Created by skycloud117
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next  Last
Louise vs. Shana
Member
241 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M
Offline
Posted 8/12/08 , edited 8/12/08

skycloud117 wrote:

Who do you think would win if the two of them went at it? Not just in terms of fighting, but personality, cuteness, etc.

If you dont know who Shana is take a look at Shakugan no Shana, The voice actress for them both is the same and even use the same voice, also there personalities are almost the same. Also the male character is the same voice actor for Saito and Yuji from both anime's as well. So its seems like an interesting fight!


why dont you make a poll like :
shana & yuuji vs louise & saito ..... it's fair like that, because louise coudln't fight without saito, isn't it ?


in my opinion, shana & saito are similar... and louise & yuuji are similar too... In SnS, shana & saito are the main fighter... Both of them also have a sword... Nietono no Shana for Shana & Derflinger for saito... Both of them also can't use magic well... So, both of them don't have a specialty in magic, but they have fighting specialty,,,

Unlike Shana and Saito, louise & yuuji don't really have a specialty in fighting, their specialty is casting magic ... Both of them a beginner mages and have special element... Louise has the void elements that's very rare, and Yuuji has the silver flame that very rare as well... Well, both of them just helping Saito and Shana when they are fighting,,, So, both of them just look like Supporter Mages...

I bet it would be fun if you make a poll like that....
Member
224 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / Singapore
Offline
Posted 8/12/08

kuncrut wrote:


skycloud117 wrote:

Who do you think would win if the two of them went at it? Not just in terms of fighting, but personality, cuteness, etc.

If you dont know who Shana is take a look at Shakugan no Shana, The voice actress for them both is the same and even use the same voice, also there personalities are almost the same. Also the male character is the same voice actor for Saito and Yuji from both anime's as well. So its seems like an interesting fight!


why dont you make a poll like :
shana & yuuji vs louise & saito ..... it's fair like that, because louise coudln't fight without saito, isn't it ?


in my opinion, shana & saito are similar... and louise & yuuji are similar too... In SnS, shana & saito are the main fighter... Both of them also have a sword... Nietono no Shana for Shana & Derflinger for saito... Both of them also can't use magic well... So, both of them don't have a specialty in magic, but they have fighting specialty,,,

Unlike Shana and Saito, louise & yuuji don't really have a specialty in fighting, their specialty is casting magic ... Both of them a beginner mages and have special element... Louise has the void elements that's very rare, and Yuuji has the silver flame that very rare as well... Well, both of them just helping Saito and Shana when they are fighting,,, So, both of them just look like Supporter Mages...

I bet it would be fun if you make a poll like that....


agreee!!!
Member
346 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / M / Philippines Ilaya...
Offline
Posted 8/12/08
Shana will own Louise! Thats for sure. If Saito comes, Yuuji will come. Gandalfr vs Mystes! What an intersting fight
519 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / I'm freddie croug...
Offline
Posted 8/12/08
If we're doing Shana vs. Louise because of voice actors. We should add Nagi from Hayate no Gotoku. She's also voiced by the person who voices Shana and Louise. In terms of cuteness, Nagi and Louise are about the same, but I vote for Shana in that area. In terms of partner. Like Louise and Saito, Shana and Yuji, Nagi and Hayate. If it were the three guys, I think Saito and Yuji'd be about the same. Saito's a far better swordsmen, but those silver fireballs are pure pwnage. Plus, Yuji has the blautsauger and if I'm not mistaken, it should still have that effect where all it has to do is make some form of contact with the opponent and instant gash....Then again I think they'd both lose to Hayate and his endless supply of obscure anime references. If it were the girls, Nagi'd stand no chance. And sure, Louise's explosions do seem powerful, but Saito's always fine. Also, from watching all three series, I think the only way for Louise to even hit Shana is to do that large area spell from the first season's final episode. Shana wouldn't give her enough time to. On the love part, at the end of the series it becomes clear that Yuji choose Shana so that places her at the top. Saito's confessed so that puts him below her and Nagi's at the bottom with no confession from either side. Also, the seiyuu for the three of them got an award for Nagi and Shana, but not for Louise. In terms of team battle, Louise and Saito'd be lacking as would Nagi and Hayate. Saito and Yuji are indeed about even, so if Shana and Yuji went after Louise first, Louise wouldn't last too long with Saito occupied with Yuji. Nagi'd never be able to even enter combat, but Hayate'd make up for that with random things and anime references. So in all out combat it really comes down to Shana/Yuji and Nagi/Hayate. Hayate'd be able to handle one of them, I don't think both of them, though. If he's quick about it, there's a chance. Hayate can do some rather odd or random things in combat with the anime references like in one episode he went Super Saiyan and took down like a hundred guys. I think I'll leave that one as a draw. But otherwise, there's no chance. In my eyes it'd be

