Stephenie Thinks there should be no Breaking Dawn Movie.

[Orgininally taken from StephenieMeyer.com]

Q:I've heard you say that you think Breaking Dawn should be two movies. Why? Also, that it might be impossible to film. What does that mean?

If Breaking Dawn were ever made into a movie, it's hard to imagine it fitting into ninety minutes. The book is just so long! I can't imagine how to distill it—if I could, the book would be shorter. But maybe a screenwriter can see a way to do it and still cover the crucial plot points.

When I said that Breaking Dawn might be impossible to film, it's because of Renesmee. You can do almost anything with CGI these days—realistic dragons and dinosaurs and endless amounts of nonexistent creatures that blend right in with the real elements. Some of them look so real you forget they're not. However, the one thing that I've never seen is a CGI human being who truly looks real. An actress can't play Renesmee, at least not when she's a few days old; she's the size of a baby, but her expressions are totally controlled and aware. She would have to be a construct, and CGI isn't quite there yet. Of course, they develop amazing new technologies everyday, and we've got a little time left.

ahhhhh ..................

what???owwwwwwww.......thats kinda disappointing for the twilight fans....

i think shes right xD
im honest...i dont like the movie...i think the books are SO MUCH better
they shouldnt bring out more movies...just more books xD

maybe.. it'll be so hard to portray renesmee in a movie..teehee..

yeah. And you can't really find a child as old as renesmee that can speak clearly and etc. And don't forget the vampire clans.. that's going to be hard..

Pls! PLEASE! PLEASE! DON'T FLAME ME FOR THIS!
I know...that its WRONG to say this, but I'm being
100% honest! I don't think there should be a Breaking Dawn movie either.
I mean you got the XXX stuff there, the gory birthing of Renesmee,
the over-expensive wedding,the CLOTHES, the BURNING EDWARD,
the DYING BELLA, the Half Vamp half Humans bursting from there mothers.
Don't you think thats ALOT for a PG-13 movie?? Don't forget that there is
ALOT of info in this book too and I'm pretty sure they can't fit it into a 2-hour
movie. You know?
Also were in the WORLD are we going to find 10 or 20 different Renesmee's
aka little GIRLS and look like LITTLE PEOPLE. That ALL look alike! Thats ALOT of work, ya know?
So please don't flame me! PLEASE. Thats just why I think she won't do it.
It's depressing yes, but she wrote it, right? I mean I WAS looking forward to it[I guess]
but remeber the Twi-Movies are still fresh and we haven't even hit a New Moon movie yet!
and they're STILL picky on who's playing Jacob! So maybe give them sometime and maybe they'll change
from the HUGE fan service. Right??
~Yu-chan<3

PLEASE DO NOT FLAME ME! >.<

I don't wish there is a movie for Breaking Dawn.
I won't like it. Unless skipped the Isle Esme part...=.=

a big disappoinment 4 the twilight fans!!

though, let's say hardwicke didnt gv d best on the movie, coz she edited more scenes on the
buk,, its no fair dt it wud hv no breaking dawn movie,,ugh!
im more excied wd the nxt movie of d twilight saga!...huhu..

yeah. If there is one, it will maybe be rated 18+ or whatever I guess.

i think she needs to have it because it would not make sense did not read that book though but i know

aww. i would be disappointed if they'll not make a movie for breaking dawn.
that time, better CGI would probably be developed.

I Agree With You All The Way

A LOT, let me tell you that again, A LOT A LOTTT of kids under the age of 13 are STILL watching the Twilight Movie even if it is PG-13
Breaking Dawn will be TOO MUCH for them!

Yes! I totally agree! When I heard that ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS[I think...] and MIDDLE SCHOOLS[no I'm sure for this one...] are taking STUDENTS to the Twilight Movie...I was taken aback! I mean you have Human Hunting,that *minor* sex scene[mostly making out though],don't forget the ripping apart of James and BURNING his CARCUS! Thats not RIGHT!
Thats like taking a newborn to see Saw II<---okay I admit I'm exaggerating alot but still.
It's just...too much. TOO TOO much!
So yes, thank you for agreeing.
I LOVE Twilight to death[no pun attended] and I just think Breaking Dawn's already boardering on rated R.

*PLEASE NO FLAME*

yea i dont really think they should make the breaking dawn movie but they still should make more all the way till eclipse...there was an icon of a reneesme and it was so kawaii!!
i dont care if they make it a movie or not. if they do...then it'll be kind of awkward....and if they dont...ill be sad but relieved without the disturbing pictures in my head.....