First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
Post Reply Manga Discussion
385 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / France brdx
Offline
Posted 12/16/08

tokwang_hilaw wrote:


romatchka wrote:


Kaara wrote:

kid Ren is Reira and Tamaki hello Tamaki slept with Reira come on we all know Tamaki dosn't use protection just look what happen to Hachi >_> And Reira would be one of the only people to call there son son ren because she cared for him a lot
that and every thing thats happen in the manga point to it if u can understand yazawas story style


i know that it could (highly is) reira son's (just by the way the story is written,it wouldnt supriz anyone)but when u read this page,you get the feeling that its hachi's son.Its like the 4are happy 2gether familly,and without a third party who has custody of the kid..i dont think reira is the type to give birth and give the baby away to takumi.
Plus ren was someone very important to everyone so all of them could have name their child ren.
i changed my mind..when you hear reira talk about kid ren it really doesnt sound as if shes talking about her son...

http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/09/
http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/16/ ~>doesnt sound as if she picked the name herself..


Hmm... nice point there.. and now I'm having second thoughts ahaha xD Yazawa likes to keep us guessing I suppose lol

http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/09/
From this page, when Reira said she should've hated him.. who could she be talking about? Takumi? Ren for dying? or little kid Ren for being Takumi and Hachi's son? The latter could be a very good reasoning and the fact that kid Ren calls Reira by her name not mommy... http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/13/

Interesting... I hope the next issue will clear things up for us ^^


me to...but u should read kaara point of view she's cleary has made up her mind,and its not stupid what she has to say ..but she could b nicer
Member
1060 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / F / CA
Offline
Posted 12/16/08 , edited 12/16/08

romatchka wrote:


tokwang_hilaw wrote:


romatchka wrote:


Kaara wrote:

kid Ren is Reira and Tamaki hello Tamaki slept with Reira come on we all know Tamaki dosn't use protection just look what happen to Hachi >_> And Reira would be one of the only people to call there son son ren because she cared for him a lot
that and every thing thats happen in the manga point to it if u can understand yazawas story style


i know that it could (highly is) reira son's (just by the way the story is written,it wouldnt supriz anyone)but when u read this page,you get the feeling that its hachi's son.Its like the 4are happy 2gether familly,and without a third party who has custody of the kid..i dont think reira is the type to give birth and give the baby away to takumi.
Plus ren was someone very important to everyone so all of them could have name their child ren.
i changed my mind..when you hear reira talk about kid ren it really doesnt sound as if shes talking about her son...

http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/09/
http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/16/ ~>doesnt sound as if she picked the name herself..


Hmm... nice point there.. and now I'm having second thoughts ahaha xD Yazawa likes to keep us guessing I suppose lol

http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/09/
From this page, when Reira said she should've hated him.. who could she be talking about? Takumi? Ren for dying? or little kid Ren for being Takumi and Hachi's son? The latter could be a very good reasoning and the fact that kid Ren calls Reira by her name not mommy... http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/13/

Interesting... I hope the next issue will clear things up for us ^^


me to...but u should read kaara point of view she's cleary has made up her mind,and its not stupid what she has to say ..but she could b nicer


Hehe yeah...
I don't really like participating in debates about entertainment but Nana is one of my favorite mangas and I can't help but participate in discussion here xD I hope we keep it civil haha

As for who's little Ren's mom, it's a bit confusing at this point because... there are hints that could point to Reira (one night stand w/ Takumi being the most effective one because look what happened to Hachi lol) but then there are also hints that could point to Hachi (Satsuki talking about four of them as a family.. kid Ren calling Reira by her name).

For now tho... I do lean a little bit to Reira being the mother.. because when I think about it.. it seems as though little Ren doesn't even know his own mother... I don't recall him wanting to see Hachi (if I was a kid, I'd like to see my mom) and then there's calling Reira by her first name too. It seems to me like Takumi raised him (or it could be Hachi accepts Ren into the family) and it could be that Takumi took custody of Ren and since we know he's such a workaholic... he'll do anything for Trapnest and to keep Reira's voice, even if it meant unburdening Reira with motherly responsibilities. Quite evil and manipulative but that's how I make Takumi lol xD
385 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / France brdx
Offline
Posted 12/16/08



Hehe yeah...
I don't really like participating in debates about entertainment but Nana is one of my favorite mangas and I can't help but participate in discussion here xD I hope we keep it civil haha

As for who's little Ren's mom, it's a bit confusing at this point because... there are hints that could point to Reira (one night stand w/ Takumi being the most effective one because look what happened to Hachi lol) but then there are also hints that could point to Hachi (Satsuki talking about four of them as a family.. kid Ren calling Reira by her name).

