First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
Post Reply Episode 24 of clannad *READ BEFORE POSTING*
Member
24494 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Sweden
Offline
Posted 7/20/08
To those people who are saying "i didn't like it" "i want Nagisa and Tomoya together" "wut is dis? why is it Tomoyo and Tomoya?"

Read this Post and you will understand why they made an OVA for Tomoyo and Tomoya

Ok lets start here, i've seen alot of topics at the forums now regarding Episode 24 of clannad (Tomoyo edition) what i want to say is that it's actually continuing from how the first clannad game ends (not the tomoyo game), about how Tomoya and Tomoyo get's together.

But for now i'm going to quote some post's to clear this up that this is the CONTINUATION from the Tomoyo Route in the Clannad Game. Not some "alternative" ending or such thing. Or actually it COULD be an alternative ending but! as i've said, it is an continue from how the game ends at the Tomoyo Route.


The so-called Episode 24 of CLANNAD (TV), which came as an OVA along with the CLANNAD DVDs, is based on the Tomoyo route in the game, and accordingly depicts an alternative CLANNADverse where Tomoya hooks up with Sakagami Tomoyo. Therefore, it has little in relation to the main Nagisa storyline which was portrayed in the rest of the series, but it provides a nice little insight into a ‘what-if’ where Tomoyo was the main heroine, and also gives a clue as to why the Tomoyo arc in the main series was so abruptly cut off. Although being a standard 1-episode OVA lasting only 30 minutes means that much of the Tomoyo story has been subjected to a hackjob by necessity, the result is still as decent as it goes, and shows us a side of Tomoyo that those of us who haven’t played the game didn’t know existed.

CLANNAD (TV), Another World (Tomoyo Chapter).





does this somewhat follow the Tomoyo ~It's a Wonderful Life~ story?


No. This episode is based on the Tomoyo Arc in the Clannad story. Tomoyo After follows on from this.



Just watched it. Good work again, Kyoto. Now facial animation is really amazing and shows more real feelings and some small feats like waving hairs adds more feelings in dialogs, you can't miss this in the last dialogue, for example. Plot is good and close to the game, but really short. Short enough. Their relations already started at the beginning of this episode and this is a pity, I expected their first contacts, meetings and relations. The main problem here is a single episode. Only 25 minutes... Because of this 25 minutes you can actually call this episode as summary and nothing more. I think, that people, who played game, should really love this, because they already know their full story, but as for others - they maybe will not like some things or will not understand some small feats here. Ah, btw, thanks a lot for this amazing soundtrack, in this 25 minutes you will hear enough outstanding tracks like Shionari II, Yukinohara and even Ana ! Kyoto, thanks again. And some more special thanks for Tomoyo's and Tomoya's last dialog. It's full and very close to the game, they tryed fully show it in this episode. One of the best dialogues in "Tomoyo's route". Now I hope for Tomoyo After...

9/10.

Well, now let's wait for Clannad AS.


And this post might be retarded/make no sense (feel free to report it if you want) but i made this post out of frustration.
That's all i have to say.
Posted 7/20/08
Wouldn't it have been more reasonable to have just posted this in any of the other Clannad ep 24 threads? Or better yet, the general Clannad thread itself?
Member
36190 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / cloud 9
Offline
Posted 7/20/08
thnx for that ^^
Posted 7/20/08
omygawd, too much reading, I'm getting dizzy!!!!!!
Member
24494 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Sweden
Offline
Posted 7/20/08

Daharkas wrote:

Wouldn't it have been more reasonable to have just posted this in any of the other Clannad ep 24 threads? Or better yet, the general Clannad thread itself?


yes it would, this was my bad, it's actually the wrong forum, so i will report my self and ask the moderators to move this to the Clannad forum
1613 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Canada
Offline
Posted 7/20/08 , edited 7/20/08
There IS a TomoyaxTomoyo manga out there. I remember reading it...it was so sad ;_;
Member
24494 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Sweden
Offline
Posted 7/20/08

seacucumber_otome wrote:

