Post Reply Did You Agree With The Ending?
Creator
3012 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / United States
Offline
Posted 7/18/08 , edited 7/18/08
I think that Sekai was a little harsh to go that far and kill Makoto. But, he did deserve some kind of punishment. Not death though. That was a little too extreme for me.

Member
5386 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / philippines, para...
Offline
Posted 8/4/08
I like the part when he died since he deserve it for messing up with ever girl in the story... but i didn't like that sekai died... i'm so hate makoto i wish katsura just help killing him since there no point loving that pervert ^.^
Creator
3012 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / United States
Offline
Posted 8/5/08

jajagegesan wrote:

I like the part when he died since he deserve it for messing up with ever girl in the story... but i didn't like that sekai died... i'm so hate makoto i wish katsura just help killing him since there no point loving that pervert ^.^


Sekai deserved to die as well since she lied and she killed Makoto. Katsura was pretty innocent through the whole anime except at the end. So, she never really deserved for anything bad to happen to her.
Member
5386 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / philippines, para...
Offline
Posted 8/5/08 , edited 8/5/08

marmaladegirl09 wrote:


jajagegesan wrote:

I like the part when he died since he deserve it for messing up with ever girl in the story... but i didn't like that sekai died... i'm so hate makoto i wish katsura just help killing him since there no point loving that pervert ^.^


Sekai deserved to die as well since she lied and she killed Makoto. Katsura was pretty innocent through the whole anime except at the end. So, she never really deserved for anything bad to happen to her.


Yah she did a lot of bad stuff, but i still hate makoto if he was any better he wouldn't have gone far if he loved katsura he should have not been tempted to do more with sekai after the practice, and if he did love sekai he should have broke properly because it was katsura who was keep hanging and believing that it was all a lie.
Sekai would have not been his cheating partner if he didn't go to her instead of katsura in ep 5 (and what he said to katsura in ep 3 piss me off >.<)... dang it i hate makoto more than any of the other characters so i only wanted him the one to die... they had better lives if he was out of the picture... oh man i went a little far sorry i really just hate makoto
Member
35 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / wherever you are
Offline
Posted 8/6/08
I think both Makoto's and Sekai's deaths were justified. All could have been avoided if Sekai just came out to him before trying to hook him up with Kotonoha. In the end Sekai introduced him to the world of adultery (hence her death) and Makoto succumbed to that world (hence his death). Can't help but think that Kotonoha deserved better.
Member
374 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / calgary, canada
Offline
Posted 8/16/08

Yah she did a lot of bad stuff, but i still hate makoto if he was any better he wouldn't have gone far if he loved katsura he should have not been tempted to do more with sekai after the practice, and if he did love sekai he should have broke properly because it was katsura who was keep hanging and believing that it was all a lie.
Sekai would have not been his cheating partner if he didn't go to her instead of katsura in ep 5 (and what he said to katsura in ep 3 piss me off >.<)... dang it i hate makoto more than any of the other characters so i only wanted him the one to die... they had better lives if he was out of the picture... oh man i went a little far sorry i really just hate makoto :sweatingbullets:


it was sekai's fault why makoto wants more.. if it wasn't because of the practices.. makoto would be contented of katsura.. i want only sekai to die.. it was all his fault!!
Member
5386 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / philippines, para...
Offline
Posted 8/17/08

theresa_naruto-addict wrote:


Yah she did a lot of bad stuff, but i still hate makoto if he was any better he wouldn't have gone far if he loved katsura he should have not been tempted to do more with sekai after the practice, and if he did love sekai he should have broke properly because it was katsura who was keep hanging and believing that it was all a lie.
Sekai would have not been his cheating partner if he didn't go to her instead of katsura in ep 5 (and what he said to katsura in ep 3 piss me off >.<)... dang it i hate makoto more than any of the other characters so i only wanted him the one to die... they had better lives if he was out of the picture... oh man i went a little far sorry i really just hate makoto :sweatingbullets:


it was sekai's fault why makoto wants more.. if it wasn't because of the practices.. makoto would be contented of katsura.. i want only sekai to die.. it was all his fault!!


well all the characters has there up and downs actually only makoto and sekai with what they did... i started to hate him at ep 3 when he said "that being around with kotonoha was tiring." what the heck wrong with you makoto... whats tiring being with the person you loved and when he advance to kotonoha even after seeing that she was a not good with guys (bec of how the guys treat her) and yet that perv.... just because kotonoha can't give him what he wants after seeing sekai willing give his desire, he lied to kotonoha even if sekai was saying "lets tell her" or "I feel bad lets stop already" but no i want you sekai, making her cling to believing that she is loved and that katsura was no one in his life anymore... i know sekai was wrong for doing and that she deserve to be punish too but makoto is still the worst for wrecking all those girls lives >.<

Member
1082 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26
Offline
Posted 8/18/08
it's true that sekai is at fault, but she's only the spark that starts things off. even if sekai didn't "confuse" makoto, otome would have tried to have sex with him during the festival anyway. either way makoto would have been introduced to the adult world with or without sekai's help. we could see in the first few episodes when he was still innocent that he prefer physical contact. so there is no question that he will accept otome's tribute. and if it goes completely according to the story line otome's friends would try to "see how good he is" after the part with the hidden camera. one way or another kotonoha, and maybe sekai too, would end up getting hurt since rumors like that spread quickly. if i were to use a example sekai would be the one who starts a spark in the garage, makoto would be the one that's stacking explosives knowing that it's dangerous. so who's more at fault?
Member
612 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F
Offline
Posted 8/21/08
Trough watching this anime the first I thougt that poor Katsura, shes so shy, than I was realy, realy thinking that Seaikai is the poor one, and than the Katsura again, than Seikai and than everybody who was in this anime and than everybody who watched it and made it...
Yet I still realy hate Makoto, but the end shouldnt be this way...Death is not the answer....I think Seikai overeacted and killed Makoto, but than Katsura was seeing dead makoto she get pathetic, like a live dead zombie or something, and than she understand that Seikais at faulth and killed her... And again I admit thatI hate Makoto, because he is, I mean he was a big sex maniac and a realy big pervert, and playboy....But they all will get mach more stuff like that in the next life, eaven Katsura, couse she killed Seikai in the end.....I realy feel sorry for the person who made this anime and imagened all this, I realy do, I think he or she is in big deppresion, normal human beeing couldnt make that in mind...soo she or he should see a doctor.... I am not pshylogical worker or something, just a 13 year old girl who got a way to think of life in general...
Member
30 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 8/28/08
If im makoto i should pick both sekai and katsura i'll make them happy and share my room to them both..sex is part of love u know....
Member
4430 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / M / somewhere
Offline
Posted 10/10/08
itou and sekai had it coming...
Member
58 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / Philippines
Offline
Posted 9/20/09
I DON'T THINK MAKOTO DESERVES DEATH I'D JUST PREFER SEKAI TO BE KILLED CUZ SEKAI REALLY DESERVES IT
You must be logged in to post.