Knocked up while in prison!?
32237 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / F / Denver
Offline
Posted 11/14/08 , edited 11/14/08
Alright, so I have nothing to back this story up, but I found it thoroughly amusing.


My friend's sister just got out of prison after 5 years. While she was there, her cellmate was a pre-op (still has a penis) transvestite. Apparently, before my friend's sister ended up in the pen, this (woman?) had impregnated another inmate. I don't know the exact details of what happened with the pregnant inmate, but it made me think of this question:


NOW BEGINS MY FORUM QUESTION


If someone was born a man, yet feels and lives as a woman, should they be put in a women's penitentiary if they should be sent to prison? They couldn't possibly survive in a men's prison, but is it okay to have a pre-op transvestite (who has natural human urges) in a cell with a woman? And vise-versa?
Posted 11/14/08
wow....that is fucked up.
Posted 11/14/08
Errr... they actually have gay men in men's prisons.
I think the ones who are getting anally rape are not the real gay ones, but the masculine ones.

I mean like a male inmate would prefer to rape a guy like Collin Ferrell more than a guy like Richard Simmons.


Who's in the right mind raping this (Richard Simmons):

instead of this (Collin Ferrell):
32237 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / F / Denver
Offline
Posted 11/14/08 , edited 11/14/08

vittoriano wrote:

wow....that is fucked up.


I'm bringing our guest book discussion over here to keep my thread alive, don't mind me.


What I was telling this gentleman was that I believe it should be fine to have trannys in their respective sexed prison. If you truly are a woman in a man's body, you should be in a women's prison. Just because you have a dick, doesn't mean you're a "man" (that sounds weird to say). Even if said transvestite had had his penis removed, he probably still would have had sex with his cellmate. Man or woman, [it] still has sexual urges. Turns out, he had a functioning organ from which to derive pleasure from, thus [it] used it, be it for gay, straight, or lesbian intercourse. It's not like [it] raped the woman, if anything, I would imagine the other inmates were jealous because it's unfair that they were deprived of intercourse with a [man].
5561 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / Neverland
Offline
Posted 11/14/08
Well, actually idk.. gotta think about it
I've always felt that gay men should be allowed in the women's cell though, only if the gay men are truly & fully gay but as I keep thinking about it there are some women that would probably rape the gay guys.. Anyway to ur question yes, I think that transvestites should be able to stay in women's cells
32237 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / F / Denver
Offline
Posted 11/14/08 , edited 11/17/08

lonely_devil wrote:

Well, actually idk.. gotta think about it
I've always felt that gay men should be allowed in the women's cell though, only if the gay men are truly & fully gay but as I keep thinking about it there are some women that would probably rape the gay guys.. Anyway to ur question yes, I think that transvestites should be able to stay in women's cells


I think that it should be okay, too. But whether or not they're "actually gay" or not, they will probably have sex with their cellmate, just as two straight women would eventually get the urge to do so, as would two straight men! Could it be considered that putting a gay man in a men's penitentiary is giving him some kind of privilege?
Posted 11/17/08

kyoukoujin wrote:

Errr... they actually have gay men in men's prisons.
I think the ones who are getting anally rape are not the real gay ones, but the masculine ones.

I mean like a male inmate would prefer to rape a guy like Collin Ferrell more than a guy like Richard Simmons.


Who's in the right mind raping this (Richard Simmons):

instead of this (Collin Ferrell):


so fuck it, bring the lube i'll rape both of them
Posted 3/23/09
no
Posted 3/23/09

goldengoat55555 wrote:


kyoukoujin wrote:

Errr... they actually have gay men in men's prisons.
I think the ones who are getting anally rape are not the real gay ones, but the masculine ones.

I mean like a male inmate would prefer to rape a guy like Collin Ferrell more than a guy like Richard Simmons.


Who's in the right mind raping this (Richard Simmons):

instead of this (Collin Ferrell):


so fuck it, bring the lube i'll rape both of them


Oh dear god MY EYES THEY BURN T.T
2035 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M
Offline
Posted 6/20/10
A transvestite might have the better life in a male prison(excluding the risk of STDs). I read that they work as prostitutes and don't get beaten up(get protection) as much as others.
75430 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
49 / F / Center of the Uni...
Offline
Posted 6/20/10 , edited 6/20/10
The standard presented to me by my friends and acquaintances within the LGBT community is that the Transgendered are expected to conform to the gender they are presenting as...

ie if you're wearing a dress, you use the girl's washroom.

further... I'm not sure when you legally become a She instead of a He (or vice versa) but in some jurisdictions it -may- (I don't know) be before the crucial operation.

Once you're legally a 'she' (or a 'he' going the other way) then the government and anyone who has a legal relationship with you has to treat you as one.

Pretty simple.

Oh and note: there's a difference between tranvestism and the transgendered. An insignificant one to the 'They're all FAGS" crowd, I'm sure but for rest of us, and for this thread which asks about Transgendered prisoners it's an important distinction.
65911 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
54 / F / Atlanta GA
Offline
Posted 6/20/10

DreadDenimPirate wrote:

Alright, so I have nothing to back this story up, but I found it thoroughly amusing.


My friend's sister just got out of prison after 5 years. While she was there, her cellmate was a pre-op (still has a penis) transvestite. Apparently, before my friend's sister ended up in the pen, this (woman?) had impregnated another inmate. I don't know the exact details of what happened with the pregnant inmate, but it made me think of this question:


NOW BEGINS MY FORUM QUESTION


If someone was born a man, yet feels and lives as a woman, should they be put in a women's penitentiary if they should be sent to prison? They couldn't possibly survive in a men's prison, but is it okay to have a pre-op transvestite (who has natural human urges) in a cell with a woman? And vise-versa?


The law in every state if you have the sex organs of a male, you sent to a male prison.
Posted 6/20/10
this sounds like something out of an bad adult movie.
maffoo 
78814 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
35 / M / England
Online
Posted 6/21/10
I think it's a tough call, and the decision would need to be made based on medical opinion (I assume that, given the gravity of the decision to have the operation, there would be counsellors/psychiatrists involved who could give such an opinion.)

Possibly the best way to handle it is to put them in a woman's prison, but give potential cell mates the right to request not to share a cell with "her" if they aren't comfortable sharing a cell with someone who is still (genetically and in this case at least partly anatomically) male.
You must be logged in to post.