Created by Celebration
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next  Last
Who's more Overrated?
Posted 12/26/08
DBSK fans are scary. I'm not going to call them overrated because it would be unfair considering that I don't actually listen to their music. But seriously, their fans are everywhere and it kind of annoys me.

FRH is overrated, though. Especially Wu Zun. He can't sing for nuts.
169462 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / Antique bookshop
Online
Posted 12/26/08
dbsk
29973 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / asia♥
Offline
Posted 12/26/08
fahrenheit......u don't need provings ryt..?
but if u need them...i sudjest that u youtube their live performances...
2851 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / In bed With Jin!!!!
Offline
Posted 12/26/08
Im a huge fan of Kat-tun and DBSK. I might be a little obsesive about them but its just proves how much i love them... AND how can you say that KAt-tun has no talent cuz um Jin can sing, Kame is a good actor, Koki beatboxes and raps.....so yeah. and how are they overrated.....just cuz of all the fans they have?? thats stupid. Dbsk does have alot of talent too..so i dont think that any of them are overrated...maybe a little. oh and i am a fan girl...but im not one of those die hard ones who are crazy.....i just love them for their talents and good looks.
Posted 12/27/08
DBSK iS N0T 0VERRATED.
THEiR FANS MAKE THEM L00K LiKE THEy ARE. i MySELF AM A BiG FAN 0F THEM BUT i'M N0T THE CRAZy TyPE.
9000 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / F / Country Homes
Offline
Posted 12/27/08 , edited 12/27/08
First of all, let check what is overrated!! HAve more fans doesn't mean they r overrated.. Why everyone here keep saying DBSK is overrated,compare with that list above.. it is not..i personally think FRH, people crazy about them n yet they dun really have much talent to show off compare to others like NEWS , and etc..KATTUN at least sing better in LIVE perf..

Compare to all FRH is the one that less in everything in term of talent as overall not as individual. We r talking about group.. not individual.. right.

If you r talking about the fans, hell yah maybe DBSK is overrated , fans do make them like a GOD or something but cant really blame on DBSK . WHY is that? because it is not their fault that fans love them.. it is fans that should b blame..

and as for me can blame on fans too, there must be something that make DBSK have a huge fans base compare to others, it is just maybe not everyone here can really understand WHY compare to them..

i am a fan too but i am not some lunatic or what so ever,, i can think n open minded

but i am not blaming everyone here for saying what u want to say , me, just expressing my opinion nothing more..

maybe someone would agree with me maybe not.. i dun really care , say what ever you want..

check this out, that is why they r so OVERATTED

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Th2wSsGr3TY - maze by JJ
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_GuEwl5mNI - raining man
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2d83GbsnOPM&feature=related - in the still of the night
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fa2NFYWD13s - love in the ice
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKTQi1b7xYg - this is the worse ever i can find they sing LIVE (doushite)

how is that overrated!!! i am confius

~peace~
1026 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / Singapore
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
Lucky Singapore don't have many DBSK fans yet, if it does, its HORROR. DBSK everywhere. LOL.

I think Fahrenheit is the overrated one. My friend is obessed over them I don't get why. They aren't attractive,(probably my taste have something to do with this) and they can't sing live. Except Aaron. He can sing.

Well, in my opinion DBSK is the hardworking one, so the they are not overrated.
I'm not a DBSK fan, yo.
1154 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / His
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
freaken NEWS is way too OVERRATED!
like come on they only get popular cause of the freaken looks!
some of their songs arent even tat good. its not addicting.
For DBSK i think they totally deserve it! like im not
a hard-core fan but i think they totally deserve it! They like work their butts off for it sooooo they reallyy really really deserve it. BUt NEWS they dont even work their butts off n they r still popular! n they(NEWS) need tooo hecka mature upp. + get some mature songs too.
Fahrenheit is overrated too. but i dont really care bout them. but they hella suck at live singing!
DBSK really the only band that deserve it. SOme other bands deserve it too but NEWS n Fahrenheit is jus OMFG!
643 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / F
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
all the bands u listed are overrated for verity of reasons.
1560 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / holding onto a bu...
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
NEWS is 100% overated. my god, their music isnt even tat nice!
kat-tun i dunno cos i never listen to them b4
and fahrenhiet is also overated, only some songs are nice
DBSK is overated cos those fangirls are always 'advertising' them but their music is nice
6356 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Philippines
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

