Post Reply Banner Judging!!
Creator
10506 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F
Offline
Posted 1/9/09 , edited 2/16/09
ok so this is how we will be deciding on the winner for the banner contest ^^
each sign has submited 3 banners ok so this is how the banners will be judged!; the banners will be judged by judges unfoourtunatly i only managed to get 2 judges because many that i offered to be a judge did not have the time for this the judges are:
Judge # 1:Baka-Master[<-- do NOT buddy he will not except any buddy request]
Judge # 2:AhiruRocks
&
Judge # 3:thedeadrose

the judges will be judging the banner from a scale of 0 to 10 then they will be added up as the final score ^^

ok so here are the banners to judge
Aries


Leo


Scorpio


Sagittarius

Libra


Virgos



lets find out who's gonna win ^^

the reason why i put A-1 or something like that was because so the judging can be easier xD they don't need to get the pic on the forum post

Judge example:
scorpio banner's
A-1=8
A-2=9
A-4=8
final score = 25
Member
21476 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / ✿ prospit ✿
Offline
Posted 1/16/09 , edited 1/31/09
Well i like all the LEOS!!!!


Jugde ~ AhiruRocks

The others were good but I like the Leo banners ^^

Aries Banners
A-1 - 5
A-2 - 5
A-3 - 5
Final Score - 15


Leo Banners
B-1 - 10
B-2 - 9
B-3 - 10
Final Score - 29


Scorpio Banners
C-1 - 4
C-2 - 3
C-3 - 3
Final Scores - 10

Sagittrius Banners
D-1 - 9
D-2 - 9
D-3 - 9
Final Scores - 28


Virgo Banners
F-1 10
F-2 10


Good job minna-san!! :D

Libra Banners
E-1 - 5
E-2 - 4
E-3 - 3
Final Scores - 12
Posted 1/31/09 , edited 1/31/09
hmm they're all well done but it's to bad that just one can dominate it >.<

Aries

A1 7
it's well done and cute ^^ but banners are made to let people join it and its for advertising
A2 5
it's a banner contest not a wallpaper contest learn the difference >__>
A3 8
this one is better and cute too ^^


Leo

B1 6
why do you think that banners exist?? it's to advertising
B2 7
this one is better ^^ but still a little to big
B3 9
look everyone...... this is how a good banner looks like

Scorpio

C1 0
this one is the most retarded banner i ever saw there is NOT anything what i could give you a point for sorry and wtf why the M ??
C2 5
it's too small it's dull and not advertising >_>
C3 0
this is just a pic without anything you've done

Sagittarius

D1 8
its a good and well made banner but it doesn't fit with the Sagittarius sorry
D2 0
die......
D3 0
wtf is this -__- a wallpaper ??

Libra

E1 7
a good banner but what does that girl have common with a libra ^__^
E2 7
its not a banner at all it's a wallpaper >_>
E3 7
this is something better

Virgos

F1 7
its a good banner but a little too big
F2 7


Total Score Aries : 20

Total Score Leo : 22

Total Score Scorpio : 5

Total Score Sagittarius : 8

Total Score Libra 21

Total Score Virgo : 7

that was it ^_______________^


Posted 1/31/09
Judge:thedeadrose

I Like Sagittarius Best...

Aries
A-1 -3
A-2 -5
A-3 -7

Total Score:15


Leo
B-1 -5
B-2 -7
B-3 -6

Total Score:18


Scorpio
C-1 -3
C-2 -4
C-3 -3

Total Score:10


Sagittarius
D-1 -7
D-2 -9
D-3 -10

Total Score:26


Libra
E-1 -8
E-2 -8
E-3 -6

Total Score:22


Virgo
F-1 -8
F-2 -5

Total Score:13

Posted 2/1/09
Total Score Aries : 50

Total Score Leo : 69

Total Score Scorpio : 28

Total Score Sagittarius : 62

Total Score Libra : 55

Total Score Virgo : 47
You must be logged in to post.