There IS a TomoyaxTomoya manga out there. I remember reading it...it was so sad ;_;


yeah, the Tomoyo X Tomoya is very sad/happy, but the Nagisa arc is just waaaaaaaaaaay sadder, you will know it when the After Story gets out.
1613 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Canada
Offline
Posted 7/20/08

darkoff wrote:


seacucumber_otome wrote:

There IS a TomoyaxTomoya manga out there. I remember reading it...it was so sad ;_;


yeah, the Tomoyo X Tomoya is very sad/happy, but the Nagisa arc is just waaaaaaaaaaay sadder, you will know it when the After Story gets out.


Yeah, I remember reading about it on Wikipedia. So sad....
Can't wait for After Story though; want to see it in anime form! ^_^
Member
24494 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Sweden
Offline
Posted 7/20/08

seacucumber_otome wrote:


darkoff wrote:


seacucumber_otome wrote:

There IS a TomoyaxTomoya manga out there. I remember reading it...it was so sad ;_;


yeah, the Tomoyo X Tomoya is very sad/happy, but the Nagisa arc is just waaaaaaaaaaay sadder, you will know it when the After Story gets out.


Yeah, I remember reading about it on Wikipedia. So sad....
Can't wait for After Story though; want to see it in anime form! ^_^


it will come out this fall
Member
24494 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Sweden
Offline
Posted 7/20/08

GintokiSakata wrote:


darkoff wrote:


seacucumber_otome wrote:


darkoff wrote:


seacucumber_otome wrote:

There IS a TomoyaxTomoya manga out there. I remember reading it...it was so sad ;_;


yeah, the Tomoyo X Tomoya is very sad/happy, but the Nagisa arc is just waaaaaaaaaaay sadder, you will know it when the After Story gets out.


Yeah, I remember reading about it on Wikipedia. So sad....
Can't wait for After Story though; want to see it in anime form! ^_^


it will come out this fall ;)


When that comes, there will be less Nagisa haters :O
Probably >.>


it definetly will, because the Nagisa route is just so... i cant even say it in words...
33 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24
Offline
Posted 7/20/08
wtf nagisa is the best..
Member
5605 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / uhhh total memory...
Offline
Posted 7/20/08

darkoff wrote:

To those people who are saying "i didn't like it" "i want Nagisa and Tomoya together" "wut is dis? why is it Tomoyo and Tomoya?"

Read this Post and you will understand why they made an OVA for Tomoyo and Tomoya

Ok lets start here, i've seen alot of topics at the forums now regarding Episode 24 of clannad (Tomoyo edition) what i want to say is that it's actually continuing from how the first clannad game ends (not the tomoyo game), about how Tomoya and Tomoyo get's together.

But for now i'm going to quote some post's to clear this up that this is the CONTINUATION from the Tomoyo Route in the Clannad Game. Not some "alternative" ending or such thing. Or actually it COULD be an alternative ending but! as i've said, it is an continue from how the game ends at the Tomoyo Route.


The so-called Episode 24 of CLANNAD (TV), which came as an OVA along with the CLANNAD DVDs, is based on the Tomoyo route in the game, and accordingly depicts an alternative CLANNADverse where Tomoya hooks up with Sakagami Tomoyo. Therefore, it has little in relation to the main Nagisa storyline which was portrayed in the rest of the series, but it provides a nice little insight into a ‘what-if’ where Tomoyo was the main heroine, and also gives a clue as to why the Tomoyo arc in the main series was so abruptly cut off. Although being a standard 1-episode OVA lasting only 30 minutes means that much of the Tomoyo story has been subjected to a hackjob by necessity, the result is still as decent as it goes, and shows us a side of Tomoyo that those of us who haven’t played the game didn’t know existed.

CLANNAD (TV), Another World (Tomoyo Chapter).





does this somewhat follow the Tomoyo ~It's a Wonderful Life~ story?


