First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
reason for rejected items
752 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / My own world
Offline
Posted 10/10/08

MikanxChan wrote:

well yeah- they said they will look to the stats and the quality blablabla. bad and crappy items got approved. and we neko girls need good item stats. they keep changing it! Look at chibi girl! level 10 weapon .. 25 damage? And we .. 15?! WE NEED GOOD ITEMS!!


YES!!!!!!!!!!! NEKO GIRLS NEEEED GOOD ITEMS!
[rant]You know the Powerful Attack Staff I made? THAT HAD GREAT STATS UNTIL THEY NERFED IT. I feel the pain of having an item getting nerfed now... It feels like your doing something to balance the game or improve neko girls(or whatever class) and they just shoot ya down, ya know?[/rant] I don't know why they took away the 3 fire damage the small neko baton did. I can't fathom why 3 fire damage had to be nerfed...

Anyway, I think reasons would be helpful, but I don't want to pressure our hard-working admins/mods. I think for now you should just make topics asking why things got rejected and/or nerfed. It'll keep the cruchyland community going.
716 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
20 / F / The Netherlands.
Offline
Posted 10/10/08

Moon_Princessu wrote:


MikanxChan wrote:

well yeah- they said they will look to the stats and the quality blablabla. bad and crappy items got approved. and we neko girls need good item stats. they keep changing it! Look at chibi girl! level 10 weapon .. 25 damage? And we .. 15?! WE NEED GOOD ITEMS!!


YES!!!!!!!!!!! NEKO GIRLS NEEEED GOOD ITEMS!
[rant]You know the Powerful Attack Staff I made? THAT HAD GREAT STATS UNTIL THEY NERFED IT. I feel the pain of having an item getting nerfed now... It feels like your doing something to balance the game or improve neko girls(or whatever class) and they just shoot ya down, ya know?[/rant] I don't know why they took away the 3 fire damage the small neko baton did. I can't fathom why 3 fire damage had to be nerfed...

Anyway, I think reasons would be helpful, but I don't want to pressure our hard-working admins/mods. I think for now you should just make topics asking why things got rejected and/or nerfed. It'll keep the cruchyland community going.


Yeah i know but. seriously..they said they would make the stats good or..w/e- More items are getting approved thats good yes.But they are still getting nerfed >.<!!! No'one cares about neko girls. =( I made-tried to make cute good around level 20 stats items but they just..made it worse >=O
5327 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / Edmonton, Canada
Offline
Posted 10/10/08

obscure89 wrote:

hmmmmm... people also rank your items... if you got high ranks and nothings wrong maybe they will approve it...
do you always got high ranks?


yes appearantly my lowest was 3.9 i think


ZeddyMarx wrote:

Sorry for bothering you. Wow, be honest, that hair is messy like just woke up in the morning ^^ but it's cool :w00t:. It's first time you summit this item right?(I bet).
+ I think most reasonable that mod unapproved this item is: it's look like same as some hairs before if the mod only glanced over it quickly :D( it's my opinion so please forgive me if I am wrong, thank you)
+ And another factor, I think the mod who rejected this item, may be he/she thought it was approved before or it was duplicated(I know it doesn't make sense but it may happen ^^)
+Thank you for showing the item by the way :D


P.S: I found an item that looks like your item, go to http://www.crunchyroll.com/show/vitemclass/?id=20221

I know it's not look like exactly but if the mod only looked it quickly so I think may be..... ^^


well it IS my item.......maybe it's messy cuz i colored it with tablet since i was bored trying to waste time....
if the case is "glanced over quickly " then they better choose new mods . cuz they're SUPPOSE to pay more attention =__=


MikanxChan wrote:

well yeah- they said they will look to the stats and the quality blablabla. bad and crappy items got approved. and we neko girls need good item stats. they keep changing it! Look at chibi girl! level 10 weapon .. 25 damage? And we .. 15?! WE NEED GOOD ITEMS!!


no kidding i thought the mods might delete some bad ones but no




ella182 wrote:

^^no of course not.. people are just too busy playing with their avatars to post..


Anyways my thoughts on this could be that when mods delete items they are shown a drop-down list of pre-written reasons to reject the item. Like for example the options could be: poor quality, copywright/from liscaned show, Similar to an existing item, low image resolution, stolen item, item was rated low or other.

