Post Reply AMV Challenge Finals
Moderator
35171 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Lurking
Offline
Posted 12/26/08 , edited 1/3/09
Well what can l say.. after these few days of hunting people down and getting in all of them including at the last minute, we have our AMV Challenge complete.

File: http://www.sendspace.com/file/cyhazr

Its 294 MB.

There might be some strange text and stuff >.> l give no guaranties.

Please keep track of what video you think is the best. To make this fair I don't want you to vote for yourself because then the tracks might become obvious who made what. To make this simple, l want you to give me what you vote like this order:


Example:

Track: Video x


You may add comments to your post as well.

Earlier l said something about:





* Originality
* Visual Quality
* Audio
* Action Sync
* Lip Sync
* Special Effects
* Effort
* Re-view-ability
* Overall


I said there would be 2 kinds of voting (Judges and Best overall) The above will be judged by the judges, so that means you have to judge the best overall.

Video 1: 2

Video 2:

Video 3:

Video 4:

Video 5: 2

Video 6: 1

Video 7:

Video 8:

Video 9: Disregard this track. It was one of my old betas and don't want votes for it. It was more intent as being funny then a actually entry.

Last Note: If anyone wishes to do this again sometime in the future, let me know by posting.

Might edit later ;|.
Moderator
7080 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / United Kingdom -...
Offline
Posted 12/26/08 , edited 1/4/09
Video 1

* Originality - 8
* Visual Quality - 7
* Audio - 9
* Action Sync - 9
* Lip Sync
* Special Effects
* Effort - 8
* Re-view-ability - 8
* Overall - 8

Video 2

* Originality - 8
* Visual Quality - 8
* Audio - 9
* Action Sync - 9
* Lip Sync
* Special Effects
* Effort - 8
* Re-view-ability - 8
* Overall - 9

Video 3 - This is One of my favourite amv, I love it more the Paper Image

* Originality - 8
* Visual Quality - 8
* Audio - 9
* Action Sync - 9
* Lip Sync
* Special Effects
* Effort - 9
* Re-view-ability - 9
* Overall - 9

Video 8

* Originality - 9
* Visual Quality - 8
* Audio - 9
* Action Sync - 9
* Lip Sync
* Special Effects - 9
* Effort - 9
* Re-view-ability - 8
* Overall - 9
AMVMaker regulars
3336 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Trudging on throu...
Offline
Posted 12/26/08
I liked Video 6. The code geass one. It was really well done. I also liked some of the beta videos, but they didn't have a solid ending.
Moderator
67850 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / Japan
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
Three videos stood out to me :3 I'm having a difficulty choosing.

#2 the bebop one. I really liked watching it. It had some editing flaws but It kept me interested. I prefer action amvs :3

* Originality 9
* Visual Quality 6
* Audio 8
* Action Sync 8
* Lip Sync ---
* Special Effects 7
* Effort 8
* Re-view-ability 8
* Overall 7

#5 was fantastic... I love the song choice (its kinda eerie and mysterious like the scenes used) :3 There's a part in it ... I've rewatched the part at 16:10 several times cuz i love it

* Originality 8
* Visual Quality 9
* Audio 9
* Action Sync 9
* Lip Sync --
* Special Effects 9
* Effort 10
* Re-view-ability 10
* Overall 9

#8 was really flashy and I usually don't like much effects... which is why I didn't love #6 ... but this one was different... it was made to look pretty cool Id like to see the rest of it one day :P

* Originality 7
* Visual Quality 8
* Audio 7
* Action Sync 9
* Lip Sync 8
* Special Effects 9
* Effort 10
* Re-view-ability 8
* Overall 8

video #3 needs mentioning also because it conveyed emotions well and was overall, pretty


OK !! so I couldnt just comment on one video!! But I've made my decision... My favorite is : #5
AMVMaker regulars
800 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / M
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
~~~~~Video1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

* Originality 8
* Visual Quality 9
* Audio 9
* Action Sync 9
* Lip Sync -
* Special Effects 6
* Effort 7
* Re-view-ability 8
* Overall 9
AMVMaker regulars
3336 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Trudging on throu...
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
Who are the Judges?
Moderator
35171 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Lurking
Offline
Posted 12/27/08 , edited 12/27/08
Me and lovely are the judges -___-.

We are judging based on scores.. you are just judging for best overall which you liked.

l'll just classify the ones above as opinions.
AMVMaker regulars
13202 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / Australia
Offline
Posted 1/1/09
OK well i'd like to say that ALL OF THEM WERE GREAT! (especially mine hehehehe)

but in the end i have decided that the first one gets my vote.
theres just something about i like.
* Originality 9
* Visual Quality 9
* Audio 7
* Action Sync 9
* Lip Sync -
* Special Effects 7
* Effort 8
* Re-view-ability 8
* Overall 9
Moderator
2963 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Montana
Offline
Posted 1/3/09
All the videos were great and i thank everyone first off for participating in this competition because i must say it was a blast editing my video for it. Well i must say video 8 blew me away from the very start but i was alittle sad that it was so short or else it would of had my vote for sure, still who ever is making that continue making cause i really liked it.

Now that is out of the way i had a very tough time picking between video 1 and video 5
Video 1
* Originality 8
* Visual Quality 8
* Audio 7
* Action Sync 9
* Lip Sync
* Special Effects
* Effort 8
* Re-view-ability 8
* Overall 8

Video 5
* Originality 9
* Visual Quality 9
* Audio 8
* Action Sync 9
* Lip Sync
* Special Effects
* Effort 8
* Re-view-ability 9
* Overall 9

So with that said video 5 has my vote for the best
Moderator
35171 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Lurking
Offline
Posted 1/3/09
l would have to say everyone improved and there was alot more participation in this event.

to bad we dont have alot of people to vote ;/.
Member
16 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 1/4/09
I had a tough time choosing between 1 and 5 as well but I'll vote 5 as well.
Posted 1/4/09
1, 6 and 8 are so good xD but i have to pick 6 cos it's one of my fav anime HAHHA sorry
AMVMaker regulars
6005 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Why be a stalker ?
Offline
Posted 1/4/09
I still have to download the file after the fifth time it failed ><
You must be logged in to post.