No. This episode is based on the Tomoyo Arc in the Clannad story. Tomoyo After follows on from this.



Just watched it. Good work again, Kyoto. Now facial animation is really amazing and shows more real feelings and some small feats like waving hairs adds more feelings in dialogs, you can't miss this in the last dialogue, for example. Plot is good and close to the game, but really short. Short enough. Their relations already started at the beginning of this episode and this is a pity, I expected their first contacts, meetings and relations. The main problem here is a single episode. Only 25 minutes... Because of this 25 minutes you can actually call this episode as summary and nothing more. I think, that people, who played game, should really love this, because they already know their full story, but as for others - they maybe will not like some things or will not understand some small feats here. Ah, btw, thanks a lot for this amazing soundtrack, in this 25 minutes you will hear enough outstanding tracks like Shionari II, Yukinohara and even Ana ! Kyoto, thanks again. And some more special thanks for Tomoyo's and Tomoya's last dialog. It's full and very close to the game, they tryed fully show it in this episode. One of the best dialogues in "Tomoyo's route". Now I hope for Tomoyo After...

9/10.

Well, now let's wait for Clannad AS.


And this post might be retarded/make no sense (feel free to report it if you want) but i made this post out of frustration.
That's all i have to say.


so this isnt the really ending right.... cuase if so i would be very sad... T.T.... and the after story is about nagsai and tomoyo... right?? sorry for a the question i am really confused...
Member
24494 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Sweden
Offline
Posted 7/20/08

Nemo_kid wrote:


darkoff wrote:

To those people who are saying "i didn't like it" "i want Nagisa and Tomoya together" "wut is dis? why is it Tomoyo and Tomoya?"

Read this Post and you will understand why they made an OVA for Tomoyo and Tomoya

Ok lets start here, i've seen alot of topics at the forums now regarding Episode 24 of clannad (Tomoyo edition) what i want to say is that it's actually continuing from how the first clannad game ends (not the tomoyo game), about how Tomoya and Tomoyo get's together.

But for now i'm going to quote some post's to clear this up that this is the CONTINUATION from the Tomoyo Route in the Clannad Game. Not some "alternative" ending or such thing. Or actually it COULD be an alternative ending but! as i've said, it is an continue from how the game ends at the Tomoyo Route.


The so-called Episode 24 of CLANNAD (TV), which came as an OVA along with the CLANNAD DVDs, is based on the Tomoyo route in the game, and accordingly depicts an alternative CLANNADverse where Tomoya hooks up with Sakagami Tomoyo. Therefore, it has little in relation to the main Nagisa storyline which was portrayed in the rest of the series, but it provides a nice little insight into a ‘what-if’ where Tomoyo was the main heroine, and also gives a clue as to why the Tomoyo arc in the main series was so abruptly cut off. Although being a standard 1-episode OVA lasting only 30 minutes means that much of the Tomoyo story has been subjected to a hackjob by necessity, the result is still as decent as it goes, and shows us a side of Tomoyo that those of us who haven’t played the game didn’t know existed.

CLANNAD (TV), Another World (Tomoyo Chapter).





does this somewhat follow the Tomoyo ~It's a Wonderful Life~ story?


No. This episode is based on the Tomoyo Arc in the Clannad story. Tomoyo After follows on from this.



Just watched it. Good work again, Kyoto. Now facial animation is really amazing and shows more real feelings and some small feats like waving hairs adds more feelings in dialogs, you can't miss this in the last dialogue, for example. Plot is good and close to the game, but really short. Short enough. Their relations already started at the beginning of this episode and this is a pity, I expected their first contacts, meetings and relations. The main problem here is a single episode. Only 25 minutes... Because of this 25 minutes you can actually call this episode as summary and nothing more. I think, that people, who played game, should really love this, because they already know their full story, but as for others - they maybe will not like some things or will not understand some small feats here. Ah, btw, thanks a lot for this amazing soundtrack, in this 25 minutes you will hear enough outstanding tracks like Shionari II, Yukinohara and even Ana ! Kyoto, thanks again. And some more special thanks for Tomoyo's and Tomoya's last dialog. It's full and very close to the game, they tryed fully show it in this episode. One of the best dialogues in "Tomoyo's route". Now I hope for Tomoyo After...

