi dake (J-dorama)
42. Cewekku Jutek = my Sassy Girl (K-movie)
43. Jonathan Mulya & Alyssa (FTV) = A Walk to Remember (Hollywood Movie)
44. Rahasiaku = Kal Hoo na Hoo (India Movie)
45. de Neny = The Nanny (Hollywood Series)
46. Cinta Remaja = Sassy Girl Chun-hyang (K-drama)
47. Wulan = Yellow Handkerchief (K-drama)
48. So what gitu loh? = Friends (Hollywood Series)
49. Baby Doll = Love Storm (T-drama)
50. Pasangan Heboh = Fantasy Couple (K-drama)
51. Kakak Iparku 17 tahun = My sister in law is 19 (K-drama)
52. Olivia = She's the Man (Hollywood Movie)
53. Sissy putri Duyung = Aquamarine (Hollywood Movie)
54. Jodoh Romantis = Romance (K-drama)
55. Cinderella Boy=Hanazakarino Kimitachihe (T-drama) --> the beginning is different, but in the middle it's the same
56. Cinta Fitri = Pure Love of 19 (K-drama)
57. Nona = Pure Love of 19 (K-drama) --> not airing
58. Kekasih = East Of Eden/Cloud Stairway (K-drama)
59. Love = The Outsiders (T-drama) --> 4 first eps , What Stars Are You From (K-drama) --> eps 5+
60. Janji = Terms Of Endeagement (K-drama)
61. Pura-Pura Kawin = Full House (K-drama)
62. Kacang Panjang dan Kurcaci (FTV) = Lovely Complex (J-movie)
63. Pembantu Milyarder = Fantasy Couple (K-drama)
64. Kenapa Gw Gak Boleh jatuh Cinta (FTV) = Lovely Rivals (K-movie)
65. Bumbu-Bumbu Cinta = Corner With Love (T-drama)
66. Fajar = Hello God (K-drama)
67. Pacar Pilihan = Lovers in Paris (K-drama) --> they said they have the lisence but the one who got the lisence is sinemart but produce by mutlivision.
68. Romatika Remaja = John Tucker Must Die (Hollywood Movie)
69. Bunga Jomblo Forever (FTV) = Never Been Kissed (Hollywood Movie)
70. Candy = Candy Candy (anime/manga)
71. Mawar = One Million Roses (K-drama)
72. Cintaku Tipe B = my Boyfriend is Type B (K-movie)
73. Pacarin Gw Kalo Berani = My Tutor Friend (K-movie)
74. Kugapai Cintamu = Staiway to Heaven (K-drama)
75. Pacarku Pendek Sekali = Lovely Complex (J-movie)
76. Eneng (RCTI) = Doraemon (anime)
77. Cinta 117 Kg = 200 pounds of Beauty (K-movie)
78. Mini = Min Min (manga)
79. Pacar Untuk Calon Kakak Iparku (FTV) = 10 Things I Hate About You (Hollywood Movie)
80. Cewek Gw Norak Sekalee (FTV) = My Dream Girl (T-movie)
81. Mend4dak Kawin = Wonderful Life (K-drama)
82. Ratu = Snow Queen (K-drama)
83. Mamamia (FTV) = Because I Said So (Hollywood Movie)
84. Mata Setan (FTV) = The Eye (Hong-Kong/Thailand Movie)
85. Bias-Bias kasih (1996) = Silk/Cinta Selembut Sutera (Singapore Series)
86. Jangan Rebut Suamiku (1997) = Romance/Kekasih (Singapore Series)
87. Balikin Body Gue Donk (FTV) = Wish Upon A Star (Hollywood Movie)
88. Sujudku = Rosalinda (Telenovela)--copied +50%
89. Bawang Putih Bawang Merah = Hana Yori Dango (J-Dorama)--copied + 50%
90. Patah hati? Capek Dech (Cookies) = John Tucker Must Die (Hollywood Movie)
91. Peluk Aku 3 menit (Cookies) = Millionaire's First Love (K-Drama)
92. Tabir Asmara (FTV) = What Lies Beneath (Hollywood Movie)
93. Kutunggu Kau di pasar Minggu (FTV) = Notting Hill (Hollywood Movie)
94. Kalo Cinta Ngomong Donk(FTV) = Love Me If You Dare (French Movie)
95. Cinta Rasa Mocca (FTV) - Beauty and the Beast (K-drama)
96. Beruntung? Gw Banget.. (FTV) - Just My Luck (Hollywood Movie)
97. Museum Spooky (FTV) = Night at The Museum (Hollywood Movies)
98. Pacarku Milyarder (FTV) = Marrying a Millionaire (k-drama)

list credit to :http://www.lautanindonesia.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=25271


It's so many, indeed
me, as one of the indonesian people that against This~

i never watch most of dramas in the list...
Though i'm in indonesian~
Most people here hate it too, but the producer still love make that shit dramas, and the rating is good too.. i wonder why :unsure:




