First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
Post Reply Manga Discussion
17 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 8/24/09
isn't the little Ren is Sachiko older brother?? if that's the case, Little Ren can't be Reira's child. And and who is this Tamaki, isn't Hachii husband's name is called Takumi???
Member
1354 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / North America
Offline
Posted 9/18/09 , edited 9/18/09

tokwang_hilaw wrote:


romatchka wrote:


tokwang_hilaw wrote:


yoshi28 wrote:


beta178 wrote:

I'm so confused, Why in the anime, the last episode # 47 starts with in the future and they said that ren is still alive, so he is not going to be dead, or they changed that on the anime?


nope is the same in the manga! I still don't know why he's pretending to be dead , thought maybe cause of the drugs problems ,but you see it clearly when theres a glimps of the future that Ren is still alive and that he is looking for Nana who dissapear but the last chapter got me confuse cause Hachi's kid can't remember her name was praying to Ren's grave. I'm getting really confuse with this manga!!


The 'Ren' they're referring in the future is the little kid... Ren.. I believe he's Takumi and Reira's son. It's confirmed adult Ren is really dead.. latest chapters available in Onemanga T__T


kid ren is rreally Takumi and Reira's?or u thinkk its the case?i thaught it wa's hachis son 2


I believe it to be the case even though it's not directly said in the manga. Satchiko mentioned in both manga and anime about her younger brother (step-bro to be exact)... but Hachi was never pregnant for the second time and from the future segments, I found a quite simple but meaningful panel between Reira and kid Ren. It was a close-up shot of their holding hands.. as if to show they're somehow connected.
http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/70/22/


Hi guys i finished reading the manga last summer i think..as you guys remembered(people who read the manga)..takumi treasured reira very much that he couldnt do it with reira cz he feels he doesnt deserve her, she's like an angel from heaven cz it made takumi's mom's life longer because reira always sings and visited her in the hospital, they only had an intense kiss+touch, but they didnt do it..and also guys in the anime season one and also in the manga, its still not confirmed if the eldest child is nobu's or takumi's but as you saw in the manga the eldest shild i think is nobu's if the ren kid has blonde hair.. and hachiko told sachiko(second child: takumi's the dad) that her father and her nii-chan(older brother) is together. Therefore, hachiko has two kids. Remember that even in the future takumi and hachiko still fights therefore the ren kid and takumi is together in another country and sachiko stayed with her mom.
Member
27 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / in cyberspace
Offline
Posted 11/25/09
*sigh* Ok, why do so many people think that Takumi slept with Reira, he kissed her...kissed her...lol. But I truly belive that Ren is Nobu and Nana's kid. The blonde hair is a dead givaway to me, plus, he is older than Sa-chan. I believe Sa-chan is Takumi and Nana's child. butt....darn it, then im thinking about where he was (Ren) when they showed the flashies of them in the future...*exhales* I never thought about that until now....idk, hopely the author will come back and solve this puzzling riddle!

But about Ren (Nana O.) omgosh! I never cried so hard for an anime/manga in my life. That really broke my heart! and then for the hiatus to begin at such a crutial point...that was cruel...very cruel!
Member
2063 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / F
Offline
Posted 1/24/10
I read all this opinions, and I'm so confused too. I don't know if it can be possible, but when I finished the last chapter of the manga I was thinking that little Ren could be Reira's and Takumi's child (because I think they were together, it was not only that famous kiss, I remember that something more happened between them). Then something else came up to my mind, what if it is Nana Osaki and Ren's child, and that maybe Nana after giving birth disappeared and then Hachi and Takumi took care of little Ren??? Can it be possible??? I don't know what to think, but it seems that the hiatus came right at the most crucial point. Does anyone know what is going on and how long is it going to last?

And I really wanted Hachi to be with Nobuo...Can't wait for the manga to continue..
Member
1696 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / Soul Society
Offline
Posted 3/4/10
Im glad TAKUMI is still alive
480 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / Scotland
Offline
Posted 3/16/10 , edited 3/16/10
Ah, really sad nana is still on hiatus =( but we should thank our lucky stars that it's not cancelled =) lets hope Yazawa gets well soon.

In regards to who's child is Ren, I think in all honesty that he is Hachi and Takumi's. The "moment" ( @ http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/70/22/ ) that someone previously referred to that Reira and little Ren had, I think is just some connection she feels with him because he possibly reminds her of older Ren? Considering she seems to be admiring his song, maybe he has inspired her again?