9/10.

Well, now let's wait for Clannad AS.


And this post might be retarded/make no sense (feel free to report it if you want) but i made this post out of frustration.
That's all i have to say.


so this isnt the really ending right.... cuase if so i would be very sad... T.T.... and the after story is about nagsai and tomoyo... right?? sorry for a the question i am really confused...


No it is not the real ending =P they are just making a "sequel" you can say for the Tomoyo arc from the game. And ~After Story~ will be about Tomoya and Nagisa and i will warn you it's going to be so freaking sad =D
Member
5605 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / uhhh total memory...
Offline
Posted 7/20/08

darkoff wrote:


Nemo_kid wrote:


darkoff wrote:

To those people who are saying "i didn't like it" "i want Nagisa and Tomoya together" "wut is dis? why is it Tomoyo and Tomoya?"

Read this Post and you will understand why they made an OVA for Tomoyo and Tomoya

Ok lets start here, i've seen alot of topics at the forums now regarding Episode 24 of clannad (Tomoyo edition) what i want to say is that it's actually continuing from how the first clannad game ends (not the tomoyo game), about how Tomoya and Tomoyo get's together.

But for now i'm going to quote some post's to clear this up that this is the CONTINUATION from the Tomoyo Route in the Clannad Game. Not some "alternative" ending or such thing. Or actually it COULD be an alternative ending but! as i've said, it is an continue from how the game ends at the Tomoyo Route.


The so-called Episode 24 of CLANNAD (TV), which came as an OVA along with the CLANNAD DVDs, is based on the Tomoyo route in the game, and accordingly depicts an alternative CLANNADverse where Tomoya hooks up with Sakagami Tomoyo. Therefore, it has little in relation to the main Nagisa storyline which was portrayed in the rest of the series, but it provides a nice little insight into a ‘what-if’ where Tomoyo was the main heroine, and also gives a clue as to why the Tomoyo arc in the main series was so abruptly cut off. Although being a standard 1-episode OVA lasting only 30 minutes means that much of the Tomoyo story has been subjected to a hackjob by necessity, the result is still as decent as it goes, and shows us a side of Tomoyo that those of us who haven’t played the game didn’t know existed.

CLANNAD (TV), Another World (Tomoyo Chapter).





does this somewhat follow the Tomoyo ~It's a Wonderful Life~ story?


No. This episode is based on the Tomoyo Arc in the Clannad story. Tomoyo After follows on from this.



Just watched it. Good work again, Kyoto. Now facial animation is really amazing and shows more real feelings and some small feats like waving hairs adds more feelings in dialogs, you can't miss this in the last dialogue, for example. Plot is good and close to the game, but really short. Short enough. Their relations already started at the beginning of this episode and this is a pity, I expected their first contacts, meetings and relations. The main problem here is a single episode. Only 25 minutes... Because of this 25 minutes you can actually call this episode as summary and nothing more. I think, that people, who played game, should really love this, because they already know their full story, but as for others - they maybe will not like some things or will not understand some small feats here. Ah, btw, thanks a lot for this amazing soundtrack, in this 25 minutes you will hear enough outstanding tracks like Shionari II, Yukinohara and even Ana ! Kyoto, thanks again. And some more special thanks for Tomoyo's and Tomoya's last dialog. It's full and very close to the game, they tryed fully show it in this episode. One of the best dialogues in "Tomoyo's route". Now I hope for Tomoyo After...

9/10.

Well, now let's wait for Clannad AS.


And this post might be retarded/make no sense (feel free to report it if you want) but i made this post out of frustration.
That's all i have to say.


so this isnt the really ending right.... cuase if so i would be very sad... T.T.... and the after story is about nagsai and tomoyo... right?? sorry for a the question i am really confused...


