Post Reply If Breaking Dawn was made into a movie, do you think it needs to be made into 2 movies?
Posted 10/6/08 , edited 10/8/08
On Stephenie Meyer's website, in the Breaking Dawn FAQ's, she states the reason why she thinks if they made it, there needs to be 2 movies made. And that it would hard also because of Renesmee. Do you guys think there needs to be 2 movies made? Because if they made it without Jacob's perspective, then it wouldn't be as long, but it still would be long anyway.

TwilightFannabe
3681 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / ...♥
Offline
Posted 10/8/08
Well...movies arent made in perspectives so it wouldnt matter.
TwilightFannabe
2413 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F
Offline
Posted 10/8/08
yeah....i think it should..... and also....creating Nessie would be really hard to do...unless they make her into a digital baby....or sumthing.,.....
TwilightFannabe
1096 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / Pennsylvania
Offline
Posted 10/8/08
I think Breaking Dawn wouldn't be a good movie. The script would have to be much tighter. I really doubt that they'd make it in general. So...lots of changes. I even think New Moon will be a lot different from the book, it just wouldn't make a good movie.
27862 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 10/8/08 , edited 10/8/08
They'd kill the movie of Breaking Dawn anywho...I'd think they either DO the movie with 2 movies (how that is ever pulled off, I'm not sure), or just do Twilight and get it over with.

PLUS, when they do the movie, Edward has to look the same age, which is physically impossible unless they can complete a movie in less than 4 years *with all of the other movies in between that*.

And...yes...Reneesme will be hard to make...unless they can make a super baby that ages and talks...like the Superbabie movie..

Also...with the perspective thing...kind of hard to change it in a movie....


FINAL OPINION: Just not do the movie at all.
TwilightFannabe
693 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / Catching the fall...
Offline
Posted 10/8/08 , edited 10/8/08
i agree.. with aikoyamashina i dont think that that would be a very good movie, cause there r so many things that only in the book can happen.. like bellas change,her power, and wat about when Bella shows Edward her mind? would we just get flashes? Wat r they going to do about the other 2 books? that would be kinda weird...
TwilightFannabe
5888 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F
Offline
Posted 10/9/08
haha ....... what would it be when the 1 or 2 part/s of Breaking Dawn would be filmed in just 1 year .......... haha ..... impossible ........... but i would like to watch the all movies of the books in the saga though ...........
TwilightFannabe
3298 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 10/11/08
I thick they should make only 2 movies,
well on the 3ed book it was weird with the whole baby thing
and i think she should have not have a baby so soon or just no baby at all
but i hope the movie does come out good
i'm lookin forward to seein it n buyin it also
Posted 10/12/08

aikoyamashina wrote:

They'd kill the movie of Breaking Dawn anywho...I'd think they either DO the movie with 2 movies (how that is ever pulled off, I'm not sure), or just do Twilight and get it over with.

PLUS, when they do the movie, Edward has to look the same age, which is physically impossible unless they can complete a movie in less than 4 years *with all of the other movies in between that*.

And...yes...Reneesme will be hard to make...unless they can make a super baby that ages and talks...like the Superbabie movie..

Also...with the perspective thing...kind of hard to change it in a movie....


FINAL OPINION: Just not do the movie at all.


I agree. I say they should leave it alone.
Posted 10/14/08
I would love to see like , a movie of every book and stuff , but let's face it . It's impossible . There are so many parts that are... well , yeah , just impossible . Especially Renesmee . Talking , and aging super quick ? I'm so sure .

I guess I wouldn`t mind seeing the New Moon one though . That's not nearly as impossible as what Breaking Dawn would be .
You must be logged in to post.