First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next  Last
Top Combine & DBSK
162 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / I LOVE BOJOONG
Offline
Posted 1/11/09
same producer......maybe the producer just ran out of ideas XD Top Combine will never be DBSK so it doesnt matter.
16058 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 1/12/09 , edited 1/12/09

quynhie wrote:



0__0 lipsynching on a ballad song? ive never heard of that before. well, you like them and i respect that but to me, they are just a regular ol' prettyboy boyband that has one or two talented members. nothing like dbsk like i said in my original post. im not bashing them or anything. its just my opinion. to each his own.

I'm pretty sure Fahrenheit and SJM has lipsynched ballads before...
I don't really judge music on how well the dance accompaniment is, so voice-wise alone, I prefer Zhang Yuan over any other current boyband member, except maybe Ryeowook.
And unless HOT regroups, Ma Xueyang's Cotton Candy beats any of the other songs that boyband members have written.
I guess it depends on your definition of talent, then... Micky and Junsu are the only one I consider half-talented in DBSK.
but since I don't really care about dancing, for all I know, Yunho could be a really good dancer.
Posted 1/13/09

idarklight wrote:


quynhie wrote:



0__0 lipsynching on a ballad song? ive never heard of that before. well, you like them and i respect that but to me, they are just a regular ol' prettyboy boyband that has one or two talented members. nothing like dbsk like i said in my original post. im not bashing them or anything. its just my opinion. to each his own.

I'm pretty sure Fahrenheit and SJM has lipsynched ballads before...
I don't really judge music on how well the dance accompaniment is, so voice-wise alone, I prefer Zhang Yuan over any other current boyband member, except maybe Ryeowook.
And unless HOT regroups, Ma Xueyang's Cotton Candy beats any of the other songs that boyband members have written.
I guess it depends on your definition of talent, then... Micky and Junsu are the only one I consider half-talented in DBSK.
but since I don't really care about dancing, for all I know, Yunho could be a really good dancer.



That's cool. We all have our own preferences.
537 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / malaysia
Offline
Posted 1/13/09
who r these Top combine??
another boyband??
95 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 1/13/09

quynhie wrote:


huangmeixi wrote:


quynhie wrote:



0__0 lipsynching on a ballad song? ive never heard of that before. well, you like them and i respect that but to me, they are just a regular ol' prettyboy boyband that has one or two talented members. nothing like dbsk like i said in my original post. im not bashing them or anything. its just my opinion. to each his own.


DBSK is sorely lacking something for how long they've been doing this...and they certainly weren't better than Top Combine went they debuted, especially considering Top Combine went through like two months of training and Junsu went through eight years.

I can't get the sense that anyone of them love music as much as two of the members in Top Combine (Zhang and Ma). The only one maybe is Micky. Maybe Junsu, but considering he was so young when he trained I don't even know if he had time to consider what he loved.

Jaejoong is good at singing, but he's given songs, he sings them and that's it. Yunho can't rap, and his dancing in five years hasn't improved.

I give them credit for working nonstop but in terms of musical artists, I see that in Top Combine more. They may still fail and never live up to that potential, but for right now, they have potential. That's my two cents. Not bashing on anyone and should probably leave before the DBSk fans come and kill me.



haha dont worry, i cant speak for the rest of dbsk fans but i respect your opinion.
I appreciate but dont favor a band becuase of the amount of passion for music they have. I go by what I see and hear which is their music and performances which i think dbsk excels at. Jaejoong is given songs but he also writes and composes his own songs too. As a matter of fact every member of dbsk composes and writes their own songs. I can name a ton of stuff that they wrote and composed by themselves. Yes, Yunho cant really rap(imo) but he can hold a note and a lot people happen to like his dancing so he's doing something right.

im not really sure what you mean by "musical artist" so i'll leave it at that LOL. anywho to each his own.


I know all the songs they composed (note I said composed, not write lyrics for), and I listened to them and it's a very lackluster and tiny list. Lackluster being a nicer term. The only one that is any good at it is Micky, and his songs are just nice, but nothing really special. The rest can't really do it at all, and I think SM makes them compose in a token manner, otherwise they would look really bad compared to HOT who was an amazing, gifted group who was chosen less for looks than talent.

I listen to DBSK's songs because SM buys really great songs for them to sing, sometimes, but as a group I don't really care about them, or find myself caring.

People like Yunho's dancing but most people aren't the greatest judges of dancing..they think him doing the same things over and over is good.

Eh...I'm getting critical of DBSK and I don't dislike them, and I like Jaejoong and Micky in terms of personality quite a bit, but they're overrated in terms of talent. Hardwork? No. Raw talent? Yes.
6802 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / the netherlands
Offline
Posted 1/13/09
it looks alike
6802 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / the netherlands
Offline
Posted 1/13/09

miss_watever91 wrote:

who r these Top combine??
another boyband??


3243 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 1/13/09
that's because it was directed by the same person ..

*or so i heard*
Posted 1/13/09 , edited 1/13/09


So you arent so fond of their own compositions but you cant say they dont compose at all and just saying they sing whatever SM gives them. And what kind of people do you consider good judges in dancing? Yunho's type of dancing is aimed to appeal to most people and he's good at it so I dont see whats wrong. He cant please everyone.

Im not sure why your pointing out their flaws though. They are only human, I never said they were perfect. Just pretty damn good for a boyband and not comparable to TC in my point of view of course.
456 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / F / fresno
Offline
Posted 1/13/09
hahah it kind of looks the same just a bit darker!:]
Posted 1/13/09
does it matter?? they'll all get raped someday
5591 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Under your bed! R...
Offline
Posted 1/13/09
Yeah they do look similar, i guess i didn't look carefully
170 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / United States
Offline
Posted 1/13/09
It's probaly the same director but both groups are really good
3789 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / somewhere??
Offline
Posted 1/13/09

light_febe wrote:

if it's really copycat, then...

COOL!! many artist like to copy DBSK means it's a good things...<33


honestly "copycat group" make me .....for me even when many artist like to copy DBSK and it show a +ve sign..but for me it still not a good things tho
10856 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
20 / F
Offline
Posted 1/19/09
It is not exactly the same. DBSK's one is at a brighter place and Top Combine's one is at a Darker and open air place. Well, I prefer top combine.
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.