First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
Post Reply scenes that u just dont get
Member
5743 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / Sand Village
Offline
Posted 12/26/08
i only dont get one scene...
u know how the girl ....whenever she plays that song on the old piano the room is changing around .....how come when jay chou played it the room didnt change?
161 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F
Offline
Posted 12/26/08
i dont get it either lol i have a lot of questions!

like the teacher can hear them playing a duet on the piano? but he cant see her? so what, she can be heard but not seen?

and why can the other girl see her when she asked her what are they doing during the piano duel!
Member
353 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Seoul, SK, but us...
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
remember that the person she first sees is the only one who can see her... during the piano duel, the other girl Chungyi (not sure) was the first person she saw... also its possible for them to hear her playing, that's why the guy found out about her in the first place--when he heard the music she played...
Member
462 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / currently at HK,...
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
its not HER they're hearing but the sound of the piano. its not a sound coming FROM her (i.e. voice)
Member
5743 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / Sand Village
Offline
Posted 12/27/08
theres another one i dont get......
how come the cleaning guy can c her?
&& wouldnt people think theres something wrong with him since he talks to himself beacuse they cant c her?
Member
1384 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Universe
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

Missy-Thr3e wrote:

theres another one i dont get......
how come the cleaning guy can c her?
&& wouldnt people think theres something wrong with him since he talks to himself beacuse they cant c her?


that was also what i was wondering
and what i thought of it is because he can see because he has brain matters?
he seems to be not ordinary.
maybe that's the reason why.
but i see no connection with him being not ordinary and him seeing her.
but that's the only possible conclusion i can think of
Member
5743 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / Sand Village
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:

theres another one i dont get......
how come the cleaning guy can c her?
&& wouldnt people think theres something wrong with him since he talks to himself beacuse they cant c her?


that was also what i was wondering
and what i thought of it is because he can see because he has brain matters?
he seems to be not ordinary.
maybe that's the reason why.
but i see no connection with him being not ordinary and him seeing her.
but that's the only possible conclusion i can think of :D


what i think about the crazy guy is because he use to know her in the past life so he could b crazy and just yell out random names && say random things
Member
1384 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Universe
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

Missy-Thr3e wrote:


blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:

theres another one i dont get......
how come the cleaning guy can c her?
&& wouldnt people think theres something wrong with him since he talks to himself beacuse they cant c her?


that was also what i was wondering
and what i thought of it is because he can see because he has brain matters?
he seems to be not ordinary.
maybe that's the reason why.
but i see no connection with him being not ordinary and him seeing her.
but that's the only possible conclusion i can think of :D


what i think about the crazy guy is because he use to know her in the past life so he could b crazy and just yell out random names && say random things :P


haha yeah there was also this janitor where the girl and the dad's guy talked and he was eavesdropping right? the long time ago scene? whew. this is becoming my obsession T_T
Member
5743 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / Sand Village
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:


blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:

theres another one i dont get......
how come the cleaning guy can c her?
&& wouldnt people think theres something wrong with him since he talks to himself beacuse they cant c her?


that was also what i was wondering
and what i thought of it is because he can see because he has brain matters?
he seems to be not ordinary.
maybe that's the reason why.
but i see no connection with him being not ordinary and him seeing her.
but that's the only possible conclusion i can think of :D


what i think about the crazy guy is because he use to know her in the past life so he could b crazy and just yell out random names && say random things :P


haha yeah there was also this janitor where the girl and the dad's guy talked and he was eavesdropping right? the long time ago scene? whew. this is becoming my obsession T_T


LOL
Member
353 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Seoul, SK, but us...
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

Missy-Thr3e wrote:


blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:


blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:

theres another one i dont get......
how come the cleaning guy can c her?
&& wouldnt people think theres something wrong with him since he talks to himself beacuse they cant c her?


that was also what i was wondering
and what i thought of it is because he can see because he has brain matters?
he seems to be not ordinary.
maybe that's the reason why.
but i see no connection with him being not ordinary and him seeing her.
but that's the only possible conclusion i can think of :D


what i think about the crazy guy is because he use to know her in the past life so he could b crazy and just yell out random names && say random things :P


haha yeah there was also this janitor where the girl and the dad's guy talked and he was eavesdropping right? the long time ago scene? whew. this is becoming my obsession T_T


