Created by sintenil2
First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
Post Reply Rate this series!!
Member
1413 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Maelstrom, Atlant...
Offline
Posted 9/27/08 , edited 10/6/08
State your Rating and Opinions about this anime!

The Good:
*
*
*
*



The Bad:
*
*
*
*

Opinion:

************************


:D:D






Here's mine:

Goodies:

10/10 = Music
9/10 = Story/Plot
10/10 = 3D Animation
8/10 = 2D Animation


Baddy:

5/10 = Dogfights [lacks action, only 2 episodes have the Good Fight]
5/10 = Romance [a cliffhanger ]


This anime would have been the best if it was thorough in its story. it was a little rush! The romance was stalled! The fights were abrupt.... but still, it was a kick ass anime!

My Rating: 7.8
Member
1413 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Maelstrom, Atlant...
Offline
Posted 9/27/08
This is the first Rating i've seen so far!


a2d117 wrote:

Macross was about the music, the fighting, and the romance. MF accomplished the first two but left the third unresolved. Episode 25 was epic for its battle scenes and music remixes, although it was a little rushed.

The goods:
- Remixes of all the good songs
- Excellent mecha action
- Sheryl is cured
- Grace is dead
- Brera and Alto fighting together
- Alto's salute to Sheryl in reference to DYRL

The bads:
- It's convenient that the giant Ranka was not Ranka so the people of Frontier can forgive her.
- Sheryls cure was Ranka's touch; cliche and anticlimatic
- Galaxy is still faceless, only represented by Grace
- Alto ran away from answering the girls again; LT unresolved

The fixes:
- A good movie wrapping up all lose ends! (yes, there is gonna be a movie)

Ep 25: 8/10
Overall Series: 9/10


i've copied and paste it here so that a2d117 will not write again;
Member
195 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Philippines
Offline
Posted 9/27/08 , edited 9/27/08
9/10 it is so good that it almost made my cry when sheryl was cured nice twist.
Member
1126 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / Republika Ng Pili...
Offline
Posted 9/29/08
Well I rate is 9/10 since the first airing of this Macross Frontier last December I known this anime is gonna be cool... It was full of action, drama, music and specially the mecha...also Sherly is so..HOT!!!
Member
11243 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / BC, Canada =P
Offline
Posted 9/29/08 , edited 9/29/08
here's my rating for Macross Frontier

Mecha Dog Fights: 6/10

Storyplot: 7/10

Romance: 8/10

Music: 9/10

Overall Score: 8.5/10
Member
493 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / Unknown
Offline
Posted 10/4/08
I'm gonna say it's absolutely superb...
the plot of the series is interesting and the music is the best of the best
Member
64967 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
37 / M / Lynnwood, Wa. USA
Offline
Posted 10/5/08 , edited 10/5/08

andydono wrote:

here's my rating for Macross Frontier

Mecha Dog Fights: 6/10

Storyplot: 7/10

Romance: 8/10

Music: 9/10

Overall Score: 8.5/10



animation during animal attack during filming of the Macross Zero Movie: 3/10
Member
1413 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Maelstrom, Atlant...
Offline
Posted 10/6/08

animation during animal attack during filming of the Macross Zero Movie: 3/10


Brera's animation was like a sketch work ^_^!
Member
936 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / North America, Ak...
Offline
Posted 10/6/08 , edited 10/6/08
Mecha/ dog fights: 7.5/10 - i wish there were more.

Story:8/10 - Liked how a majority of the Macross stories/ series were tied into one series.

Romance: 5/10- It left with a cliff hanger

Music: 10/10 - i like Yoko kanno

Plot twist: 2/10- i wish they could have made it less predictable. Even watching it raw which i know no Japanese i could figure out just by expressions, body language, and voice emphases

The fact it Licensed now : 5/10- Good b/c now it'll be on dvd an i can share it with other ppl. Bad b/c its not on dvd yet, and it has a strong possibility of getting bad dubs.

Overall: 8/10 for now
Member
195 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Philippines
Offline
Posted 10/7/08

DuGeMon wrote:
animation during animal attack during filming of the Macross Zero Movie:
3/10 :angry:

agree.lol what the hell with the animation in that part,it looks like the scene was in adrenaline,so speedy with those lines.
366 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
38 / F
Offline
Posted 10/7/08
Mecha/ dog fights: 10/10 - Good enough since Macross story is never bout mecha in the first place. It's just a decoration.

Story:10/10 - I like it a lot since it's a simple explanation sci-fi.

Romance: 10/10 - It's hanging and feels like Minmei - Hikaru - Lisa triangle love which is nostalgic and for me it's great.

Music: 10/10 - May'n RAWKS !!!! Megumi Nakajima reminds me of Minmei which she has the 'innocent voice tone.

Plot twist: 10/10 It's predictable that Grace is the antagonist and I am glad she is.

Overall: 10/10 - The fact this anime only have 25 episodes with full of romance and songs is great. This is so Macross. I would give 11 if there's more neko nyan nyan dance.

One thing I hate is Ranka's VA Megumi Nakajima sounds so stiff until half of the episodes she sounds better. As a singer she's great but not as a VA.

Sheryl Nome is my fave next to Grace.
Member
936 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / North America, Ak...
Offline
Posted 10/7/08 , edited 10/7/08

tsunderemomiko wrote:

Mecha/ dog fights: 10/10 - Good enough since Macross story is never bout mecha in the first place. It's just a decoration.

Story:10/10 - I like it a lot since it's a simple explanation sci-fi.

Romance: 10/10 - It's hanging and feels like Minmei - Hikaru - Lisa triangle love which is nostalgic and for me it's great.

Music: 10/10 - May'n RAWKS !!!! Megumi Nakajima reminds me of Minmei which she has the 'innocent voice tone.

Plot twist: 10/10 It's predictable that Grace is the antagonist and I am glad she is.

Overall: 10/10 - The fact this anime only have 25 episodes with full of romance and songs is great. This is so Macross. I would give 11 if there's more neko nyan nyan dance.

One thing I hate is Ranka's VA Megumi Nakajima sounds so stiff until half of the episodes she sounds better. As a singer she's great but not as a VA.

Sheryl Nome is my fave next to Grace.

BUt ranka's character from the begining was immature, shy, and in short a child. by the end of the series she's still immature , but she came out of her shell and grew up some. and the voice actress conveyed it pretty good.
366 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
38 / F
Offline
Posted 10/7/08
@Beyond-the-Grave

You're right. Maybe I just didn't notice that.

BUT since there's a lot of new VA which mainly will be focused on singing later are like trying to promote their self through anime. I don't remember which anime but they sound stiff and kinda feel forced to act. Well it's just a bussiness anyway.
Member
936 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / North America, Ak...
Offline
Posted 10/7/08

tsunderemomiko wrote:

@Beyond-the-Grave

You're right. Maybe I just didn't notice that.

BUT since there's a lot of new VA which mainly will be focused on singing later are like trying to promote their self through anime. I don't remember which anime but they sound stiff and kinda feel forced to act. Well it's just a bussiness anyway.


U sure it wasn't an American TV show? American actors tend to do that a lot especially when they think they can act and sing.
366 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
38 / F
Offline
Posted 10/8/08
And why wouldn't any Japs doin the same thing?

Wellcome to the real world.
First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.