Remove this ad
First  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  Next  Last
Post Reply Image Favorite Similarities Between D.Gray-Man and Full Metal Alchemist?
277 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
17 / M / Sweden
Image Offline
Posted Jul 23 2008
I dont really think they really are so similair i mean in almost every manga the main character havent got any parents and that they both have crazy hands is true but look at Allens arm and compare it to Eds ITS HUGE beside Allen evolves his to loads of things but Ed just got an Robot arm. So what im trying to say is that you can find similarities between almost all Animes/Mangas. And that the drawings look alot alike mayb is couse someone who worked on FMA works on D. grayman now
Member
5642 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
27 / F / New Zealand
Image Offline
Posted Jul 23 2008
My first instict was that they are different but on much thought Image when you get down to the nitty gritty they do have similarities but its good because when I watch them i don't feel tlike im watching duplicate animes- like some out there (I wont name names Image )
404 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
17 / F / Somewhere between...
Image Offline
Posted Jul 24 2008
And not to mention Komui's strong feelings over lenalee and Maes Hughes's strong feelings over his daughter...
Valent
Level 26 Boy
1398 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
27 / M / Singapore
Image Offline
Posted Jul 24 2008

Catz1297 wrote:

do u think they are simular?
Here are sum things that i think r simular:
Black Order/ Military
messed up right arm
Kanda/ Mustang
both cry when they can't save someone
eats alot
no parents<kinda>

lol do u agree?


Yeah true about the messed up right arm =X
Member
1426 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
14 / F / Canada
Image Offline
Posted Jul 24 2008
lol whoops i forgot ain't it Allen's left arm and Ed's right???
i'm confused in my own forum.... heeheee Image
Member
5642 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
27 / F / New Zealand
Image Offline
Posted Jul 24 2008
lets just say they both have a messed up arm and leave it at that
Member
2548 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
16 / F / Canada
Image Offline
Posted Aug 25 2008, edited Sep 28 2008
haha. When saw Chapter 1 of D. Gray-Man, I shouted "HE LOOKS LIKE ED!" And yeah, even with the major plot differences, I felt like DGM and FMA were similar. They both totally rock!


Oh and, for some reason Komui reminds me of Hughes. I think it's the daughter complex and sister complex thing.
2679 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
29 / F / still on the move
Image Offline
Posted Aug 25 2008
In the beginig yes, I though kid with odd arm like Edward but as the series progresses the story lines are so dissimilar I stopped comparing and watched it for the sake of watching because d.gray man is very, very good
Member
404 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
15 / F / Beijing, China
Image Offline
Posted Aug 26 2008
Some parts.
5150 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
16 / M / LIR I-I3/-\RT&S{}uI_
Image Offline
Posted Aug 26 2008
sorta...but most anime characters eat alot ex:goku,luffy,naruto etc..
Member
195 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
22 / M / Mexico
Image Offline
Posted Aug 26 2008
lol i didn't realized before... but they are, but i think d.gray man is better
123 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
21
Image Offline
Posted Aug 31 2008
I suppose in various ways that DGM and FMA does have its similarities, but I think all or the majority of animes have their own similarities in ways--though--they still have their own differences as well.
Member
magicalgirlj's Avatar
Level 11 Chibi Unisex Avatar
17040 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
19 / F / wherever the Vari...
Image Offline
Posted Sep 1 2008, edited Sep 1 2008
ed, allen, and al are like brothers
2485 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
14 / F / Home ^^
Image Offline
Posted Sep 1 2008
Kanda/ Mustang?? wonder how kanda's fans will react hahas

Moimy wrote:

Also over-reacts when called short?

LOL AGREED

105 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
19 / F / earth
Image Offline
Posted Sep 2 2008, edited Sep 2 2008
Some parts are similar....... Image
But, this is the kind of thing you find in ALOT of good anime/manga, so its not a big deal. Image

Plus, even with the similarities between them, they both have kick-ass plot lines and concepts that are completely different. Image

So, again, the similarities don't matter at all since both mangas/animes are different enough in their own ways and AREN'T complete rip-offs of the each other.
First  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post!