First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next  Last
Philippine version of my girl is lousy!!
3277 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Guitar Street.com
Offline
Posted 5/31/08 , edited 5/31/08

nobodysbaby from aznv.tv wrote:
i was never really a fan of filipino dramas coz they drag on sooo much. like, all the shows on abs cbn are so melodramatic and exaggerated, and i dont think the filipino version of my girl would be any different. so nope. not watching it coz i dont think they can remake this great drama to a better one


original post: http://aznv.tv/en/community/vtopic/13410/2/
71 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / manila philippines
Offline
Posted 5/31/08 , edited 5/31/08
HOW COULD A REMAKE POSSIBLY BE CLAIMED TO BE A FILIPINO WORK? your point strays from the main issue. and please do not drag nationalism in this. NOT ALL FILIPINOS WHO WATCH THIS approve of your comments. IN FACT some Filipinos- as many as those who like the series- absolutely hate it. peace
71 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / manila philippines
Offline
Posted 5/31/08
btw

to my countrymen who continuously drag the "Filipino" nation into this mess... why are you so angry? why?

one of the main foundations of our republic is "freedom of speech"
as much as I do think that @freak may have gone overboard, it was really not him who started the whole FILIPINO issue.

so if he made a direct attack at our nation- consider it partly your fault since you brought it up.

and the whole originality thing- AGAIN PEOPLE, a remake is not an original.

i have a scenario for you....
lets say abs FIGURATIVELY spent 10million on this,
what does this say about us?

do we not have enough writers, scribes who can write originals?

this remake arguably can be said to have had been made as an attempt to ride the original "my girl" popularity band waggon. IT's A BUSINESS. I sincerely doubt that ABS had nationalism in their hearts when they decided to make this. so please

I ASK OF YOU. DO NOT anymore, incite the negative comments about our country.
YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN.

Member
295 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / philippines
Offline
Posted 5/31/08

mrdidoy wrote:

btw

to my countrymen who continuously drag the "Filipino" nation into this mess... why are you so angry? why?

one of the main foundations of our republic is "freedom of speech"
as much as I do think that @freak may have gone overboard, it was really not him who started the whole FILIPINO issue.

so if he made a direct attack at our nation- consider it partly your fault since you brought it up.

and the whole originality thing- AGAIN PEOPLE, a remake is not an original.

i have a scenario for you....
lets say abs FIGURATIVELY spent 10million on this,
what does this say about us?

do we not have enough writers, scribes who can write originals?

this remake arguably can be said to have had been made as an attempt to ride the original "my girl" popularity band waggon. IT's A BUSINESS. I sincerely doubt that ABS had nationalism in their hearts when they decided to make this. so please

I ASK OF YOU. DO NOT anymore, incite the negative comments about our country.
YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN.




excuse me mr.didoy!!!do you feel smart?? it looks like your pointing me like im the one who started the whole riot here!
well then...i'ved just said i love filipino works that's because i was raised nationalistic!
LOL!im not draggin it!!!yah I know a remake is a remake..but still i should be proud because kim chiu stars in a drama that hit the korea and other countries...!!!freedom of speech you're saying,then don't mind us here!!loser!!


and I don't post any negative comments.
Member
429 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F
Offline
Posted 5/31/08

kironobu wrote:


chichel_31 wrote:


simplepart wrote:

Lol!!you have no right to stop them!don't give a damn to those people..
Honestly, we watch it everynight...and we were all laughing..If you can't appreciate filipino works then bury your body 6 feet below the ground!!!!!Sorry, I was raised nationalistic!


i agree:))MABUHAY ANG MGA PILIPINO!!!hehehee.

wala na sa topic:))

and yes,people are entitled to have their own opinions,but it just pisses me whenever they say that it doesn't have ORIGINALITY. for crisses sake,it's a remake you guys!hahaha!


I do agree with you... and yea I guess people are just that shallow sometimes...


SUPER SHALLOW!

hahaha:))
Member
429 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F
Offline
Posted 5/31/08
whoa..haha.well,at least people are showing emotions!hahaha.

and oh,mr. creator of this forum,you didn't answer if you're a filipino,well,i'm just asking.

peace y'all.
3830 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / in front of the m...
Offline
Posted 5/31/08 , edited 5/31/08
maganda nmn xa.

