First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
Post Reply Do you think Minato is Junichi's real sister? (as in related by blood)
Member
2967 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / X
Offline
Posted 12/8/08 , edited 12/18/08
I think it is a YES! In episode 10, Junichi basically says to his sister it is a taboo. If they weren't real siblings then he and everyone else would not have made a big deal of it. They also have the same last name... but I guess you could change that... or one of them could be adopted... Same hair and eye color... but it's an anime so you can't really compare characters. I Highly doubt that they are NOT related by blood. (Double negative is kinda confusing ay?) I guess because people want Minato and Junichi together so bad that they are willing to use "they are not blood related siblings " to justify their opinion. Man... Episode 10 was awesome... why did it take until the end of the season to start developing a plot in the story.

---
Although it is possible that they are not siblings... there is more evidence to support that they ARE sister and brother. I really don't understand why people really believe they are not. I guess I could understand that they WANT them not to be but wanting/hoping shouldn't be the samething as believing.
--
12/18/08

uuuh...uhhh... O..O...Oh...MG... It.... was... was... It... It... was... So UNEXPECTED... No... No... It can't ... no... no... nooo... wait... let me... lemme lemme check... waa-ait.... wait!... WHAT! umm... umm...I... I... guess... ya... I was... right... there's no... imposs... nooo... I was right... I never thought I... Me... Yo... could... be right... I... never... thought... the most likely thing... to happen... would happen... but... but... it... did. Wait... Wait... that-at-at means... "you where wrong?"... and "I was right?"... No Wa... Noooo... Couldn't be... I... I guess... It's... pro---bable... Nooo.... And... the... least likely thing to happen... didn't happen??... noo... no way. OMG... I'm so surprised... their... their blood related?... couldn't be... but... but... you guys said... noo... but... but... didn't you...? I'm spuh-spuh...speachless... my... my... my mouth... can't express how happy! I am right now... I... I... have fulfilled my purpose here... Lord... I... I'm ready to ascend into heaven now. Rapture me...
71 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
37 / M / Northwest U.S.A
Offline
Posted 12/8/08
Wikipedia states she is his younger sister
Member
2967 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / X
Offline
Posted 12/8/08
You do know that what wikipedia says isn't always correct, right? I could go to wikipedia right now and change it to older brother.
Member
2966 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Singapore
Offline
Posted 12/8/08
We can't say yes, either no because it a game based anime so ending can be happen many ways. So wait until the last episode! I hope she's not blood related! Wiki is not always correct.
sounji 
93 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / Florida
Offline
Posted 12/8/08
i am just going to say no lol and hope its no
Member
1409 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M
Offline
Posted 12/9/08
I'm hoping it's a no ^^ . But even if it ends up as a yes , MINATOXJUNICHI <33 so even if incest i dont care ! XD because they are so kawaii together <33
Member
1821 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M
Offline
Posted 12/9/08
i dun really care if she is blood related or not just i rea~~~ly hope dat she IS not blood related...and i think theres sum1 said dat jun is the adopted one not her....
Member
4492 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / M / RP~Ether of Heave...
Offline
Posted 12/9/08
putting the Hgame aside since the truth is told in Minato's route.

for this anime I hope they're not related, so at least
there will be a possible Jun'ichiXMinato end. (although chances of that happening are slim to none)

but even if they are siblings who cares INCEST is all good with me.
HOT SISTER IS HOT!
Member
905 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / United Kingdom
Offline
Posted 12/9/08
For a long time I have been going around saying that they're blood related.

But I've just now been told that apparently in the PS2 game they're not blood related.. WAT. Since the anime contains the PS2-only character, I have no clue anymore. I really hope they're still blood related though.. since it's so overused when the brother falls in love with his sister but she turns out to not be related to him.
Member
884 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F
Offline
Posted 12/9/08
Actually JohnyBeGood, I think you've got it mixed up. First of all, there is no way we could know if they are or if they are not. To me, and I'm not just saying this because I'm a Minato fan, it seems like they are not related. Why would they build up all this tension just to end up saying "Oh, so we are related? I guess I'll be with Yuuhi, then." Even if that did happen, he wouldn't just stop liking her. So the fact is that nobody other than the makers of this anime know the answer to that question. So the people saying "They aren't blood related!!" Are (in my opinion the right people) the ones that think it seems like they aren't blood related. And the people saying "Omg they are blood related!" are either just saying that because they think they're just automatically right, or because they're trying as hard as they can to make it seem like he'll end up with Yuuhi. Which, *ahem*, he won't. To me it really seems like they aren't blood-related and are gonna end up together. So yea, people can state their OPINIONS on whether they are or not, but you can't go around saying "THEY ARE!!!" or "THEY'RE NOT!!!" because you don't really know. And if you do go around saying if they are or not and thinking you're right, and then it turns out the other way, you're gonna feel like an idiot.

One last thing, he soooooooooo loves Minato! Yuuhi's just a stupid obstacle who's trying to ruin everything but, in the end, will not get Junichi.

