Which is Better, Le Chevalier D'Eon or Jigoku Shoujo?
2057 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Posted 11/10/07 , edited 11/10/07
Well, for me like the two of them. That's why I'm asking you guys.

Le Chevalier D'Eon: The story takes place in the 18th Century, on the eve of the French Revolution. It is the era of King Louis XV. Versailles glitters and its full glory and the great river Seine sees beautiful Paris in a ghastly chaos. One day at dawn, a lady's body is found in a casket floating along the Seine. Her name is Lia de Beaumont, and there is a mysterious word on the lid of the casket: PSALMS.

Lia's younger brother, D'Eon de Beaumont, is a member of the secret police and is investigating the mystery of a series of disappearance of young women. Now his sister has become one of the victims. And as D'Eon goes after the case, a history of taboos opens its door...

The story is loosely based on the historical figure Chevalier d'Eon, who lived in the middle of 18th Century pre-revolution France under the reign of Louis XV.

In reality D'eon was a man who claimed to be born female. Later he disgused himself as a woman known as Lia de Beaumont in order to become closer to the queen.

Jigoku Shoujo: Each short story of which the series narrates the suffering of a different individual caused by one or more antagonists. A website known as Jigoku Tsūshin (Hell Correspondence) may only be accessed at midnight by one who harbors a desire for revenge against their tormentor. Should someone submit the name of one they hate, the Jigoku Shōjo (Hell Girl) will offer them a straw doll with a red string wound about its neck. If the string is pulled, she will ferry the recipient of the revenge straightaway to Hell, but on the condition that those who request her intervention will also be sent to hell at the end of their natural lives

During each story, the protagonists' dramas are explained in detail from the start of their grudges, through the escalation of their torment until it becomes unbearable and they resort to accessing the Hell Correspondence website. The contents of the site are only a text: "あなたの怨み、晴らします。 (We will take revenge on your behalf.)", a text box where the grudge's object must be written, and a "送信 (Send)" button. Some time after the post, they are visited by Enma Ai, a young red-eyed girl wearing a traditional sailor school uniform (usually the dark version used only in winter months). She hands them a black straw doll (In the second season, the doll may also be red or dark blue, depending on who turns into it) with a red string tied to its neck, and she tells them that if they want their vengeance to be delivered, they must remove the string from the doll, and their enemies will be immediately taken to Hell. However, a crest-shaped mark will appear on the protagonists' chests, which serves as a constant reminder that once their lives come to an end, they must give compensation for Ai's service by having their own souls also sent to Hell.

10907 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Under someone bed!
Posted 11/10/07
No more vs thread.
78167 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / M / Japan
Posted 11/10/07
Isn't it a little odd to be comparing these to anime?

Anyway, as much as I'd hate to put your effort to waste, we highly discourage versus threads in the forum since they usually generate little discussion from the users. You may post your views, if you like, on the current threads for the said anime.

~ Locked
You must be logged in to post.