First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
Post Reply Will he get his memory back??
1044 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
33 / F / Florida
Offline
Posted 12/22/08

Sai1Nonly wrote:

Nope. Index will learn sooner or later (seeing as how she's already catching on) that Touma lost his memory. Insert sad scene followed by a "it's okay because we can make new memories."

That's my two cents.


that sounds like what will happen.

or of course he gets his memory back and she loses hers because Touma's life is anything but fair.
Member
30569 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / The Pacific
Offline
Posted 12/24/08
As much I want him to get his memories back, he can't. They were destroyed.
129 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / F / Philippines
Offline
Posted 12/24/08 , edited 12/24/08
nope! but I like to think that there maybe someone who can manipulate time and space and let him see that forgotten past or maybe somekind of power that can heal him without being nullified by Touma's image breaker... hehehehe its a long shot but well you never know. ^__^V,,
129 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / F / Philippines
Offline
Posted 12/24/08

tenchikiss wrote:


Sai1Nonly wrote:

Nope. Index will learn sooner or later (seeing as how she's already catching on) that Touma lost his memory. Insert sad scene followed by a "it's okay because we can make new memories."

That's my two cents.


that sounds like what will happen.

or of course he gets his memory back and she loses hers because Touma's life is anything but fair.



waaaa That's sooo Touma. But I hope not. Thats totally unfair for both of them.

319 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / UnKnown
Offline
Posted 12/25/08
Well he might, just so they can add in a plot twist. Cause when you lose memories, gain new ones and new feelings, when the old memories come rushing back its almost like you have a split personality.
However there is the 95% chance that he wont, just to make it a different plot twist, though I think that getting his memories back would make a much better twist and draw the viewers in as its so unexpected.
212 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / Selangor, Malaysia
Offline
Posted 12/26/08
Din't the Doc said his brain cells got fried or something? Well, not like it matters, since the "New Toma" is exactly the same as the "Old Toma". I mean, really, his relationships with all the other characters haven't changed at all, have they? So I don't see the point of drawing up a plot to ensure he "gets his old memories back". What Sai1Nonly posted a few posts up is probably what's eventually gonna happen sometime in the series ... On a side note, its rather odd how he doesn't question how his past was/who his family is even though he's amnesic. Unless he's an orphan or something?
15 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / M / Massachusetts
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
my only question is if his hand can dispel all magic and powers how can it not dispel their after effects, as if i remember correctly he has already done this with "miko" bringing her back to life and all.

also another thing is if his memories are fried because brain cells are fried how do we not know that in the 103,000 volumes of different magics there isn't something that can reverse the damage done (so long as he doesn't touch his head to break the spell). but i think his Imagine Breaker works on the fact that he has to know what something was or happened before the effect to cause it to undo, so if he were to even have just a little bit of his previous life told to him he may be able to undo the damage to the brain cells concerning the damage to the that which he had learned and its relation to his other memories of that. I don't blame you if you get lost in that as it is very confusing trying to describe a non physical or intangible object.
212 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / Selangor, Malaysia
Offline
Posted 12/28/08
... Right. Indeed, I got lost about midway thru your description and skipped to the end of it.

Well, I think he could "undo" the miko's death because there was still something left to undo. That is to say, if she still had a heart, and asking her to die would stop it, then using his hand would make it beat again. However, he got his brain cells destroyed, so there was nothing for him to "undo". I mean, you can't really touch something that isn't there anymore, can you? Well, that's my take on it anyway. Might be right, might be wrong, doesn't really bother me much, since the shows still awesome even with a slightly amnesiac lead.
1189 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / Berkeley, Califor...
Offline
Posted 12/28/08

Aetheus wrote:

Din't the Doc said his brain cells got fried or something? Well, not like it matters, since the "New Toma" is exactly the same as the "Old Toma". I mean, really, his relationships with all the other characters haven't changed at all, have they? So I don't see the point of drawing up a plot to ensure he "gets his old memories back". What Sai1Nonly posted a few posts up is probably what's eventually gonna happen sometime in the series ... On a side note, its rather odd how he doesn't question how his past was/who his family is even though he's amnesic. Unless he's an orphan or something?


