First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
Hana Yori Dango vs Meteor Garden
14619 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F
Offline
Posted 11/17/08 , edited 11/17/08
I've seen a Hana Kimi japan vs Hana Kimi taiwan but i havent seen a HYD vs MG yet(:
or so i think..lol

So here are my questions...
Who played the better?

Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao or Barbie Xu
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun or Vic Zhou
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota or Ken Zhu
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi or Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? HYD or MG
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun or Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?
For me I love HYD!(:
Everything about it.....the cast,storyline,scenary,etc..
the characters are so so much better looking and "younger"
Plus my favorite people are in it...Mao,Jun,Shun etc..
188 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
35 / F / Banjarmasin, Indo...
Offline
Posted 11/17/08

happipplrock wrote:

I've seen a Hana Kimi japan vs Hana Kimi taiwan but i havent seen a HYD vs MG yet(:
or so i think..lol

So here are my questions...
Who played the better?

Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao or Barbie Xu
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun or Vic Zhou
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota or Ken Zhu
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi or Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? HYD or MG
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun or Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?



hemmm,,i cant compare those dramas,, i like both, each of them has plus/minus n attractiveness,,
those are so amazing n honestly, 4 me very2 unforgettable...hehehehe....

well,, bout ur question,,( i cant choose both huh?? )
hemmm.... i would say that :
1.inoue mao
2.matsujun
3.vic chou
4.matsuda shota
5.abe tsuyoshi
6.MG
7.maotsujun
8.HYD

2056 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / zamboanga city
Offline
Posted 11/17/08

happipplrock wrote:

I've seen a Hana Kimi japan vs Hana Kimi taiwan but i havent seen a HYD vs MG yet(:
or so i think..lol

So here are my questions...
Who played the better?

Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao or Barbie Xu
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun or Vic Zhou
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota or Ken Zhu
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi or Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? HYD or MG
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun or Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?
for me its...
For me I love HYD way better(:
Everything about it.....the cast,storyline,scenary,etc..


well form me, i love meteor garden.,

the cast the story line, is also good .,

hana yori dango japanese., hmmm it's like., no comments theirs no trilled.,
1359 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27
Offline
Posted 11/17/08

happipplrock wrote:

I've seen a Hana Kimi japan vs Hana Kimi taiwan but i havent seen a HYD vs MG yet(:
or so i think..lol

So here are my questions...
Who played the better?

Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao or Barbie Xu
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun or Vic Zhou
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota or Ken Zhu
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi or Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? HYD or MG
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun or Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?
for me its...
For me I love HYD way better(:
Everything about it.....the cast,storyline,scenary,etc..


HYD characteres are apparently hotter, when i first saw MG and saw the F4, i was like "vomit, vomit" but i grow on him and even think he's cute in the end.

HYD ALL THE WAY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2056 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / zamboanga city
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
meteor garden.
2743 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / F / St. Louis
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
Makino Tsukushi? Inoue
Domyoji Tsukasa? Jerry
Hanazawa Rui? Both
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota
Mimasaka Akira? Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? MG
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun
Overall which one is your favorite? HYD
987 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / one of a kind pla...
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
Makino Tsukushi?Inoue Mao
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi
Which drama had the better F4? HYD
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun

OVERALL:
Hana Yori Dango
**hyd is perfect in every way its short,but really has a lot of details and they dont spend a million episodes in one
problem(like when domyouji lost his memory-in meteor garden it was like hmm...10 eps?)
no offense though..meteor garden was my first drama in another language besides filipino and american..and i loved it(!)
but hyd is really far better than meteor garden
Posted 11/17/08 , edited 11/17/08
Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi
Which drama had the better F4? HYD
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun

HYD is better than MG because I've watched MG, but my opinion, season two just ruined it ''-.-

352 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / california
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
HYD.....
i liked the story for HYD alot better than MG...but F4 in MG were really hot!!!!!
1019 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
HYD..
but I also loved MG, it was like one of my first dramas(besides TVBs LOL) , so it was really memorable.
Makino Tsukushi: MAO CHAN was the BEST!!!
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan (can't choose)
Hanazawa Rui? Vic
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota
Mimasaka Akira? Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? MG
Which couple do you like better? jun & mao all the way!!!
12723 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Malaysia the land...
Offline
Posted 11/17/08

happipplrock wrote:

I've seen a Hana Kimi japan vs Hana Kimi taiwan but i havent seen a HYD vs MG yet(:
or so i think..lol

So here are my questions...
Who played the better?

Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao or Barbie Xu
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun or Vic Zhou
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota or Ken Zhu
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi or Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? HYD or MG
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun or Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?
For me I love HYD!(:
Everything about it.....the cast,storyline,scenary,etc..
the characters are so so much better looking and "younger"
Plus my favorite people are in it...Mao,Jun,Shun etc..


1) Inoue Mao
2) Jerry Yan
3) Oguri Shun
4) Matsuda Shota
5) Vanness Wu
6) MG
7) None
8) MG

Extra comment: Honestly the Japan version would have been so much better if Matsumoto Jun didn't ruin it for me..I don't like his acting at all.
11501 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
well i like hana yori dango better (:
237 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / Torrance, CA
Offline
Posted 11/17/08

happipplrock wrote:

I've seen a Hana Kimi japan vs Hana Kimi taiwan but i havent seen a HYD vs MG yet(:
or so i think..lol

So here are my questions...
Who played the better?

Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao or Barbie Xu
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun or Vic Zhou
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota or Ken Zhu
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi or Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? HYD or MG
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun or Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?
For me I love HYD!(:
Everything about it.....the cast,storyline,scenary,etc..
the characters are so so much better looking and "younger"
Plus my favorite people are in it...Mao,Jun,Shun etc..


- Inoue Mao is definitely better than Barbie Xu.
- Jerry Yan is better
- Vic Zhou is better
- Matsuda Shota is better
- Vaness Wu is better
I think Taiwanese F4 is better because they look more like friends in MG. They hang out together more. But, I like Matsumoto Jun and Inoue Mao better as couple.

I love both of dramas though.. I wonder how the Korean version going to be. They probably suck.
1009 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / Cee-dee-oh-cee, P...
Offline
Posted 11/17/08 , edited 11/17/08

happipplrock wrote:

I've seen a Hana Kimi japan vs Hana Kimi taiwan but i havent seen a HYD vs MG yet(:
or so i think..lol

So here are my questions...
Who played the better?

Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao or Barbie Xu
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun or Vic Zhou
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota or Ken Zhu
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi or Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? HYD or MG
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun or Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?
For me I love HYD!(:
Everything about it.....the cast,storyline,scenary,etc..
the characters are so so much better looking and "younger"
Plus my favorite people are in it...Mao,Jun,Shun etc..


Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao
Domyoji Tsukasa? JunMatsu! :)
Hanazawa Rui? Vic Zhou is better, though I also like Shun. :)
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota
Mimasaka Akira? Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? MG.. =)
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun
Overall which one is your favorite?
Love both! =)

13214 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
47
Offline
Posted 11/17/08 , edited 11/17/08
everything's flawless n HYD---....
well n MG---you'll notice that the f4 can't act.....n etc..----
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.