hime_chama wrote:

for now, i dont think kat-tun and news are considered overrated yet. they aren't that asia-wide well known and popular yet. for kat-tun i only know kame(dont even know his full name) and akanishi jin.
so to me, they cant be considered overrated at all.
as for FLH, they cant really sing. they cant really dance. they can't really act well too... esp jiro. he makes me cringe. i like wu chun though, but seeing fangirls flailing their arms over flh doesnt bring a frown to my face yet. probably because flh fans are still considered quite rational and they do understand that their idols has room for improvement.
but dbsk... gosh, thinking of their fangirls make me grimace.
they're very defensive and thinks the world of the 5 dongbang boys, and call them gods. i have nothing against the boys, but their fans really gave me a very bad impression during the time when rumours of a collab between dongbang and flh started off. many dongbang fans set up topics and dissed flh, saying why wld they wanna humiliate themselves. i think that was really very rude and if that has achieved anything, was to reflect badly on dongbang fans. they need to learn how to respect fellow humans. (sorry for sounding harsh, but i'm frank)
while reading other dbsk popularity thread, someone argued that they're godified because their grp name is rising god of the east. if that's the case, then isnt the 3 members of G.O.D more worthy to be labelled as GODS?
so yeah, in conclusion, dbsk is worthy of my vote.


i agree w/ the DBSK fangirl thing...actually bcause of them i didnt had a chance to know DBSK well..now everytime i will see DBSK i always ignore them bcause of my 1st impression 2 them(and that is the fangirl thing)...bcause they are already treating DBSK as their GOD...and 4 me is wrong...some of them are already over reacting...and some already annoying...bcause they always argue to the other fangirl of the other groups..i never got in a forum that they didnt argue or defending DBSK...they always reacts in other peoples opinion...
2478 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / U.S.
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

Celebration wrote:

I am confused about these bands and to why they are as popular as they are. I give up trying to understand the minds of fangirls and fanboys. I purely love to enjoy music, in most languages and styles. I mean I find all four of them weak vocally and looks are averagely cute. Don't get me wrong. In News I absolutely love Yamapi and Ryo-chan, They are extremely good actors. Fahrenheit, I don't get at all. Only one who is cute and is under-rated in my opinion is Calvin, but I am pretty sure people will argue with me about that statement so each his or her own. I won't comment about the rest of the members Especially Jiro, cause it is not nice and I don't know him personally and it is not like I hate them. DBSK, hmmmm. The are an enigma. I don't get there appeal, but they are hard workers so I can appreciate that about them. And they have a lot of charisma. But that all I can say about them. There singing is average and the dancing....whatever. Kat-tun. They just can't sing at all. I mean at least Calvin and Aaron can sing from Fahrenheit (though the other two can't) But no one in Kat-tun can sing. But I do like Kame-kun as an Actor. Jin is extremely cute, and so is Ueda. Koki and Taguchi are adverage actors. I think Yuichi looks weird. but they all are just as charasmatic as DBSK.


You ask me why I know so much about these groups? Cause I researched it. I was really trying to understand the mind of a fangirl/boy. I failed even with all my gain knowledge. I mean all the groups have there good points (mainly outside of singing) but is it enough to have female and male hysteria? Not really. I mean I don't hate them at all. I just don't really get it. Even after all my research on each group.

These is not a hate topic, And I check the threads to see if this is a repeat, it isn't. I've looked. And if it is, my bad. just lock this.

