2274 cr points
Send Message:   F / Narnia
 Offline
|
heya everybody,
ive watched Hana Kimi Japan and its like i dont know if its worth it watching Hana Kimi Tawain cuz it mite not be as good as the Japanese one, Which do u think is better really?? to tell u the truth the japanse one is really good, and ppl say the tawain one is funny but i dunno.................
|
|
Member
246 cr points
Send Message: 27 / M / Makati, Manila
Offline
|
hey i've watched both versions and they're both good~ i don't get why people can't stop comparing the two :(
i feel like these all sprung out from the ABS-CBN - GMA network rivalry in the philippines..
now about your question.. you've watched hana kimi japan and hana kimi taiwan has a "few different spices" in it, i recommend watching it as well.. there is no better version~ as previously mentioned, they're both good
|
139 cr points
Send Message: 22
Offline
|
i would SO go for hana kimi japan
|
77 cr points
Send Message: 24 / F / perth, australia
Offline
|
well i think u should watch both...both are equally good i guess but the taiwan version is more stretched while the japanese one is more in speed...both very good lor...if u have to compare i think the best thing out of the two is how well the character of nakatsu/ xiu yi was portray dramatically well by each actors...hahaha really very dramatic and make each scene so funny....
|
|
Member
495 cr points
Send Message: 24 / F / moooooonwalk :D
Offline
|
Nethermyr wrote:
hey i've watched both versions and they're both good~ i don't get why people can't stop comparing the two :(
i feel like these all sprung out from the ABS-CBN - GMA network rivalry in the philippines..
now about your question.. you've watched hana kimi japan and hana kimi taiwan has a "few different spices" in it, i recommend watching it as well.. there is no better version~ as previously mentioned, they're both good
yah i agree! xD
i've watched both and they have their own diff ways of presenting the manga. and it all started with ABSCBN and GMA rivalry, you're right Nethermyr. ^_________^ PS i'd take the japan as usual. xD
|
3258 cr points
Send Message: 22 / F / Lala Land
Offline
|
joeyQ wrote:
well i think u should watch both...both are equally good i guess but the taiwan version is more stretched while the japanese one is more in speed...both very good lor...if u have to compare i think the best thing out of the two is how well the character of nakatsu/ xiu yi was portray dramatically well by each actors...hahaha really very dramatic and make each scene so funny....
good point you have. both toma and jiro really protrayed nakatsu/xiu yi well! so did ogushun and wu chun as with sano izumi. but for the case of mizuki... well, i thought horikita did better than ella. i personally feel that ella has overdone it. *shrugs*
anyway, hkj and hkt are rather different. but i i only have time to watch one, i would choose hkj. doesnt mean that hkt is bad too.... just that hkj made me laugh much more.
|
1864 cr points
Send Message: F
Offline
|
I really think the Japanese version is way better!~!!!
|
80 cr points
Send Message: 24 / F / Argentina
Offline
|
the manga is still the best D: . both hkj and hkt were made based on the manga, and both are different. there's no point in comparing them -_- i enjoyed both versions a lot :3
|
|
Member
354 cr points
Send Message: 22 / F / over here..guess...
Offline
|
hmm.. for me hana kimi japan is the best... i watched some episodes from hana kimi taiwan & i didn't like it as much as i like the japan version....
|
|
Member
4236 cr points
Send Message: 21 / M
Offline
|
the best 1 to choose??
i think
hana kimi japan 
ahahaha
there's more cute
than the hana kimi taiwan ^_^
and perfectly hairstyle |
|
Member
440 cr points
Send Message: 24 / F
Offline
|
i like tHe japan versiOn mOre~!!!
i wasn't even able tO finish watching hkt..hehe
|
|
Member
2684 cr points
Send Message: 19 / F / Manila,Philippines
Offline
|
I noticed that many people picked the japanese version...but for me they're both good.
I've watched both of them from start till end and i find both of them funny and hilarious...I recommend that you watch both of them to know the difference.I also recommend you to read the manga...as it has a way better ending than the two dramas...and by reading the manga you can see which is better.
For me Hana Kimi Japan focuses more on the funny side of the story and on Mizuki's life in the dorm with BOYS ...while Hana Kimi Taiwan focuses on the romantic side of the story and on Mizuki's life with SANO.
...but both of them are nice to watch... a definite favorite!!!
^^
|
|
Member
2684 cr points
Send Message: 19 / F / Manila,Philippines
Offline
|
Nethermyr wrote:
hey i've watched both versions and they're both good~ i don't get why people can't stop comparing the two :(
i feel like these all sprung out from the ABS-CBN - GMA network rivalry in the philippines..
now about your question.. you've watched hana kimi japan and hana kimi taiwan has a "few different spices" in it, i recommend watching it as well.. there is no better version~ as previously mentioned, they're both good
yeah...I agree they're both really good...and I also agree about the rivalry thing...it's just funny that ABS-CBN put "The original" in their title...and GMA put "The newest and the Best"
...so its like...Hana-Kimi Taiwan "The Original"
...and Hana-Kimi Japan "The Newest and The Best"
...haha...channel rivalry is really funny!\
^^
|
3258 cr points
Send Message: 22 / F / Lala Land
Offline
|
Shu_chan wrote:
Nethermyr wrote:
hey i've watched both versions and they're both good~ i don't get why people can't stop comparing the two :(
i feel like these all sprung out from the ABS-CBN - GMA network rivalry in the philippines..
now about your question.. you've watched hana kimi japan and hana kimi taiwan has a "few different spices" in it, i recommend watching it as well.. there is no better version~ as previously mentioned, they're both good
yeah...I agree they're both really good...and I also agree about the rivalry thing...it's just funny that ABS-CBN put "The original" in their title...and GMA put "The newest and the Best"
...so its like...Hana-Kimi Taiwan "The Original"
...and Hana-Kimi Japan "The Newest and The Best"
...haha...channel rivalry is really funny!\
^^
hana kimi taiwan is the original?! they're kinda deluded huh? for me, the term original means the pioneer. both hkt and hkj cant be termed as original as they borrowed the entire plot from an already existing manga!
to me, hkt is just 'the taiwanese version' and hkj is 'the japanese version'.
period.
|
|
Member
16699 cr points
Send Message: 22 / Sa Puso Mo...
Offline
|
even so...HANA KIMI JAPAN for ME!!!!
|