The reason I feel that little Ren is Hachi's and not Reira's is because of this - http://www.onemanga.com/Nana/70/22/ - "Nana will insist on taking him back" (bearing in mind that Takumi calls Hachi Nana and it's unlikely they're talking about Nana O, since she's missing at he time)
"...suffering because of his parents"

Of course we haven't seen Hachi pregnant again to confirm this, but is it necessary? We're skipping from past to future and whatnot, we haven't seen everything inbetween so we don't know.

=)
56 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F
Offline
Posted 5/31/10
The scene with Reira and kid Ren might also be inspired because Reira says earlier in the manga that she won't sing for anybody but Ren. Also, Hachi tells older Ren that she wants to name her child after him, so wouldn't it make sense that after his death she would name her child Ren? Its been a while since I've read the manga but those were some key scenes that stuck with me, and the incident with older Ren
22 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 7/17/10
whoa whoa!!!!!! isn't the manga on HIATUS?????
Member
176 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / Stafford
Offline
Posted 7/26/10
ahh!!! i want this to contiune... but 1 thing for sure i never thought that Ren was Reira's son =S, now i'm all confused ;.; i want it to contiune
I'm sorry if you don't agree but this is my conclusion to who is Ren's mother

But to solve the issue with not seeing her pergent again.... erm couldnt she have had twins, she did have sex with both tukami and nobu, this could relate to how diff they look.
tbh i think Ren is Nobu while Satsaki is Tukami =D and tbh they both look the similar to Nana (Hachi). And come on if the kid wasn't Nanas why would she take him off Tukami for the holidays, to be honest I don't think she would ask about him how ren is doing if he wasn't hers. She still seem fairly worried about him too =S (http://www.1000manga.com/Nana/70/17/) and she did also call him brother when she was talking to Satsaki. And Ren doesn't like Japan either so that might be why he doesn't mation his mum (Nana) because he doesn't want to live there, he wants to live in London. This is why he's also so close to the Tapest (based in London) aswell, while Satsaki is close to the Black Stones(based in Japan).

I really can't see tukami sleeping with Reira. She is too much of a sister to him and something that can't be touched like an Angel aswell. Not to mation I don't think Reira would give her son to Nana she hates her cuz she's married to Tukami. I more think that she can't hate the kid because she sees a lot of the real Ren in him meaning she can't hate him (he's still a kid so he has his own personility). I think the reason she wants to hate him is because she wanted tukami for herself but she couldn't have him cuz Nana was pregent and kid Ren is related to that issue. And on top of that Reira isn't a singer anymore, if she had her own kid she would look after him herself.
Posted 7/27/10
Yeah Ren's parentage is really confusing. I thought it was Reira and Takumi's son at first, but I heard from someone that it is actually Hachi and Nobu's son, but I have no idea WHY Takumi would bring Nobu's son to England. Unless he doesn't know? But really the kid looks nothing like him. It's really confusing. And I thought Ren looked older than Satsuki too, which would mean that he is actually the first child that broke Hachi and Nobu up So that would explain why Takumi is raising the child like his own, though it is completely selfish and twisted for him to take the kid away from his real parents.

And Reira did sleep with Takumi at least once, but it wasn't drawn, just implied. Takumi knew it was the only way to keep that depressive idiot happy, so he "sacrificed" his feelings.
Member
176 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / Stafford
Offline
Posted 7/28/10
I do realyl think Ren is Nobus tho. And Takumi did say he was gona look after the baby no matter whos it is. But yeh I still don't get why little Ren would be in london. It does say that he doesn't want to go back to Japan, but not how he got there in the first place =S. And Why hes with Takumi? Maybe it is just cuz he teaching him music ( I'm reali not sure on that 1.) But I could see why Nana(Hachi) would have named her son Ren, Older Ren did say the nicest name there are, are the names of flowers like mine. Thats how her draughters name Satsaki was picked. And if he was the first born, she might have done him Ren for (Rocker)Nana.
Ok, i just took it that he only kissed her. I don't think takumi cares about being selfish or not, I swear it was just a competition to who was gonna get Nana (Hachi) with Nobu .
I would have never thought he did =S, i really dont get why she wants to be with him though??? Then again she can have him as long as Nana (Hachi) gets back with Nobu. (which so isn't gonna happen )
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.