This would be much much much easier then them having to type out a reason, and it would help people who are trying to design items and want to know why theirs didn't make it...


no kidding =__=





5327 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / Edmonton, Canada
Offline
Posted 10/10/08 , edited 10/10/08
OMG i didnt think there's so many replys lmao

but seriously as a DESIGNER i have pride in my work (a lot on some) and it's not nice to be beaten by crappy items made in few seconds

or be rejected for no appearant reason
52844 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / USA-CA
Offline
Posted 10/10/08

bluewitch201 wrote:

OMG i didnt think there's so many replys lmao

but seriously as a DESIGNER i have pride in my work (a lot on some) and it's not nice to be beaten by crappy items made in few seconds

or be rejected for no appearant reason


Yeah, I agree with you Designers have their own pride so we( players) need to respect it include the mods. By the way, I saw a lot of crappy or stolen items still got approved, it's so stupid. I think the mods should pay "more attention". That's my opinion
30324 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / Naha, Okinawa - D...
Offline
Posted 10/13/08 , edited 10/13/08
If I had 100% control of the approval of items, there probably wouldn't be many things for anyone... lol...
Luckily I don't >_>

Anyway, I agree he seemed pretty rude in that PM, I don't think he should have said such a thing... I'd feel really bad, and probably report about his behaviour. Usually I try to type in a friendlier, neutral manner in my design PMs.
He should have pointed out specific things, like for example, if it fits, is stolen, is too flat, too 3D, etc...

Also the approval of uglier items, it depends on who's approving the items at the time. Some mods are stricter, and some are really easy. I try to accept only really good items, and disapprove really bad items, while leaving things I can't decide on, to other mods.

PS: Stats shouldn't matter, since we're required to change them according to a set score sheet(basically we have to change almost everything's stats before approving). But it's best to try and not go too high with stats.
2438 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / Peru
Offline
Posted 10/13/08 , edited 10/13/08

pikangie wrote:

If I had 100% control of the approval of items, there probably wouldn't be many things for anyone... lol...
Luckily I don't >_>

Anyway, I agree he seemed pretty rude in that PM, I don't think he should have said such a thing... I'd feel really bad, and probably report about his behaviour. Usually I try to type in a friendlier, neutral manner in my design PMs.
He should have pointed out specific things, like for example, if it fits, is stolen, is too flat, too 3D, etc...

Also the approval of uglier items, it depends on who's approving the items at the time. Some mods are stricter, and some are really easy. I try to accept only really good items, and disapprove really bad items, while leaving things I can't decide on, to other mods.

PS: Stats shouldn't matter, since we're required to change them according to a set score sheet(basically we have to change almost everything's stats before approving). But it's best to try and not go too high with stats.


Could you explain me what this Set Score sheet consists of? It would save the mods a lot of trouble when managing the stats if we learn how to put stats accordingly :3
30324 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / Naha, Okinawa - D...
Offline
Posted 10/14/08
Yea several of us mods agree with that, but we haven't gotten a response as to whether it's ok to post the sheet...
Posted 10/14/08
580 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M
Offline
Posted 10/15/08
Geez, they rejected one of shinji's items? Did they even know that it was his design or not? If not, they need to pay more attention I guess.
30324 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / Naha, Okinawa - D...
Offline
Posted 10/16/08
Wow, really? I didn't even see that one... I wonder who did it, though.
23440 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F
Offline
Posted 10/16/08
i think from the fact tt shinji's design even get rejected, they realy did look at the designs....... perhaps u can try designing some other???? coz some of the designs does look pretty similar to other items.....
211 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F
Offline
Posted 10/17/08 , edited 10/17/08
This may not be in context of why things are rejected. But I'm getting overly tired of items with low stats. People will create decent looking things for your avatar with low stats? Why? Then I get stuck with something that doesn't look so good, cause the stats are good. I beg people. Please create something nice with good stats too. So we aren't so limited.

Edit: I was unaware that the Mods nerf the items themselves. Which altimately blows... Do they nerf the level too?
Btw this is my new set if you guys want to vote!

5327 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / Edmonton, Canada
Offline
Posted 10/21/08

jjamesc21 wrote:

Geez, they rejected one of shinji's items? Did they even know that it was his design or not? If not, they need to pay more attention I guess.


so? just cuz it's shinji don't mean it's that great =__________________=



sakusyaorockz wrote:

i think from the fact tt shinji's design even get rejected, they realy did look at the designs....... perhaps u can try designing some other???? coz some of the designs does look pretty similar to other items.....


not really.....................i'm sure it dosent


Purpleskyez wrote:

This may not be in context of why things are rejected. But I'm getting overly tired of items with low stats. People will create decent looking things for your avatar with low stats? Why? Then I get stuck with something that doesn't look so good, cause the stats are good. I beg people. Please create something nice with good stats too. So we aren't so limited.

Edit: I was unaware that the Mods nerf the items themselves. Which altimately blows... Do they nerf the level too?
Btw this is my new set if you guys want to vote!



no kidding!
24468 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
19 / F
Offline
Posted 10/21/08
Yeah, I made these eyes not to long ago [http://www.crunchyroll.com/show/vitemclass/?id=22873]
And instead of defense and damage, it's now defense, lightning damage, and magic bonus. But I guess it's okay for them to do that... sometimes.
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.