First  Prev  1  2  3  4  Next  Last
do you like taiwanese or jap version?
Posted 9/8/08
I prefered the Japanese version than this one due to the fact that Ella and Jiro acted a little too extreme. I'm not saying I don't like them it's just that the acting in this drama wasn't all that to great.
689 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / F
Offline
Posted 9/15/08 , edited 9/15/08
Actually I loved Jiro's acting in this drama..I think if I was feeling the way he felt, I would probably act like that. However both version are good. I think there are better actors and actress in the Taiwanese version...but the storyline for the Japanese version is a lot better...The Taiwanese version is also funnier to me...and I know it's one of the drama that I will want to watch again..Although the Japanese version was good, I don't think I will rewatch it again.
Member
420 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / CeBu,pHiLiPpiNeS!
Offline
Posted 9/16/08
i'LL gO fOr TAiWAN!!!
100 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / In front of my co...
Offline
Posted 9/18/08
I watched the Japanese version, then read the manga, then watched the Taiwanese version.
In support of the Taiwanese version:
-I can understand some of it
- It followed the manga more closely
-WU CHUNNN!!!
-Mizuki... Ahh... ReiXi actually looked like a guy


In support of the Japanese version:
-The ending.
-The names are the same!!! Sano, Ashiya, Nakatsu, Umeda, ... all in theJap version and manga - Taiwan changed their names.
- I liked it that Sano saved Ashiya instead of his coach or friend.
- Umeda loks better with short hair
-The deviations from the maga were cute and interesting
-I was so crazed after finishing it that I downloaded some of the music, including BACKGROUND MUSIC of all things. I still listen to it.
-I watched this because of my cousin. The Taiwanese versionI watched because I had to download the whole OST to get Zen me Ban by S.H.E and couldn't bear to have a soundtrack for something I didn't watch, and I also wanted to watch it because the Japanese version was so good, I wanted MORE!

I like the Japanese verson better. The Taiwanese version isn't bad or anything. I just like the Japanese version better.
Member
455 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / philippines
Offline
Posted 9/20/08
i like hk taiwan because the characters when one exaggerate a certain scene it complements the other actor or actress.. for me the Japanese version is cute also .. but i don't like the casting for me i don't find them energizing .. but this is just my personal opinion ..!!
74 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Bulgaria
Offline
Posted 9/24/08
JAPANESE VERSION but TW is also good
990 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / mydreamland
Offline
Posted 9/29/08
prefer the japanese version. the incidents are funnier than the taiwanese version.actors and actresses more good looking.i tink taiwanese is only the facial expressions and movements funny but nt the incident.
JAPANESE VERSION ALL THE WAY!!
278 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / Kono chiisana mac...
Offline
Posted 9/29/08 , edited 9/29/08
I choose HanaKimi Japanese ver.!!

da real ikemen -good looking guys- paradise! especially nakatsu and nanba-senpai!
*ah, nose bleeding*
(although i don't like shun as sano)

and i think HKJ is funnier than HKT.
35 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / Malaysia truly As...
Offline
Posted 9/30/08
I thought both were great in their own way. If there was some way to fuse the two it'd be awesome!!!! I like Nakatsu from J more than T. But I really prefer Wu Chun over Oguri. If Maki looked a little more like a guy she'd be even better at the role and if Ella looked a little more like a girl then she'd be perfect too lol! So no particular pref there

Acting in J was better as it wasn't too OVERLY exaggerated like T. However T grows on you after a while. You start liking the characters even after you vow not to XD.

So I kinda like both
4154 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / New York
Offline
Posted 10/9/08
TW DRAMA!! & i tried watching two episodes of jp version... ;o

Why?
-Cause TW version has ALL the hot & cute guys. I mean seriously, all of them are HOT! (Jiro, Wu Chun, Danson) Cute; The guy that's cute, the spirit guy, etc.
-It's more bright and colorful..I'm a colorful person, so I like colorful things better
-Even the poster is better...I mean, just by judging the poster, I'd watch TW version first. :P
-CHUNELLA scenes..also CHUNJIRO scenes. haha. Ella so cute even though she was a little overexaggerated..;]
-Just..all the episodes made me laugh out loud. :D
-& when all the boys gather in one room & you know..chat? haha

JP verrsion isn't bad...
-Nakatsu is hot & funny!! xD
-Their acting are better
-Maki is prettier than Ella..but doesn't look like a boy x.x
Member
570 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / mikafanclub.com
Offline
Posted 10/9/08
I liked the Taiwan version better. I watched a couple episodes of the Japan, but then I started watching the Taiwan one. I didn't really like it at all when I first saw it. I didn't like Ella. but she grew on me and I realized she was pretty much the only reason that I didn't like it. I also think that the Taiwan one follows the manga way better and I love the manga! It's my favourite! I also like the Taiwanese guys. The only thing that bugs me are the names.
Posted 10/10/08
Reasons that Hana Kimi Japan Rocked!!!:
1. Nakatsu's "I'm not a homo dance"
2. Maki's just too cute
3. Nakatsu's nosebleeds and Mizuki moments
4. The part where Sano saved Mizuki rather than his manager or something like that...
5. The part where Sano was drunk and kissed almost everybody (even Ikuta Toma + the guy who played Kagurazaka! (ps. don't know how to spell his name)
6. It's way funnier
7. The lie detector (poor Nakatsu...) it was so friggin' hilarious
8. The acting was awesome
9. Even through the hilariousness, there were still some serious SanoxMizuki and NakatsuxMizuki moments.
10. It left such a good impression to me that I'm counting down the time the special comes out.
11. They stuck to the original names.
12. There's much much more, but I'm too lazy to name them all...

Well as you can see, I'm a HKJ fan. But I really liked the Taiwan ver. cause they actually acted the true story and it was pretty funny too. Although sometimes there acting was slightly extreme for me (not in a good way for me). So yep, go Hana Kimi Japan!
291 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F
Offline
Posted 10/11/08
I LOVE BOTH OF THEM! ONE IS FUNNIER(JAPANESE) AND ONE HAS CUTE BOYS(JIRO)!
205 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / F / that little dot i...
Offline
Posted 10/15/08
i like the taiwanese version cuz its a bit more realistic.
1010 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / Hawaii
Offline
Posted 10/23/08
Hana Kimi Taiwan!
Much more enjoyable, it's HILARIOUS, and ALL the guys are hot!
The Japanese version has an ugly lead and other guys I prefer to never look at without having my eyes burned.
In Hana Kimi Taiwan, Jiro Wang and Wu Chun two of the hottest guys in Asia! <333
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.