Touma isn't "exactly" the same.. he was more reclusive and withdrawn when he had his memories so many ppl wouldn't know him well enough to realize the difference, as well Index didn't have enough time or comfort to know him well enough b4 hand... As he is now he's less... umm Philosophical err... The wisdom and intelligence he had b4 (losing his memories) is no longer there.. For example... The scene that caused me to pick touma as one of my favorite characters of all time, was his lecture to magic swordsman girl.. I loved that scene and how he handled that situation... Other traits are gone too.. Such as his laziness and his reluctant nature to get involved with someone too much, ect...
1189 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / Berkeley, Califor...
Offline
Posted 12/28/08

superjosh wrote:

my only question is if his hand can dispel all magic and powers how can it not dispel their after effects, as if i remember correctly he has already done this with "miko" bringing her back to life and all.

also another thing is if his memories are fried because brain cells are fried how do we not know that in the 103,000 volumes of different magics there isn't something that can reverse the damage done (so long as he doesn't touch his head to break the spell). but i think his Imagine Breaker works on the fact that he has to know what something was or happened before the effect to cause it to undo, so if he were to even have just a little bit of his previous life told to him he may be able to undo the damage to the brain cells concerning the damage to the that which he had learned and its relation to his other memories of that. I don't blame you if you get lost in that as it is very confusing trying to describe a non physical or intangible object.


The after effects is a spell though... There are continuous spells (like Index's seal on her memory) and non-continuous (like a fire ball attack)... The one Touma suffered was a non... The after effects weren't magic, caused by but not magic, so there was no magic to dispelled...
Its like using a spell to destroy a building and having him touch it with the intent of the building fixing itself... wont work

As for bringing the miko back to life.. She wasn't dead in the first place... She was.. How do i say... More or less told to die... She was dying due to the influence of his spell that wouldn't end till she was fully dead, as you saw it wasn't a instant kill spell, and Touma dispelled it b4 it could fully kill her...

If Touma could dispell after effects then he could become a healer to those hurt by magic and even resurrect the dead, change vamp's back into humans, even bring back all the memories that Index lost.. If humans are god's creation then touching another human would eliminate them (god does seem to exist in some manner in there world)
Member
Erehe 
5156 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Heretic's Keep
Offline
Posted 12/28/08

Aetheus wrote:

... Right. Indeed, I got lost about midway thru your description and skipped to the end of it.

Well, I think he could "undo" the miko's death because there was still something left to undo. That is to say, if she still had a heart, and asking her to die would stop it, then using his hand would make it beat again. However, he got his brain cells destroyed, so there was nothing for him to "undo". I mean, you can't really touch something that isn't there anymore, can you? Well, that's my take on it anyway. Might be right, might be wrong, doesn't really bother me much, since the shows still awesome even with a slightly amnesiac lead.


Now, Now, The Miko is only found in the anime, Thus a creation of the J.C. Staff, The manga tells the real story.
212 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / Selangor, Malaysia
Offline
Posted 12/28/08

Erehe wrote:


Aetheus wrote:

... Right. Indeed, I got lost about midway thru your description and skipped to the end of it.

Well, I think he could "undo" the miko's death because there was still something left to undo. That is to say, if she still had a heart, and asking her to die would stop it, then using his hand would make it beat again. However, he got his brain cells destroyed, so there was nothing for him to "undo". I mean, you can't really touch something that isn't there anymore, can you? Well, that's my take on it anyway. Might be right, might be wrong, doesn't really bother me much, since the shows still awesome even with a slightly amnesiac lead.


Now, Now, The Miko is only found in the anime, Thus a creation of the J.C. Staff, The manga tells the real story.


She was? Well, then again, I did find it funny that the manga seemed to skip the Miko part of the anime, jumping straight to the Mikoto arc. I don't see the point in her creation, though, besides maybe providing a few filler episodes.
Member
Erehe 
5156 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Heretic's Keep
Offline
Posted 12/28/08

Aetheus wrote:


Erehe wrote:


Aetheus wrote:

... Right. Indeed, I got lost about midway thru your description and skipped to the end of it.

Well, I think he could "undo" the miko's death because there was still something left to undo. That is to say, if she still had a heart, and asking her to die would stop it, then using his hand would make it beat again. However, he got his brain cells destroyed, so there was nothing for him to "undo". I mean, you can't really touch something that isn't there anymore, can you? Well, that's my take on it anyway. Might be right, might be wrong, doesn't really bother me much, since the shows still awesome even with a slightly amnesiac lead.


Now, Now, The Miko is only found in the anime, Thus a creation of the J.C. Staff, The manga tells the real story.


She was? Well, then again, I did find it funny that the manga seemed to skip the Miko part of the anime, jumping straight to the Mikoto arc. I don't see the point in her creation, though, besides maybe providing a few filler episodes.


Purpose highlighted in bold, She only exists in the anime, same goes for Aurelous Izzard and his episode arc.
358 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / Singapore
Offline
Posted 12/29/08
Either way its fine.After all he's doing allright until now.
2343 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / Philippines
Offline
Posted 12/29/08
No but maybe just maybe he will cuz you know some anime makes miracle
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.