Member
665 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / SuJu's 12th floor...
Offline
Posted 9/23/08
im boycotting BHN too, but.

as far as i know, bawang putih bawang merah has no similarity AT ALL with HYD. idk if any of you have watched it, i watched both dramas and find no similarity at all. in fact, bawang putih bawang merah is based on indonesian traditional story, so its really unfair that u put it there.
Member
1242 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / spore
Offline
Posted 9/27/08
LOLX! MY GDNESS, it is a REALLY REALLY long list posted here.

do ppl really watch those dramas? i mean, they are juz re-production of a show wad.. where's the sense of freshness then? ><
Member
7988 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / CANADA~
Offline
Posted 9/27/08
Holy crap.. that's one long list...>_>" No offence against Indonesian people. but why the hell would they think of doing that in the first place =\ It's not that they're NOT gonna get found out sooner or later -_-; If they were charged for all the plagerism they've done.. Think of how much money that would be O_O
Member
5 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25
Offline
Posted 10/2/08
Salvador Dali once said "Those who do not want to imitate anything, produce nothing"
you do know who Salvador Dali is right?

we produced something. we've achieved things, we've created good movies.

bawang merah and bawang putih? wake up people. It's a folk story since like, ancient.

don't exaggerate things. how can you make such a conclusion? people worked on those movies, people who get paid, people who made it possible to be watched on the screen. It's not easy, it's hard work, and you easily say they're imitating something?
550 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F
Offline
Posted 10/5/08
I dont know why i join this group I should leave after this
I feel is kinda too mean
True they copies too much
but hey they not the only one who copy alots too rite?
Taiwanese adopt Japanese manga/anime alots
they also latey got their drama not their own

Devil behid You
It Started With A Kiss
MG (Hana Yori Dango)
City of sky
Sweet Relationship
Marmalade Boy
Poor Prince Taro
Mars
Hana Kimi
Hi! Working Girl
Peach Girl
Qilin House of Love
Romantic Princess

But i dont get why they have boycott
Everyone copy each other but why they
then shouldnt taiwanse, chinese or other also have boycott too
I not indoeasia but i just found is a little too mean
Yeah i know they kill 1 litre tear big time hahaha my drama
Ryoxerika
no matter wuz the sec one could never be as good as the first one
is great that other like it n want to make their own version
maybe they really like i and want how the story go their way
so maybe they change alot from the japnanese ver.

I love 1 litre tears alots
is make me sad that erika ryo dont have much romance but
this is not romance drama anyway




Member
1365 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23
Offline
Posted 10/14/08
omg i cant believe that 2 many they copy.indonesian people always copy the top2 movie or drama.why doesnt their make their own??that would make their top!!
Member
231 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / Japan And INDONES...
Offline
Posted 10/27/08
REALLY?NOT REALLY ALL !!

Indonesia not all copy until so many !!!
That made this forum the SOK TAHU...

NOT REALLY !! don't believe!! He only wanted to destroy the Indonesian name LOL


Jika kamu benar2 tahu ...apa buktinya ah?GUE AJA GAK TAU !! If you knew all that..

Could you report we Could you report we ?LOL


Member
536 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / Malaysia
Offline
Posted 11/28/08

scarlet820 wrote:


starmuffin wrote:

you guys keep saying indonesia plagerize dramas, please, not DRAMAS! but the mangas they were based on. Hanakimi was based on the manga hanazakari no kimitachie, it has 2 versions taiwanese and japanese, japanese version (it was done later than taiwanese) did not plagerize the taiwanese version, they paid the author of the manga to represent the manga as a drama, their 2 completely different versions. Same with meteor garden and hana yori dango... their not plagerizing but creating another version. God, you guys are mad just because u feel offended by the shitty indonesian version of 1 litre of tears. Assume it, one litre of tears is better, cast, acting, story EVERYTHING! but it does not mean the indonesian version PLAGERIZED it, its based on the diary of kito aya, not on the drama!


Starmuffin,

ARE YOU AWARE OF WHAT YOU ARE SAYING!?

If the indonesian version "buku harian nayla" DID NOT plagiarized cuz they based the storyline to the actual diary of Kitou Aya and not to the jdorama "One Litre of Tears", isn't it still PLAGIARIZM!?

Why I say so?

Well <_<; ---- In the FIRST PLACE, RCTI (the one who aired buku harian nayla) did not credit or acknowledge not only Fuji TV and the jdorama One Litre Of Tears
BUT ALSO the diary of Kitou Aya!

They EVEN noted that "This story is fictitious: the similarities of names, characters, places, and times are purely coincidental."
HOW can it be PURELY COINCIDENTAL when there is an ACTUAL REAL STORY behind this
- and that is the LIFE STORY of the REAL KITOU AYA!
It's like they didn't even PAY RESPECT to the memory of a person who already passed away - and THAT for me is JUST PLAIN RUDE!