For now... I do lean a little bit to Reira being the mother.. because when I think about it.. it seems as though little Ren doesn't even know his own mother... I don't recall him wanting to see Hachi (if I was a kid, I'd like to see my mom) and then there's calling Reira by her first name too. It seems to me like Takumi raised him (or it could be Hachi accepts Ren into the family) and it could be that Takumi took custody of Ren and since we know he's such a workaholic... he'll do anything for Trapnest and to keep Reira's voice, even if it meant unburdening Reira with motherly responsibilities. Quite evil and manipulative but that's how I make Takumi lol xD


i agree with u..im as confuse but leaning more to reira by the way how our dear mangaka makes hachi go thru some tough time..but as i undersand i think when ren died they stop trapnest ,bcoz a friend from ren says that his steal waiting for trapnest 2get back 2gether (plus it could b the reason why reira stop singing~>ren's death..) so that makes takumi less of a bastard in ur eyes ..(personally i never believed he had any lovers,plus he didnt seemed to like it to have reira as one of his 'many' lovers..like he slept with her for her to feel better as u say hell do anything 4her.. )




3604 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / in a cave eh... n...
Offline
Posted 12/16/08

romatchka wrote:


tokwang_hilaw wrote:


romatchka wrote:


Kaara wrote:

kid Ren is Reira and Tamaki hello Tamaki slept with Reira come on we all know Tamaki dosn't use protection just look what happen to Hachi >_> And Reira would be one of the only people to call there son son ren because she cared for him a lot
that and every thing thats happen in the manga point to it if u can understand yazawas story style


i know that it could (highly is) reira son's (just by the way the story is written,it wouldnt supriz anyone)but when u read this page,you get the feeling that its hachi's son.Its like the 4are happy 2gether familly,and without a third party who has custody of the kid..i dont think reira is the type to give birth and give the baby away to takumi.
Plus ren was someone very important to everyone so all of them could have name their child ren.
i changed my mind..when you hear reira talk about kid ren it really doesnt sound as if shes talking about her son...

http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/09/
http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/16/ ~>doesnt sound as if she picked the name herself..


Hmm... nice point there.. and now I'm having second thoughts ahaha xD Yazawa likes to keep us guessing I suppose lol

http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/09/
From this page, when Reira said she should've hated him.. who could she be talking about? Takumi? Ren for dying? or little kid Ren for being Takumi and Hachi's son? The latter could be a very good reasoning and the fact that kid Ren calls Reira by her name not mommy... http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/74/13/

Interesting... I hope the next issue will clear things up for us ^^


me to...but u should read kaara point of view she's cleary has made up her mind,and its not stupid what she has to say ..but she could b nicer


hehe sorry if it sounded mean bad days for me stressfull this what i do when i need to let of steam actally this is nothing compared to what i wrote on the one othe other fourm on the NANA page to do with this same thing.....and soo but know whats fun to do when waiting for NANA to be posted on onemanga read the other works by Ai Yazawa Neighborhood story is grate and it kills alot of time

24 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
36 / F / wherever it is...
Offline
Posted 12/24/08
Will there be a posibility that Sachiko & little kid Ren are twin sister & brother?
30 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
37 / F / Canada
Offline
Posted 12/26/08

romatchka wrote:


tokwang_hilaw wrote:


yoshi28 wrote:


beta178 wrote:

I'm so confused, Why in the anime, the last episode # 47 starts with in the future and they said that ren is still alive, so he is not going to be dead, or they changed that on the anime?


nope is the same in the manga! I still don't know why he's pretending to be dead , thought maybe cause of the drugs problems ,but you see it clearly when theres a glimps of the future that Ren is still alive and that he is looking for Nana who dissapear but the last chapter got me confuse cause Hachi's kid can't remember her name was praying to Ren's grave. I'm getting really confuse with this manga!!


The 'Ren' they're referring in the future is the little kid... Ren.. I believe he's Takumi and Reira's son. It's confirmed adult Ren is really dead.. latest chapters available in Onemanga T__T


kid ren is rreally Takumi and Reira's?or u thinkk its the case?i thaught it wa's hachis son 2


How can that be ? I clearly saw an adult Ren talking with Hachi about Nana in one of the chapters it was in the entrence of the appart they use to live in (Nana & Hachi) and Hachi's kid was like 4 or 5 years old , I got to check it out but it was in one of the old chapters !!!
Member
1060 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / F / CA
Offline
Posted 1/6/09

yoshi28 wrote:


romatchka wrote:


tokwang_hilaw wrote:


yoshi28 wrote:


beta178 wrote:

I'm so confused, Why in the anime, the last episode # 47 starts with in the future and they said that ren is still alive, so he is not going to be dead, or they changed that on the anime?


nope is the same in the manga! I still don't know why he's pretending to be dead , thought maybe cause of the drugs problems ,but you see it clearly when theres a glimps of the future that Ren is still alive and that he is looking for Nana who dissapear but the last chapter got me confuse cause Hachi's kid can't remember her name was praying to Ren's grave. I'm getting really confuse with this manga!!


