First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
The Tower of DRUAGA -the Aegis of URUK
1454 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Hinamizawa
Offline
Posted 6/13/08 , edited 6/13/08

LeapofFateAMV wrote:


Promathia19 wrote:


LeapofFateAMV wrote:


Promathia19 wrote:


LeapofFateAMV wrote:


Promathia19 wrote:



its not a duplicate. it may have the same topic name, but the subject being asked is different. the other topic is the anime in general, this is more specific


You can apply this same statement for that thread therefore this thread is not needed.
Also if this kind of thread is allowed than there would be many more unneeded threads like this.


unless u can put ALL the different types of subjects in the 1st post or in the title, how would one know what the question is? mayb ud have time to browse through all the pages to find the new question being asked, but u know that a lot of ppl wont try to. its much easier just to just make a new one. this is no duplicate thread since the question is not an exact copy of the other thread, its just the anime thats involved


Those people that are lazy to actually browse through a thread that is already in use should not be able to make another thread[not saying that the person who made this thread is lazy]. Also there are a lot of lazy people and maybe a few people can have the same question and just make a thread without using the search button, therefore compiling into many duplicate threads. That is why it is easier to just use the thread that BlaBla gave.


then report those threads. since this isnt really a duplicate, theres really nothing to report


Can you stop being ignorant of the fact that this is a duplicate thread? I have given you sufficient evidence that this thread is a duplicate and not needed.

I guess an example is needed.

Lets say I was talking about Code Geass S2 and when the show reaches 12 episodes, I post a thread about what you think about it?
There is already a Code Geass S2 thread and therefore it is a duplicate because I can easily just say my opinion on the matter without releasing a subtopic about the show.
LOL
Wow, your logic is horriable! If a mod actually does something about this then I am going to laugh! No mod is stupid enough to have that logic go through their head.
It is because it is the second to final, and final episodes that makes this thread different, and gives people a place to chat about it in general, because they may not get anyone on the original thread.
520 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / California
Offline
Posted 6/13/08 , edited 6/13/08

LeapofFateAMV wrote:

Can you stop being ignorant of the fact that this is a duplicate thread? I have given you sufficient evidence that this thread is a duplicate and not needed.

I guess an example is needed.

Lets say I was talking about Code Geass S2 and when the show reaches 12 episodes, I post a thread about what you think about it?
There is already a Code Geass S2 thread and therefore it is a duplicate because I can easily just say my opinion on the matter without releasing a subtopic about the show.


just because that theres a thread with the same anime name DOES NOT make it a duplicate thread.

1) u post something about Code Geass S2 and its about what u thought about the whole series. Then 2) another person makes a thread about the same anime, Code Geass S2, and makes the post "Who is your favorite character in CG S2?" Does that make this thread a duplicate? no, it doesnt because its a completely different question from the one before.

and then theres 3) someone who makes a thread about CG S2, "What might happen in the next episode?" thats not a duplicate of either of the 2 previous topics. One is an overall topic, one is a favorite topic, and one is a "what might happen since it hasnt happened yet" (or next season) topic.


du·pli·cate adj. ˈduplɪkɪt, ˈdyu-; v. ˈduplɪˌkeɪt
–noun. a copy exactly like an original.


all three of the topics i just gave is not an exact copy of the original.
520 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / California
Offline
Posted 6/13/08

LeapofFateAMV wrote:

So you are saying that every second to last episode of an anime has to have a sub forum to discuss the matter?
Please answer that question because it seems like you lack the knowledge to do so.
You are just being ignorant of the fact that your thread is a duplicate and will be locked.

Come back when you fully comprehend what a duplicate thread is.


and what happens if it doesnt get locked? what will u say/do then?
1454 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Hinamizawa
Offline
Posted 6/13/08 , edited 6/13/08
Thank you Promahia.
I just did not know how to get it through to those people. ( I am not the sharpest knife in the kitchen right now. I Got too little sleep, and I can not go back to sleep because my friends stopped by and we all started drinking lots of Soda/pop/soda pop and energy drinks and played smash brothers for hours. )
104101 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / This Dying World
Online
Posted 6/13/08

LeapofFateAMV wrote:


jakun_kenpachi wrote:


That is about the anime overall, this is about after episode 11, and a discussion on up coming episode 12. This is not about the over all anime.


I believe both sentence contradicted each other.


lmao how can some1 say that without realizing it???
1454 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Hinamizawa
Offline
Posted 6/13/08
This is not just what happens in the next episode. It is the current, and discussion on the anime based off seeing episode 11.
Plus most of the time "What might happen in the next episode" threads have other "What might happen in the next episode" of the same anime.
If a mod locks this thread I will be shocked and then laugh.
1454 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Hinamizawa
Offline
Posted 6/13/08

LeapofFateAMV wrote:


AnimeKami wrote:


LeapofFateAMV wrote:


jakun_kenpachi wrote:


That is about the anime overall, this is about after episode 11, and a discussion on up coming episode 12. This is not about the over all anime.


I believe both sentence contradicted each other.


lmao how can some1 say that without realizing it???


I have no idea I:

How do I contridict myself?
I am saying that the topic linked is about the overall anime, and this is not. So how does is contridict?
2653 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / I don't know
Offline
Posted 6/13/08 , edited 6/13/08
Wow, this thread is soon going to turn in to a flame war.

I noticed and........
Not a duplicate sorry...
34529 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
36 / F / Undisclosed Location
Offline
Posted 6/13/08
Duplicate as reported.

Locked
First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.