TEAM MINATO!!!!!!!!!!!
Member
782 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26
Offline
Posted 12/9/08
i disagre cuze thats not the point in the anime, u can tell Juinchi will fall for Yuuhi, and ur prob right that there not blood related, this is a tricky topic.....hmmm...
824 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27
Offline
Posted 12/9/08
Well as far as the PC game goes, yes they are, so I've heard many many times. But if like Ahaemily says in the PS2 game they aren't related then they most likely are not going to be related in the anime as well since the anime is closer to the PS2 version I'm assuming, and the anime would most likely try to be T.V. friendly as much as possible so as far as the anime goes she's probably not (though I'm not sure) but since in the original game she is I voted yes.
Member
2967 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / X
Offline
Posted 12/9/08

kookoo14 wrote:

Actually JohnyBeGood, I think you've got it mixed up. First of all, there is no way we could know if they are or if they are not. To me, and I'm not just saying this because I'm a Minato fan, it seems like they are not related. Why would they build up all this tension just to end up saying "Oh, so we are related? I guess I'll be with Yuuhi, then." Even if that did happen, he wouldn't just stop liking her. So the fact is that nobody other than the makers of this anime know the answer to that question. So the people saying "They aren't blood related!!" Are (in my opinion the right people) the ones that think it seems like they aren't blood related. And the people saying "Omg they are blood related!" are either just saying that because they think they're just automatically right, or because they're trying as hard as they can to make it seem like he'll end up with Yuuhi. Which, *ahem*, he won't. To me it really seems like they aren't blood-related and are gonna end up together. So yea, people can state their OPINIONS on whether they are or not, but you can't go around saying "THEY ARE!!!" or "THEY'RE NOT!!!" because you don't really know. And if you do go around saying if they are or not and thinking you're right, and then it turns out the other way, you're gonna feel like an idiot.

One last thing, he soooooooooo loves Minato! Yuuhi's just a stupid obstacle who's trying to ruin everything but, in the end, will not get Junichi.

TEAM MINATO!!!!!!!!!!!


I never said I Liked Yuuhi? I actually like Minato but I don't like MinatoXJunichi But I Don't like incest (My opinions have nothing to do w/ what is true though, I just wanted to make clear my opinion). All because you hate Yuuhi doesn't make Minato a non blood related sister. If you read my post you would know I said that it there is a chance that I could be wrong. I never said I was absolutely right. I just said that there is alot more evidence to support Minato as a sister than Yuuhi. The only evidence I have heard from everyone else is "I hate Yuuhi" or "I love Minato". EXCEPT for


ahaemily wrote:

For a long time I have been going around saying that they're blood related.

But I've just now been told that apparently in the PS2 game they're not blood related.. WAT. Since the anime contains the PS2-only character, I have no clue anymore. I really hope they're still blood related though.. since it's so overused when the brother falls in love with his sister but she turns out to not be related to him.


Who actually gave a valid point. In the real H-game they are related. I don't know if your facts are right (I trust you though) but it makes sense that the ps2 version has non incest because incest would raise the rating. Ya, I'm not sure if there going to follow the Ps2 version or the actually adult VN?

Also I don't think you can actually use the VN to see who will end up with who but (Correct me if I'm wrong) doesn't this VN have different paths in which you could end up with different characters? This topic is not another "Who do you like better", "Would you want Minato to be blood related", or "MinatoXJunichi or YuuhiXJunichi". The question is do you "think" (Not want) Minato is a blood related sister.

Really like what did you see in my post? Did you some how see "YuuhiXJunichi4Eva"?, it is IMPOSSIBLE for Minato not to be blood related, or "ALL you people who believe minato is a not blood related! are WRONG." Once again I state that I never said that I was absolutely sure that she is blood related.

Doesn't the last part of what your saying contradict the point you were trying to make?


And if you do go around saying if they are or not and thinking you're right, and then it turns out the other way, you're gonna feel like an idiot.

One last thing, he soooooooooo loves Minato! Yuuhi's just a stupid obstacle who's trying to ruin everything but, in the end, will not get Junichi.


Yes... people can state their opinions and I have allowed them too. I stated my opinions and I also wanted to hear everyone elses. It's just when I said


Although it is possible that they are not siblings... there is more evidence to support that they ARE sister and brother. I really don't understand why people really believe they are not. I guess I could understand that they WANT them not to be but wanting/hoping shouldn't be the samething as believing.


I just always wondered why people would believe something when they have no evidence to support it.

Yes... I know I repeated alot of my points twice but it was to make sure what I said was Clearified. I do not want another misunderstanding.
Member
2967 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / X
Offline
Posted 12/9/08

tendayslate wrote:

Well as far as the PC game goes, yes they are, so I've heard many many times. But if like Ahaemily says in the PS2 game they aren't related then they most likely are not going to be related in the anime as well since the anime is closer to the PS2 version I'm assuming, and the anime would most likely try to be T.V. friendly as much as possible so as far as the anime goes she's probably not (though I'm not sure) but since in the original game she is I voted yes.


Although Incestry would probally help the show more than hurt it. You might be right about the TV friendly thing though. I wonder what type of channel this show is played on (that might be a clue to lead us closer to the truth). I'm not sure but I think the only thing different in the PS2 version and the PC is the H scenes, incestry, and the rich blonde girl. Most likely their wouldn't be H scenes even if it did follow the PC. It is kinda unknown if there actually is incestry. The only thing pulling us towards the ps2 version is the blond girl (I forgot her name). Well... I never played the ps2 version and there might be other things that push the show towards the ps2 version.

I think there are other shows that aired on TV that had incest so I don't think you can rule out incest being on TV but different Channels might make a difference.
824 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27
Offline
Posted 12/9/08


Just wondering why you think it would help the show more than hurt it? I'm sure most people don't want them to have a blood relation and a romantic relationship (though there are a few exceptions). And yes you are right there probably are other shows with incest on T.V. but they are very uncommon I am sure and if indeed the PS2 version did cut it out and the anime seems to be most likely based on the PS2 version then they most likely won't be blood related. You do have a point though with the channel thing. It probably does really depend on what channel they show it on. On a completely side note I would want to play a translated version of the PS2 game.
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.