LOL


I think the best explanation is that the janitor was the first person she saw at that time... that's why the guy didn't see her... only the janitor did...
Member
5743 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / Sand Village
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

zerimarnayrb wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:


blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:


blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:

theres another one i dont get......
how come the cleaning guy can c her?
&& wouldnt people think theres something wrong with him since he talks to himself beacuse they cant c her?


that was also what i was wondering
and what i thought of it is because he can see because he has brain matters?
he seems to be not ordinary.
maybe that's the reason why.
but i see no connection with him being not ordinary and him seeing her.
but that's the only possible conclusion i can think of :D


what i think about the crazy guy is because he use to know her in the past life so he could b crazy and just yell out random names && say random things :P


haha yeah there was also this janitor where the girl and the dad's guy talked and he was eavesdropping right? the long time ago scene? whew. this is becoming my obsession T_T


LOL


I think the best explanation is that the janitor was the first person she saw at that time... that's why the guy didn't see her... only the janitor did...


yeh! but it still cant explain how he could c her since the first person who sees her is the only one who can
Member
353 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Seoul, SK, but us...
Offline
Posted 12/27/08

Missy-Thr3e wrote:


zerimarnayrb wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:


blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:


blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:

theres another one i dont get......
how come the cleaning guy can c her?
&& wouldnt people think theres something wrong with him since he talks to himself beacuse they cant c her?


that was also what i was wondering
and what i thought of it is because he can see because he has brain matters?
he seems to be not ordinary.
maybe that's the reason why.
but i see no connection with him being not ordinary and him seeing her.
but that's the only possible conclusion i can think of :D


what i think about the crazy guy is because he use to know her in the past life so he could b crazy and just yell out random names && say random things :P


haha yeah there was also this janitor where the girl and the dad's guy talked and he was eavesdropping right? the long time ago scene? whew. this is becoming my obsession T_T


LOL


I think the best explanation is that the janitor was the first person she saw at that time... that's why the guy didn't see her... only the janitor did...


yeh! but it still cant explain how he could c her since the first person who sees her is the only one who can



I think it does explain how... since the janitor was the 1st person she saw at that time, (just after opening the door of the piano room from where she came from) it applies that the janitor would be the only person who would see her for the rest of the time she stays there... same with the time when she came back with eyes covered with her hands counting the steps to the classroom only to see the other girl and not the boy... since she saw her 1st, the other girl was the only person who could see her for the rest of her stay there.. so basically, if she sees a person for the 1st time just after time traveling, that person would be the only person who could see her... hope i made sense..
7 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F
Offline
Posted 12/28/08
I think wOOt definitely understand this movie a whole lot! you are so on the dot.
7 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F
Offline
Posted 12/28/08
sorry not wOOt but zerimarnayrb. I'm still new to this site.
5 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26
Offline
Posted 12/28/08

zerimarnayrb wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:


zerimarnayrb wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:


blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:


blackmariaxd wrote:


Missy-Thr3e wrote:

theres another one i dont get......
how come the cleaning guy can c her?
&& wouldnt people think theres something wrong with him since he talks to himself beacuse they cant c her?


that was also what i was wondering
and what i thought of it is because he can see because he has brain matters?
he seems to be not ordinary.
maybe that's the reason why.
but i see no connection with him being not ordinary and him seeing her.
but that's the only possible conclusion i can think of :D


what i think about the crazy guy is because he use to know her in the past life so he could b crazy and just yell out random names && say random things :P


haha yeah there was also this janitor where the girl and the dad's guy talked and he was eavesdropping right? the long time ago scene? whew. this is becoming my obsession T_T


LOL


I think the best explanation is that the janitor was the first person she saw at that time... that's why the guy didn't see her... only the janitor did...


yeh! but it still cant explain how he could c her since the first person who sees her is the only one who can



I think it does explain how... since the janitor was the 1st person she saw at that time, (just after opening the door of the piano room from where she came from) it applies that the janitor would be the only person who would see her for the rest of the time she stays there... same with the time when she came back with eyes covered with her hands counting the steps to the classroom only to see the other girl and not the boy... since she saw her 1st, the other girl was the only person who could see her for the rest of her stay there.. so basically, if she sees a person for the 1st time just after time traveling, that person would be the only person who could see her... hope i made sense..


thats one long explanation xD but i think ur right
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.