No it is not the real ending =P they are just making a "sequel" you can say for the Tomoyo arc from the game. And ~After Story~ will be about Tomoya and Nagisa and i will warn you it's going to be so freaking sad =D


ok thank u very much for that... and i am totally prepaired to cry my eyes out... which i have done so for this anime many times lol and thank you ^^ very much... =D
Member
24494 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Sweden
Offline
Posted 7/20/08

Nemo_kid wrote:


darkoff wrote:


Nemo_kid wrote:


darkoff wrote:

To those people who are saying "i didn't like it" "i want Nagisa and Tomoya together" "wut is dis? why is it Tomoyo and Tomoya?"

Read this Post and you will understand why they made an OVA for Tomoyo and Tomoya

Ok lets start here, i've seen alot of topics at the forums now regarding Episode 24 of clannad (Tomoyo edition) what i want to say is that it's actually continuing from how the first clannad game ends (not the tomoyo game), about how Tomoya and Tomoyo get's together.

But for now i'm going to quote some post's to clear this up that this is the CONTINUATION from the Tomoyo Route in the Clannad Game. Not some "alternative" ending or such thing. Or actually it COULD be an alternative ending but! as i've said, it is an continue from how the game ends at the Tomoyo Route.


The so-called Episode 24 of CLANNAD (TV), which came as an OVA along with the CLANNAD DVDs, is based on the Tomoyo route in the game, and accordingly depicts an alternative CLANNADverse where Tomoya hooks up with Sakagami Tomoyo. Therefore, it has little in relation to the main Nagisa storyline which was portrayed in the rest of the series, but it provides a nice little insight into a ‘what-if’ where Tomoyo was the main heroine, and also gives a clue as to why the Tomoyo arc in the main series was so abruptly cut off. Although being a standard 1-episode OVA lasting only 30 minutes means that much of the Tomoyo story has been subjected to a hackjob by necessity, the result is still as decent as it goes, and shows us a side of Tomoyo that those of us who haven’t played the game didn’t know existed.

CLANNAD (TV), Another World (Tomoyo Chapter).





does this somewhat follow the Tomoyo ~It's a Wonderful Life~ story?


No. This episode is based on the Tomoyo Arc in the Clannad story. Tomoyo After follows on from this.



Just watched it. Good work again, Kyoto. Now facial animation is really amazing and shows more real feelings and some small feats like waving hairs adds more feelings in dialogs, you can't miss this in the last dialogue, for example. Plot is good and close to the game, but really short. Short enough. Their relations already started at the beginning of this episode and this is a pity, I expected their first contacts, meetings and relations. The main problem here is a single episode. Only 25 minutes... Because of this 25 minutes you can actually call this episode as summary and nothing more. I think, that people, who played game, should really love this, because they already know their full story, but as for others - they maybe will not like some things or will not understand some small feats here. Ah, btw, thanks a lot for this amazing soundtrack, in this 25 minutes you will hear enough outstanding tracks like Shionari II, Yukinohara and even Ana ! Kyoto, thanks again. And some more special thanks for Tomoyo's and Tomoya's last dialog. It's full and very close to the game, they tryed fully show it in this episode. One of the best dialogues in "Tomoyo's route". Now I hope for Tomoyo After...

9/10.

Well, now let's wait for Clannad AS.


And this post might be retarded/make no sense (feel free to report it if you want) but i made this post out of frustration.
That's all i have to say.


so this isnt the really ending right.... cuase if so i would be very sad... T.T.... and the after story is about nagsai and tomoyo... right?? sorry for a the question i am really confused...


No it is not the real ending =P they are just making a "sequel" you can say for the Tomoyo arc from the game. And ~After Story~ will be about Tomoya and Nagisa and i will warn you it's going to be so freaking sad =D


ok thank u very much for that... and i am totally prepaired to cry my eyes out... which i have done so for this anime many times lol and thank you ^^ very much... =D


Hehe Noproblem
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.