First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next  Last
who killed ciel's parents?
298 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / -
Offline
Posted 11/18/08

annaivida wrote:


Ketychan wrote:

I think haku_vue is right but it can by the queens order too. I don´t think Sebastian bertay his ,,master" because he has his principles XD


you are so right... principles, aesthetics... even demon have laws they obey and they are far more elegant and well differ from human thinking...

but Sebastian being under The late Phantomhive.... then Aunt Anne should have known him right? anyway.... its not Sebastian.... hehehe.... that's what i believe.... wow!!!


Nope it is possible because remember that sebastian is a demon.He can take on any form.,but im sure he wouldnt betray Ciel.He always say something about what he will do if he refuses Ciel's order maybe release his soul?
87 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31
Offline
Posted 11/18/08
I don't believe it was Sebastian. think of this way, it's the twist of the story . hinting in a very subtle way who might be the killer but in the end the least expected is actually the culprit
Member
3500 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 11/18/08

riyahnna wrote:

I don't believe it was Sebastian. think of this way, it's the twist of the story . hinting in a very subtle way who might be the killer but in the end the least expected is actually the culprit


agree on that one... sebastian maybe a demon in any forms but i dont think his the killer. i have the hunch that it maybe another clan that hates the phantomhive or the queen itself or maybe lets think closer - relatives of the phantomhive... anyway - im not that curious to know who the killer is... time will reveal it.
Posted 11/18/08
I think it could be the Queen the one they serve so willingly...in one episode I can't remember maybe it was 6 that Ciel was told to be careful, because the one who put the collar on him, that he should be careful it isn't the same to lop off his head....it was something like that....but who knows....Seb I want to believe that he isn't the one who did it since he said no matter what he would stand by Ciel.
Member
892 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / China
Offline
Posted 11/21/08
from the fifth manga, ciel heard screams from a room and saw his dead parents lying on the floor. when he found Tanaka (i forgot his name, but he's that weird old man) he was then caught by someone, then he was put in a cage and tortured in all sorts of horrible ways, it was during that time that sebastion appeared. I think he was at that place as well, so it did look a bit suspicious. But then if ciel's parents were first murdered, then does that mean that while he was being tortured they burned the mansion as well. but there is another question i have, in ep 2, ciel's father was seen sitting on a chair the ring on his finger, yet in the manga, after he was murdered he was lying on the floor, if they did move his sitting position, then why would they do that?
Posted 11/21/08

shadowbabii wrote:

haha i seriously think its the coffin guy or the queen of england hahah xD
the coffin guy cuz hes creey n the queen of england cuz she probably doesnt want the family 2 over throw her
x]


ooh nixe guess..i kinda go on with u n that^^-the queen that is
Posted 11/21/08
I personally think it was Sebastian, though I love him :P. He is a demon and a demon is a demon with or without principles.

Think of it this way: Why would Sebastion be chosen for Ciel if he DIDN'T know what happened to his parents? And If he didn't why wouldn't he want Ciel to find out? Wouldn't he want to help Ciel figure out who killed them if hes so sensitive to it? And GRELL is the only one SEBASTIAN knows because Shinigami and Demons are relatively close. Plus, his Aunt might HAVE known but she didn't kill them, after all, she loved the guy longer than she loved Ciel, who she couldn't kill herself. Grell, being heartless probably has a subordinate but he wouldn't edge Ciel on, after all, Grell loves his face and Ciel is strong with Sebby. Heck, maybe Sebastion didn't

Don't get me wrong, I don't want him to be it either, cause hes the 2nd best character along with Ciel as 2nd>_<"! Sorry I personally think the Undertaker is my favourite character XD I love his personality!
Member
1772 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / planet,,earth,,in...
Offline
Posted 11/21/08
this maybe sounds ridiculous but on my first thought i think........ ciel killed his own parents... i dont know for what reason but thats what i think...
823 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / Philippines, Zamb...
Offline
Posted 11/21/08
its not sebby?
i think i should wait patiently
Member
8253 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / Death City
Offline
Posted 11/22/08
who knows? But hey if it turns out to be Sebastian then yeah I would be shocked.
120 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
76 / M
Offline
Posted 11/23/08
i think its suicide =D
nah,jk
Posted 11/23/08
i dnt know!!!!!!!!!!! :/
Member
23957 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / The Seven Kingdom...
Offline
Posted 11/24/08
wow....everyone has their good opinions~!!!

i seriously want to be proven wrong since i dont want Sebby to be the culprit...
no matter what...ZETTAI NI~!!

but all we got wait for the anime and manga to reveal more of the clues...
Member
78 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Aosta, Italy
Offline
Posted 11/24/08
I may be a bit late to answer the forum but I think it was the Queen also because maybe she thought that the Phantomhive family was in to deep with her business that she had them killed and didn't expect Ciel to survive and thought that she could use the Phantomhives since Ciel doesn't know who the culprit is and seems not interested in the matter. Another pawn is better after all right? Well that's what I think at least
Member
101786 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
19 / F / singapore
Offline
Posted 11/24/08

annaivida wrote:

not Sebastian..... the queen herself... that's my theory... specially we are dealing with queen victoria here who would annihilate everyone and everything in the way...

who killed ciel's parent's and why is sebastian's reaction that way? hmmm... mada mada - too early for ciel to find out and his still in the growing process... Sebastian - well - he was only asked by Ciel when he was about to die right? ... Sebastian is a DEMON... remember unless he was under some contract with someone...... i really believe it's not Sebastian... just like Ciel said... Demon has aesthetics and different from human - they will gain nothing with killing without something in return... only a pure soul to be taited by the demon can tempt them... just like CIEL's SOUL....


HEY! NICE TINKING!
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.