-sha tingin ko po wala nman po masama na gwin ung my girl sa phil version at medyo pareho sa korean version. baka gnwa nla un para sa mga taong hinde napanuod nung my girl na korean version. baka lang. peace tayo. opinyun ko lang po eun.

grbe bket dmeng mei ayaw kei kim.? kyahaha. [ako.hnde kasi pnagmamalake ko na kya ng mga pinoy na gwin un kasi pinoy ako. kyahaha.peace po. pumapayag po ba kayo na apihin ng ibang lahi? hah? hah? kyahaha. an drama ko. peace po. opinyun ko lang mga pngsasabi ko] -
Member
429 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F
Offline
Posted 5/31/08

mrdidoy wrote:

btw

to my countrymen who continuously drag the "Filipino" nation into this mess... why are you so angry? why?

one of the main foundations of our republic is "freedom of speech"
as much as I do think that @freak may have gone overboard, it was really not him who started the whole FILIPINO issue.

so if he made a direct attack at our nation- consider it partly your fault since you brought it up.




uhmm,mind you, i think you should re-read the whole thing.the creator of this forum called the guy who said he was raised nationalistic a fool because uhmm,he said he was nationalistic.i mean,an opinion is an opinion,but calling people names just for having some patriotism isn't really fair.

we're not even talking about the series anymore.haha!
52 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / yourface
Offline
Posted 5/31/08 , edited 5/31/08

freakjojo06 wrote:

THREAD
To all you MY GIRL PH LOVERS read this thread.. hehehe
please don't be shock!!!!
http://aznv.tv/en/community/vtopic/13410/2/


Sounds like you're trying to persuade people to go against My Girl PH.
But seriously, why bother showing that link? The people who support this drama aren't going to care about those negative comments. You can't try to change their opinion about it.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

People should stop arguing about whether or not this is better than the original.
FOR GOODNESS SAKE, the drama hasn't even FINISHED.
Don't be so quick to judge something -____-.

Btw, you can't expect other people not to be offended by what you said. I mean you titled your thread "Philippine version of my girl is lousy!!". If you didn't want people to get offended you should have titled it something like, "Your opinions about My Girl PH?"
71 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / manila philippines
Offline
Posted 5/31/08 , edited 5/31/08
do i feel smart? you feel like im pointing at you? nice. you don't post negative comments and yet you specifically called me a loser? did i attack you in any way? No one questions your nationalism. I am as much proud of being filipino as anyone else. read my comments before you call me names. You talk of insults as if you don't dish out any. I never mentioned names nor did I in any way lean towards you as the topic of my comments. and yes I do respect your freedom of speech. where is your respect for mine?

i merely made a remark about how nationalism has been senselessly involved.... so who is the loser? I guess the loser is the person who feels uncomfortably guilty :D

to ms chichel, i think you need to reread my post. its written in the last part.

"so if he made a direct attack at our nation- consider it partly your fault since you brought it up."

and i also stated that i believe that the forum creator HAS GONE over board. PLEASE READ the whole thing as a whole. not by parts.

suggesting that my post aims to neglect the insult to nationalism is not only retarded but also very very careless.

I do not wish for any confrontations.

I merely tried to post my opinion on why i think the issue has been made into something it is not.

and please. calling me names won't help. it just makes you look dumb.
71 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / manila philippines
Offline
Posted 5/31/08
in order to facilitate the end of the nationalistic "ego war" i have a message for the forum creator.



"Haha!!! are you FOOL??? being nationalistic to a CORRUPT NATION... haha.. try to wake up... do you know that in other countries their idea about PHILIPPINES is that it is the POOREST county in asia... idea ok? don't get me wrong in here... if you really don't understand anything about what i'm saying and try to have a meeting with GLORIA ok!!!"

as much as i am with you in expressing your opinions, i really think an apology is needed for the above statement. i mean... i could understand what you are trying to say, still, there is no such need for comments like this. :D

peace to my nation and all of the world

"we are one"




3277 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Guitar Street.com
Offline
Posted 5/31/08
Ok, Im sorry about what I said earlier... but my whole point in this guys is not to look down on Filipino's work... It's really sad watching them remaking a drama series when they have talents to do an original drama series that whole asia will appreciate... or even in other country.. I do believe that filipino writers and producers have a better talent that those writers and producers of the original MY GIRL or other asian DRAMA... so why remake if they could make a better original drama series... their only showing that they love or appreciate korean or other asian's work but they don't consider loving or having confidence in their work.... if ever I offended someone then im sorry...
71 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / manila philippines
Offline
Posted 5/31/08
yes. i agree with you on that one. very well said i guess that explanation would satisfy our "other forum" posters
Member
10192 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F
Offline
Posted 5/31/08

freakjojo06 wrote:

heyhey!!!! did I call myself a Filipino? I really can't remember it...


you are obviously a Filipino,,

1571 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
76 / F / just behind you
Offline
Posted 5/31/08 , edited 5/31/08
This thread is going wild. Obviously, the threadstarter is not making any sense. We should stop posting in here. Anyone who posts after me is worthless.
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.