In my opinion the most overrated on is Fahrenheit. Only a little more over rated then Kat-tun, due to there popularity but lack of skills out side off singing. (already stated only Calvin and Aaron can sing.) And no Jiro and Wu chun can not act. Nor do I feel that they are cute. They are okay. But like I said that is my opinion and I am pretty sure lots of people will argue that statement. But this question must be ask, cause I seriously want to know what is the deal.


This has almost nothing to do with this topic but when I first saw Fahrenheit in that drama thing,I also thought Calvin was the cutest one. But my friend thought he was ugly. It was when my friend first intruduced me to crunchyroll and Asian music. When my friend showed me DBSK and Suju, I first thought they were girls,seriously. The same thing with Fahrenheit,they all looked like girls to me except Calvin. So I found it disgusting how my friend who's a big fan of DBSK can like them since they looked like girls. Then I thought they were all gay,lol. I found it weird how the only one that looked like a "boy" was considered ugly. But then my asian friend showed me an amazing mv called Lies and well thats the end of my boyband search. But I know that DBSK are talented, too bad I cant say the same for the rest. Calvin is still cute.
6356 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Philippines
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

raliya6 wrote:

I don't know that much about fahrenheit cause I've only liked a few of their songs but i listen to a lot of johnny groups and SM groups.

Kat-Tun can't sing so i voted for them-people like them because of Jin and Kame-they're actings alright though

In DBSK i hate Mickeys voice especially in live performances but xiah can actually sing very well and I also like jaejoong and changmin's voices. Yunho and Mickey -the rappers of the group?-can't sing that well and this seems to apply to all other boybands as well. Rappers=can't sing

Nothing in NEWS stands out-no vocal range but they aren't horrible-mostly people like them for Yampi so no talent needed

Super Junior and all Johnny groups should have been on the list-Suju has one good singer(Ryeowook) and a few okay ones-I like them only for their personalities(Heechul) but not singing abilities

Boy bands in general are overrated-that's kind of the whole drive in favor of them. Crazed fan girls attracted to them for reasons other than their singing buying multple copies of the same album along with every DVD, and photo book they release.

In the case of DBSK-showing that some of them can actually sing-and not give you nightmares while singing acappella, has boasted them to super stardom-Just imagine what would happen if they marketed a group where they ALL sang well




i think i have to disagree to it about the KAT-TUN cant sing thing...have u already heard them sing or u just heard them one's and u already judge them...of course not all of their song shows their real voices demo i think u should listened to their songs first

listened to this songs
SPECIAL HAPPINESS-kamenashi kazuya and junnosuke taguchi
KIZUNA-kamenashi kazuya
CARE-jin akanishi
HESITATE-jin akanishi
MOTHER/FATHER-KAT-TUN
WHITE X'MAS-KAT-TUN

and who has a band that can beat box good a MARU does..
and KOUKI is the most look like a rapper too all those 4 bands...
6356 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Philippines
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

Kawaii_neko-chan50 wrote:

Im a huge fan of Kat-tun and DBSK. I might be a little obsesive about them but its just proves how much i love them... AND how can you say that KAt-tun has no talent cuz um Jin can sing, Kame is a good actor, Koki beatboxes and raps.....so yeah. and how are they overrated.....just cuz of all the fans they have?? thats stupid. Dbsk does have alot of talent too..so i dont think that any of them are overrated...maybe a little. oh and i am a fan girl...but im not one of those die hard ones who are crazy.....i just love them for their talents and good looks.


uhhmm!!..i agree!!....JIN can sing very well he can do high pitch...KAME is a good actor he already won how many times as the best actor and so does jin but not like kame...KOUKI is the best rapper ever...MARU is the coolest beat boxer...JUNNO is the most good in acrobatics and he has the most lame jokes among all of them and UEDA is the who can play many instrument...so how can they say that KAT-TUN has no talents soo guys u are wrong!!!..
11196 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / hk (ka...
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
Fahrenheit, some of their voices are alright. but then they can't really perform well live.
DBSK, KAT-TUN and NEWS can do pretty good live performances
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.