Louise:
Wins
Losses 5
Draws 1

Shana:
Wins 4
Losses 1
Draws 1

Nagi:
Wins 2
Losses 2
Draws 1

Over all:

Louise: -5

Shana: 3

Nagi:0

So, in my eyes, Shana'd win.
519 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / I'm freddie croug...
Offline
Posted 8/12/08
Wait, forgot a rather handy trick that gives Shana and Yuji complete control in combat. They both have the ability to cast a fuzetsu around the battlefield. If they do that, even Louise and Saito are completely helpless. Shana is a flame haze and Yuji is a mistes, so they're completely fine. However, Saito, Louise, Nagi and Hayate are all human, they wouldn't be able to move in the fuzetsu, let alone even be conscious of what was going on inside it.
220 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / malaysia/ipoh
Offline
Posted 8/12/08
shana 100% will win =.=''' confirm de
220 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / malaysia/ipoh
Offline
Posted 8/12/08
100% is shana confirm de
Member
1762 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / Philippines
Offline
Posted 8/12/08
Louise!! because she has pink hair and looks more cute than Shana..
Member
1352 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28
Offline
Posted 8/12/08

kazecoole wrote:

Wait, forgot a rather handy trick that gives Shana and Yuji complete control in combat. They both have the ability to cast a fuzetsu around the battlefield. If they do that, even Louise and Saito are completely helpless. Shana is a flame haze and Yuji is a mistes, so they're completely fine. However, Saito, Louise, Nagi and Hayate are all human, they wouldn't be able to move in the fuzetsu, let alone even be conscious of what was going on inside it.


I dont think it would affect Louise since she can use magic and Fuzetsu is a form of magic so Saito's sword should make him immune to its affects since it repels magic
102 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M
Offline
Posted 8/12/08
u know what? once shana or yuji uses fuzetsu, louise or saito cant move so shana and yuji wins!!!

LOLS
Member
1352 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28
Offline
Posted 8/12/08
well that depends, Louise isnt a normal human her magical power could very well prevent her from being affected by that, and Deflinger nulls magic thats targeted at Saito so he would most likely be immune as long as he doesnt let go of his sword. Its not as simple as one might think.

Seems when its just shana and louise shana seems to win but when you add in the partners it seems more people think that the louise team will win
680 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / Moon
Offline
Posted 8/13/08
shana
23 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32
Offline
Posted 8/13/08 , edited 8/13/08
what about this? who would you have (1) in a fight (2) hanging out?

In a fight i rather have SnS crew.
Hanging out would be ZnT for me.
Member
11437 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
20 / F / Singapore
Offline
Posted 8/14/08
shana !
Member
34 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / Argentina
Offline
Posted 8/14/08 , edited 8/14/08
Depends on the season :P

For me the Shana from the first season is much more funny, charismatic and interesting; in the second season she becomes a boring, all the whining shadow of the previous one ¬_¬U


In the other hands, Lousie gets better with the time (maybe too much fan service), but i sill have a lot of fun watching it, more now that i can see the third season xD

So i choose Lousie ;D

Pd: There is no point in compare them "fightin" -.-U Cos they are in differents wolrd with diferent rules... is as silly as asking who wins, if Superman or Goku...
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.