The 'Ren' they're referring in the future is the little kid... Ren.. I believe he's Takumi and Reira's son. It's confirmed adult Ren is really dead.. latest chapters available in Onemanga T__T


kid ren is rreally Takumi and Reira's?or u thinkk its the case?i thaught it wa's hachis son 2


How can that be ? I clearly saw an adult Ren talking with Hachi about Nana in one of the chapters it was in the entrence of the appart they use to live in (Nana & Hachi) and Hachi's kid was like 4 or 5 years old , I got to check it out but it was in one of the old chapters !!!


Maybe you were talking about this page but it's shin... he grew much taller and with that attire, he actually kinda looks like Ren at first glance^^
http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/62/09/

Member
12 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25
Offline
Posted 1/10/09
i think that the ren junior is probably Reira's child too from takumi. judging from how hachi might react, she would either refuse to raise ren which might cause them to seperate(not divorce since she told junko that she doesnt intend to divorce him), or she would accept ren and raise him to try and save her family but later on couldnt handle takumi for being away so long or somthing...

and i dont think thats the link that yoshi was talking about (ren's appearance) its much earlier...but the thing is, if he was alive... why would they go grave sweeping?? so i guess he really is dead. i think the whole point of the story is to show nana's strength and how she was able to live and not die off with ren like she would have probably wanted... am i making any sense?
49 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / Phils.
Offline
Posted 2/2/09
Yeah, its depressing and it took me by surprise as well. Right now I'm really agitated for the next chapters. I hope every characters pull through. I also hope that the coming chapters reveals what happened to Nana O. I'm worried about her at this point. Especially because of the promise she had with Ren that when he dies he would take him with her.
Member
12 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25
Offline
Posted 2/7/09
oh dont worry i dont think she would kill herself or anything... there are things that she said, like things that keeps her alive, and wanting her to live. she did think of dieing countless times but i think knowing that hachiko is waiting for her and all the love she gave her will keep her from doing anything reckless like taking away her life.
4532 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / sand village
Offline
Posted 2/19/09
omg!! u have no idea how many times ive cried in this anime especially when i heard reiras new song some lyrics (but i hate reira) the lyrics "we never promised but dont let go of my hand
8 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
36 / F
Offline
Posted 3/8/09
IS REN TUKUMI’S CHILD OR NOBU’S? The last time Nana had her period before her pregnancy was July 6(vol 8 ch 26, pg 6). So that is the next day after Trapnet's tour ended which was July 5 (Vol 5, ch 16, pg 3). She ofcourse slept with Tukumi that night. So she would be ovulating exactly 2 weeks from then, which is July 20. The next time she sees Tukumi is in exactly 2 weeks(vol 6 ch 20, pg 1). She mentions that she hasnt heard from him in 2 weeks and that night when Nobu walked her home, Tukumi showed up infront of her apartment. The next person she sleeps with after that is again Tukumi on July 29th, when Blast have their performance. Then 2 days after that is the first time she sleeps with Nobu. She has a relationship with Nobu till Aug 31 ( 9 days after the firewords which were on Aug 22(vol 7ch23 pg 12). On the night of Aug 31 Tukumi shows up at Hachi's door and finds she is pregnant.
So during the possible dates of ovulation/conception which are July 19-21, she only was with Tukumi. Another pointer ofcourse is the fact that Nobu used condoms each time. Now why does Ren have Nobu's hair? I dont know about that. He seems to have Tukumi's eyes! Anyway I am quite positive it is Tukumi's child because of the dates that I have calculated and I hope you are convinced too.

784 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
66 / F / California
Offline
Posted 3/27/09
This is like friggin crazy. I have no idea that I can cry this much just by reading the manga. Friends recommend it long time ago, but I hesitate and never want to read it, but now i'm in the middle of happy because I read such a "complicated" manga or I wish I didn't start it, because I want more and I can't believe the wy things happened.
8 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
36 / F
Offline
Posted 4/4/09
I have come across this wonderful site which a lot of raws and many shoujo manga. You can go to this site for a quick summary of chapter 82 of Nana (scroll 1/4th of the page and you should see it)

http://tatsukida.pitas.com/

And if you are looking for the latest raws for Nana (currently chapter 82) you can go to:
http://comic.sky-fire.com/HTML/NANA/

Happy reading:)
1932 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / In your fucking h...
Offline
Posted 8/4/09
all i want is nobu and hachi together thats all sorry if i misspelled the names
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.