Post Reply Breaking Dawn
Member
574 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F
Offline
Posted 8/28/08
I'm not saying Breaking Dawn wasn't enjoyable. But did anyone else think that everything was tied up too perfectly? I mean, in Twilight, New Moon and Eclipse, Bella has her choices.

Edward or Jacob
Mortal or Immortal
Cullens or Charlie/Renee
Humanity or No humanity

Then why, may i ask, does she get absolutely EVERYTHING? I'm all for happy endings but it's...TOO happy. Bella should have had some type of sacrifice. But she gets everything. She gets a baby, who Jacob incidentally imprints on, which make the truce between werewolves and vampires even stronger. She get Charlie AND the Cullen family. And she doesn't even go though the "newborn" phase. It's much too perfect. Everything she worried about never happens.

More over, other characters like Mike, Angela and Jessica fall off the face of the earth. And so does Renee for that matter. And Alice, Jasper and the whole Cullen family. There wasn't much on them. And i LOVE them. I missed hearing about them. And Edward was just a sperm donor in Breaking Dawn. And by the way, I thought he only had venom. Where did the magical little spermies come from? I miss Edward. He had so much more character. But it was all about Bella and Renesme now. And Leah was starting to get interesting but then she's dropped and we don't know the outcome of HER story. Doesn't Leah deserve a happy ending too?

nd not many people could step into Bella's shoes after she was pregnant. She became a mother so quickly. Knowing Bella, she probably wouldn't have been HAPPY when she thought she was pregnant after five minutes. I would want to call MY MOM. And Bella also becomes SUPERWOMAN after her transformation. Makes her even more unknown to the Bella i used to know.

And I was hoping for some action with the Volturi. The tension was so awesome. But they left which sort of left me unsatisfied. But i guess i'm glad everyone was okay.

Don't get me wrong cause i did enjoy Breaking Dawn. Emmett was funny with all his innuendos. And i loved Garrett. ( "I'll follow you anywhere woman", that was cute) But as i said: Everything was too perfect for my liking.

If anyone of you actually FINISHED my rant (i doubt it), then what do you all think?


Posted 8/28/08
I think that is in the top ten for biggest rants ever. I guess you are right, but tying it up is probably a good thing, because now everone was happy. But what you say about all the characters was right.
443 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / Belgium
Offline
Posted 8/28/08
Wow...you gave us quite something to think about Well, i think i couldn't say it better, the ending was indeed a little bit "too" happy. And yeah, it's also a shame that so many characters faded away, the book could have definetly been more better if they stayed...Well, we can only hope that Stephanie holds all these things in mind with midnight sun
Member
574 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F
Offline
Posted 8/28/08
Haha. Thanks guys Edward better be more Edward-ly awesome in Midnight Sun. Or i'll cry and that won't be a pretty site x)
Member
478 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F
Offline
Posted 8/28/08
It was okay and I do agree with you
27964 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / In HeR BeauTiFuL...
Offline
Posted 9/21/08
I do agree with you ,although i enjoyed reading it as well...but i guess Stephenie wanted to please all the sides.. i also wanted to know about Leah...she's the only person with problem left unsolved =[...and yeah the whole book was about Bella and seem to concentrate on solving her problems...but maybe bcuz it's from bellas perspective..but anyways im glad it ended up that way ..without anyone i loved getting killed or hurt =]
Member
17784 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / No where to be seen
Offline
Posted 9/28/08
well i didnt finish the book yet but it does seem a little 'too' happy. how in the world did bella get everything she had wanted??? its just weird >_<
195 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F
Offline
Posted 10/15/08 , edited 10/15/08
Wow, now that you mentioned it, Breaking Dawn was a little TOO happy.
I actually skimmed through the book again and was like "WTF?"
But all in all, the book was mmkay.
Member
838 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / Philippines
Offline
Posted 11/14/08
I quite agree! The ending was a little to happy! it's like a disney movie where they live happily ever after! i was thinking about jacob being with bella or edward became human or someone should have died.. hehe.. LOL!
Member
184 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / Internet
Offline
Posted 1/2/09
well, I am not quit happy with the imprinting...and I dont really like the verry happy ending on breaking dawn either
You must be logged in to post.