ANOTHER THING.
If they DID NOT copy the jdorama itself then how come they have SIMILAR SCENES and EVEN SAME CHARACTERS like Moses is to Asou Haruto? If they really DID ONLY based their storyline to the diary, then THERE SHOULDN'T be any MOSES.

Because in the diary of Kitou Aya, THERE WASN'T anyone like Asou. Asou is only a FICTIONAL character that was ADDED to the jdorama's storyline because it was a special request of Kitou Aya's mother since one of her deepest regrets was that her daughter was unable to experience a relationship(love life) in her short life.

So you STILL think they, RCTI and the BHN staff especially the screenwriter Serena Luna(Chevyra Edenia) HAVE NOT DONE any wrongdoing!?


im totally agree with you scarlet820 ... i feel like crying over ur words.... well, kitou aya should be having respect from others like us who knows how to SAY THE TRUTH about this.. and about BHN plagiarized 1 Litre of Tears and changed Aya's Story....

*Kitou aya-san, forgive us as we cant help u so much except defending the truth just this way....*

Member
2351 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / Singapore
Offline
Posted 11/29/08

korfkid wrote:

Pacarku Pendek Sekali = Lovely Complex (J-movie)

lol i seriusly wanna laugh when i read this...Pacarku pendek sekali means my boyfriend is really short XD


hell yeah me too :3
(i understand malay, i slighty of indonesia cause the launguage malaysia/indonesia is the same)

nothing of that matters.

anyway, i'm kinda pissed too. i mean, if they wanna copy, put a copyright on it. Indoneisa always (when i mean always, its alwaaaaaays) broadcast these romance drama and so on, and its not even theirs.
another thing is i dont like indon romance made dramas cause its like sooo flooding of love, which is hardly realistic. -_-



89. Bawang Putih Bawang Merah = Hana Yori Dango (J-Dorama)--copied + 50%

i watched Bawang Putih Bawang Merah before, but i dont think there's any copy things going on
BUT i remember watching this Indon drama where there's these 3 guys who bullies a commoner, then like 2 of the rich guys like her and blah blah. Just like in Hana Yori Dango.
Member
15556 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / Malaysia,South Ea...
Offline
Posted 11/29/08

eternal_days wrote:


korfkid wrote:

Pacarku Pendek Sekali = Lovely Complex (J-movie)

lol i seriusly wanna laugh when i read this...Pacarku pendek sekali means my boyfriend is really short XD


hell yeah me too :3
(i understand malay, i slighty of indonesia cause the launguage malaysia/indonesia is the same)

nothing of that matters.

anyway, i'm kinda pissed too. i mean, if they wanna copy, put a copyright on it. Indoneisa always (when i mean always, its alwaaaaaays) broadcast these romance drama and so on, and its not even theirs.
another thing is i dont like indon romance made dramas cause its like sooo flooding of love, which is hardly realistic. -_-



89. Bawang Putih Bawang Merah = Hana Yori Dango (J-Dorama)--copied + 50%

i watched Bawang Putih Bawang Merah before, but i dont think there's any copy things going on
BUT i remember watching this Indon drama where there's these 3 guys who bullies a commoner, then like 2 of the rich guys like her and blah blah. Just like in Hana Yori Dango.


i'm malay actually oh yeah about bawang merah bawang putih it's nothing compare to hana yori dango it's juz a lotof ppl lik her( and i think siska is pretier than the main character lol) i wonder why ppl lik to watch that sinetron it's REALLY lame
Member
15556 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / Malaysia,South Ea...
Offline
Posted 11/29/08

Yangel616 wrote:

I dont know why i join this group I should leave after this
I feel is kinda too mean
True they copies too much
but hey they not the only one who copy alots too rite?
Taiwanese adopt Japanese manga/anime alots
they also latey got their drama not their own

Devil behid You
It Started With A Kiss
MG (Hana Yori Dango)
City of sky
Sweet Relationship
Marmalade Boy
Poor Prince Taro
Mars
Hana Kimi
Hi! Working Girl
Peach Girl
Qilin House of Love
Romantic Princess

But i dont get why they have boycott
Everyone copy each other but why they
then shouldnt taiwanse, chinese or other also have boycott too
I not indoeasia but i just found is a little too mean
Yeah i know they kill 1 litre tear big time hahaha my drama
Ryoxerika
no matter wuz the sec one could never be as good as the first one
is great that other like it n want to make their own version
maybe they really like i and want how the story go their way
so maybe they change alot from the japnanese ver.

I love 1 litre tears alots
is make me sad that erika ryo dont have much romance but
this is not romance drama anyway







because the stories that you listed i based on manga and they give credit for that
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.