First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
Hana Yori Dango vs Meteor Garden
566 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
35 / F / PHILIPPINES
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
i love evrything in MG
66 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F
Offline
Posted 11/17/08

Who played the better?
Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao or Barbie Xu - cant choose.. Inoue Mao was prettier but i dunno which one acted better
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun or Vic Zhou
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota or Ken Zhu
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi or Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? HYD or MG
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun or Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?

METEOR GARDEN ALL THE WAY!!! HYD wasnt as exciting as MG.
also MG's f4 is sooooo much better! vic zhou is hot hot HOT !
im a meteor garden fan forever <3
lol i LOVE it!
except MG2 was pretty lame.. dragged on for wayy too long.
12158 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / ╰☆ 没有黑暗の地方╭☆
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
HYD beats MG anyday! loved it <3 though the movie didn't live up to my expectations
3591 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / in MICKEY YOOCHUN...
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
i like hyd better!!!
233 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / out of coverage area
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
Barbie Xu
Jerry Yan
Vic Zhou
Ken Zhu
Vanness Wu
MG
Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?
MG, idid not find HYD interesting
19005 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Los Angeles
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
loved hyd it was the best!!!!!!!!
didn't really like meteor garden though...
183 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
Makino Tsukushi: Inoue Mao
Domyoji Tsukasa: Matsumoto Jun
Hanazawa Rui: Oguri Shun
Nishikado Sojiro: Matsuda Shota
Mimasaka Akira: Abe Tsuyoshi
Which drama had the better F4: HANA YORI DANGO! 8D
Which couple do you like better: Maotsujun! :D
Overall which one is your favorite:
HANA YORI DANGO FTW! :D
im sorry but i dont like meteor garden.
PLUS the cast in HYD is better
PLUS the cast is better looking ^^
HAHA. but this is personal preference i guess
-shrugs shoulders-
373 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
47 / F / Wisconsin
Offline
Posted 11/17/08
Hmmm Good question....(s)....lol

All in all HYD was truer to the manga (which I'm still reading...long thing aint it) and in my opinion better as a whole (HYD --both seasons and final). MG would be closer if I could throw out MG2 (though good, I think too much was packed into it creating a feeling of it lacking substance at the end), but in he end I think HYD still woulda come out ahead.

As for choosing actors between the two ...ehhh, its a bit hard.

Lets just call the choice a draw for the most part,,,I mean if you sit back and try and imagine the actors switching series'...ehhh it kinda fit the way it went..though in the case of Rui....ehhh I could almost see that going either way.
Which had the better F4? ehh...lol it went the way it went...I really see HYD's f4 as is and MG as is.
607 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / F / Paris, France
Offline
Posted 11/17/08

IDoNotKnowOk wrote:
Honestly the Japan version would have been so much better if Matsumoto Jun didn't ruin it for me..I don't like his acting at all.


Really? Matsujun is what made the entire series, for me. I say this not as a fan of him but as a fan of the show - I actually held off on watching it for a while after discovering him.

I've only watched clips of MG and marathoned the entire HYD series, so I can't judge fairly which I one I like better. Or maybe I can, on the basis that I watched both seasons in half a week even though I had heard of MG like five years beforehand XD
12723 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Malaysia the land...
Offline
Posted 11/17/08

agentduckiechan wrote:


IDoNotKnowOk wrote:
Honestly the Japan version would have been so much better if Matsumoto Jun didn't ruin it for me..I don't like his acting at all.


Really? Matsujun is what made the entire series, for me. I say this not as a fan of him but as a fan of the show - I actually held off on watching it for a while after discovering him.

I've only watched clips of MG and marathoned the entire HYD series, so I can't judge fairly which I one I like better. Or maybe I can, on the basis that I watched both seasons in half a week even though I had heard of MG like five years beforehand XD


Yes...I honestly don't like his acting. But its just my opinion ...there is no right or wrong when it comes to this. MG was very boring but HYD was more boring
2056 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / zamboanga city
Offline
Posted 11/17/08

ettenoj wrote:

Barbie Xu
Jerry Yan
Vic Zhou
Ken Zhu
Vanness Wu
MG
Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?
MG, idid not find HYD interesting


yah you're right meteor garden really rocks

especially the F4.,
2056 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / zamboanga city
Offline
Posted 11/17/08

ilove_xo wrote:


Who played the better?
Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao or Barbie Xu - cant choose.. Inoue Mao was prettier but i dunno which one acted better
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun or Vic Zhou
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota or Ken Zhu
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi or Vanness Wu
Which drama had the better F4? HYD or MG
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun or Jerry and Barbie
Overall which one is your favorite?

METEOR GARDEN ALL THE WAY!!! HYD wasnt as exciting as MG.
also MG's f4 is sooooo much better! vic zhou is hot hot HOT !
im a meteor garden fan forever <3
lol i LOVE it!
except MG2 was pretty lame.. dragged on for wayy too long.


who played better?

of course the meteor garden.
607 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / F / Paris, France
Offline
Posted 11/17/08 , edited 11/17/08

IDoNotKnowOk wrote:


agentduckiechan wrote:


IDoNotKnowOk wrote:
Honestly the Japan version would have been so much better if Matsumoto Jun didn't ruin it for me..I don't like his acting at all.


Really? Matsujun is what made the entire series, for me. I say this not as a fan of him but as a fan of the show - I actually held off on watching it for a while after discovering him.

I've only watched clips of MG and marathoned the entire HYD series, so I can't judge fairly which I one I like better. Or maybe I can, on the basis that I watched both seasons in half a week even though I had heard of MG like five years beforehand XD


Yes...I honestly don't like his acting. But its just my opinion ...there is no right or wrong when it comes to this. MG was very boring but HYD was more boring


Well, don't worry, I won't hold your opinion against you. I'm a big girl and can take criticism of people I like, LOL. But seriously, I thought he was brilliant as Domyouji. Not "brainy" brilliant (indeed, Domyouji is a complete idiot), but I mean that he truly captured Domyouji for me, and I'm sure that Domyouji has become a very big part of him (especially after the success of HYD and his own DoS image within Arashi). I'm sure the people who watched MG first feel the same way about Jerry Yan. It also helps that someone wrote a really funny recap of Season One on Livejournal, and that's what got me to watch the whole thing
449 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / cali
Offline
Posted 11/17/08 , edited 11/17/08
Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao or Barbie Xu both
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun or Jerry Yan both
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun or Vic Zhou definately can't decide both are like my fav actors
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota or Ken Zhu shota
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi or Vanness Wu vanness
Which drama had the better F4? HYD or MG mg
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun or Jerry and Barbie matsojun if it was barbie and vic... then definately that couple ^_^
Overall which one is your favorite? hm...not sure prob mg


overall both were good... but if you go for second season i would have to say HYD II was better than MG2....
885 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / F / somewhere out the...
Offline
Posted 11/18/08
Makino Tsukushi? Inoue Mao
Domyoji Tsukasa? Matsumoto Jun
Hanazawa Rui? Oguri Shun /Vic zhou
Nishikado Sojiro? Matsuda Shota
Mimasaka Akira? Abe Tsuyoshi
Which drama had the better F4? HYD
Which couple do you like better? Maotsujun
Overall which one is your favorite?
For me I love HYD!(:
i like the story better,, every episode is exciting....(unlike MG>>I got bored watching season @ T_T)
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.