First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next  Last
a popular anime is also a good one?
429 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / New York
Offline
Posted 7/4/08

DemonWithin912 wrote:

lol?

Popularity does not show how good an anime is.

|:

Example
Let us compare it to music.

Let us say a band that is popular, let's say the Jonas Brothers.
The Jonas Brothers are popular but they make shitty music.


That is how anime is

Damn Bill for taking my example >:3


you both took my examples, and im too busy to come up with a third.
basically, popular anime are usually horrible but can be good(occasionally)
14835 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / California
Offline
Posted 7/4/08

angelpuzz56 wrote:


DemonWithin912 wrote:


angelpuzz56 wrote:


DemonWithin912 wrote:

lol?

Popularity does not show how good an anime is.

|:

Example
Let us compare it to music.

Let us say a band that is popular, let's say the Jonas Brothers.
The Jonas Brothers are popular but they make shitty music.


That is how anime is

Damn Bill for taking my example >:3


the jonas brothers do not hav shitty music u just dont hav taste in music


and it depends on the anime

lol I don't have taste in music?

Please, I bet you couldn't name a single decent band |:

You probably likez them Linkinz Parkz and MCR'zzz

Jonas Brothers is just another pop boy band to aim for teen girls |:

They don't make music.




Ok maybe I do like Linkin Park

But Jonas Brothers are hot and their music is good and if their music did suck why do so many ppl go to ther concerts and why do so many ppl listen to their music

Oh boy they are hawt? Ohz really!
Music is about the atmosphere and lyrics, not based on looks.

The Jonas Brothers lyrics are shitty and pretty much sing about the same things.

Popularity does not make the band good.

Let us give an example:
Naruto is a crazy popular anime with many fans. Naruto's just plain sucks but yet it is popular?

Popularity ≠ Good

Checkmate
25644 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M
Offline
Posted 7/4/08 , edited 7/4/08
This is an impeded fallace or verminous assumption.Its basically like saying every apple tastes like a good apple when theirs always a centralized difference between each apple.
2830 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / M / Stargazing at noon
Offline
Posted 7/4/08

darkstarrose wrote:

Well, what do you think? Is a popular anime also good?I measn, most of the popular ones are like this because of ecchi , sf stuff.But maybe less popular anime have more detailes, the graphic is better, the characters feelings are well explained.I don't say there are not good popular anime( i saw a lot of them)...but i wonder.
For example, i think "ef~a tale of memories~" is very good and it is not that popular..
tell me what you think!


I completely agree with you. I really like ef- a tale of memories

3882 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F
Offline
Posted 7/4/08
when did it become about music? i thought the topic's anime ^^

i guess its just a difference between what you like and how the story goes

Example the big three:
I only watched several Naruto eps, it was okay but i'm not a fan and i stopped watching.
Bleach started interesting, then got to fillers, then a boring arc, but still has some good eps.
I didnt even start on one-piece, i have a feeling i won't like it but i hvnt tried soo

its just that a popular anime means a larger percentage of the people that watched it liked it so the chance that you would like it too is higher, meaning you would say its a "good anime" too.
14952 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / M / Canada
Offline
Posted 7/4/08
it all depends on the person
Posted 7/4/08

NeonGenesis wrote:


darkstarrose wrote:

Well, what do you think? Is a popular anime also good?I measn, most of the popular ones are like this because of ecchi , sf stuff.But maybe less popular anime have more detailes, the graphic is better, the characters feelings are well explained.I don't say there are not good popular anime( i saw a lot of them)...but i wonder.
For example, i think "ef~a tale of memories~" is very good and it is not that popular..
tell me what you think!


I completely agree with you. I really like ef- a tale of memories



x2
36029 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M
Offline
Posted 7/4/08
no popularity means prett much nothing. 1 example that proves this is Naruto. its popularity only shows how stupid some ppl are
3399 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
20 / F / turn around >=3
Offline
Posted 7/4/08
I never learnt 2 like naruto but i like da yaoi version <3 so overrated anime are not always good i really liked d.grayman though ^-^
1451 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / someplace somewhere
Offline
Posted 7/4/08
not really
591 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / ---
Offline
Posted 7/4/08
Umm no? Preference being a key issue. (Note: Examples may not be popular anime)

Sailor Moon: I doubt too many guys would love the show even if it were popular.... unless they're drooling during the transformation scenes....
One Piece: Okay some love it, others can't stand the art. Just shows some prefer nice clean animation.
Ghost In The Shell: I can't imagine a 10 year old jumping up and down over that show. While a more mature person may enjoy it more.
Pokemon/Digimon/Naruto etc: Kiddy shows! Same as Ghost In The Shell but in reverse kids(yes) older audiences(no)
Higurashi No Naku Koro Ni: Umm "The following program may show some scenes that are disturbing to some..... or many viewers" :P
I loved it though

One major factor of preference is the Genre. While I'm open to most Genres, some may think comedic anime's are fantastic, others may avoid it as it's a waste of time.
363 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / F / not given
Offline
Posted 7/5/08

DemonWithin912 wrote:


angelpuzz56 wrote:


DemonWithin912 wrote:


angelpuzz56 wrote:


DemonWithin912 wrote:

lol?

Popularity does not show how good an anime is.

|:

Example
Let us compare it to music.

Let us say a band that is popular, let's say the Jonas Brothers.
The Jonas Brothers are popular but they make shitty music.


That is how anime is

Damn Bill for taking my example >:3


the jonas brothers do not hav shitty music u just dont hav taste in music


and it depends on the anime

lol I don't have taste in music?

Please, I bet you couldn't name a single decent band |:

You probably likez them Linkinz Parkz and MCR'zzz

Jonas Brothers is just another pop boy band to aim for teen girls |:

They don't make music.




Ok maybe I do like Linkin Park

But Jonas Brothers are hot and their music is good and if their music did suck why do so many ppl go to ther concerts and why do so many ppl listen to their music

Oh boy they are hawt? Ohz really!
Music is about the atmosphere and lyrics, not based on looks.

The Jonas Brothers lyrics are shitty and pretty much sing about the same things.

Popularity does not make the band good.

Let us give an example:
Naruto is a crazy popular anime with many fans. Naruto's just plain sucks but yet it is popular?

Popularity ≠ Good

Checkmate


the jonas brothers do not sing about the same things and if u actually listened to their music u would kno but i guess u dont and naruto does suck but thats ur opinion and no one asked for it and sum ppl mite actuallly like naruto and the ppl who like naruto watches naruto and thus makes it popular

its ur opinion that anime that are popular are not good but that doesnt mean uther ppl think its not good

like vampire knight for instance, its popular and its good and alota ppl watch it which makes it popular and y do ppl watch that anime? Its because its good.

An anime cannot become popular if little ppl watch it and onli wen little ppl watch that anime is wen a few ppl like it but wen alota ppl watch that anime it means alota ppl like it and when ppl like the anime it means that the ppl think its good

I prove my point.
12371 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / i dont know
Offline
Posted 7/5/08

DemonWithin912 wrote:

lol?

Popularity does not show how good an anime is.

|:

Example
Let us compare it to music.

Let us say a band that is popular, let's say the Jonas Brothers.
The Jonas Brothers are popular but they make shitty music.


That is how anime is

Damn Bill for taking my example >:3

LOLZ XD so true so true
2659 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / Lucky Land 13
Offline
Posted 7/5/08
fma, death note, vampire knight and d. gray man are all really good popular animes ^.^
5678 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / nyc
Offline
Posted 7/5/08
not necessarily...hype can get carried away at times.
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.