First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next  Last
Hana yori dango Vs. Boys before flower
292 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / neverland
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
Hana yori dango all the waaaaay!!!!
Posted 1/23/09
i prefer the japanese HYD cast..
79512 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / dubai
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
actually, i like the korean cast more better...matsujun is so ugly..yuck....sorrie guys...
1643 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / F / MD, USA
Offline
Posted 1/23/09

LuvMi7 wrote:

Hana Yori Dango VS. Boys Before Flower
Tell me what u think! and by the way.. dont take the things i said personally



I can't decide which version is better, but I like the Korean cast much better than the Japanese one.


VS

I prefer the Korean version of Domyoji (Goo Joon pyo). He looks way much better with more masculine face and body. He's absolutely charming. I think he's smoking hot!!! His acting skill is great. He really suits to be Domyoji.
Plus, he looks hot with permed hair!!! I actually like that perm hair. That style suits him well.



VS

I also prefer the Japanese Rui - Oguri Shun. The Korean Rui isn't that great looking. His acting is not bad, but I don't think he's hot enough for that role.



VS

I prefer the Korean version. He looks so cute and sweet. I bet everyone would agree with me, right???




VS

It's a tight. Both of them are ok.



VS

I like the Japanese girl more. She's some what cuter although both are cute.




VS

The Korean girl is much prettier!!! She look so cute and innocent!!!

1643 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / F / MD, USA
Offline
Posted 1/23/09

joreen95 wrote:

actually, i like the korean cast more better...matsujun is so ugly..yuck....sorrie guys...


I absolutely agree with what u said.
3358 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
76 / F / In my pants. No,...
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
I love the Korean cast, period.
Makino always looked like an old grandma to me, don't give me that crap about how she's natural and shit, I know she isn't plastic, 'kay? I don't know if it's the lines around her mouth that make her look older, but yeah. Something about her bothers me. The Korean one isn't that much prettier, though it's obvious she's a cutie with sexy hair.

It's just that HYD is way too overrated; not in a good way, I bet if the Korean version came out first, it would dominate.
1078 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / las islas filipinas
Offline
Posted 1/23/09 , edited 1/23/09
i think the f4 korean cast are indeed hotter but the japanese f4 are cuter.

mao is waaaaaaay better than the korean girl. the korean girl reminds me more of nodame.

i still like the story of hana yori dango. the korean version is more meteor garden-ish. i prefer the cute light-hearted story of HYD.

BUT. i really like the pairing of the korean soujiroh and yuki. HAHA. they look good together! i'm even more interested on their pairing than the main casts. :))
1604 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
Too Bad with "BOF" the only word is "look". Talk about acting LMAO (especially the bad executed Kversion).
11560 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / here....Matsujun...
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
Hanadan casts....for better acting...
well..looks are subjective

Jun Pyo, he's the perfect manga/anime adaptation of Domyouji...lyke bringing the Domyouji alive...dat's only abt look...
cuz he totally can;t pull off Domyouji's attitude. he looks too normal...aren't Domyouji suppose to be spoiled-brat, evil, violence, self-centered and childish...not to forget his bad Japanese..or in Korean ver...bad korean...
also...'the almighty ME' DOmyouji...srsly JunPyo didn't give me any kind of dat attitude...
and i'm irritate by the way he simply fall for 'stupid Jan Di' ~ talk abt tis girl later
erm..i dun see much confrontation between Jan Di and Jun Pyo dat can make Jan Di really hates Jun Pyo.
Jun's version...physically...yup..he's short...the shortest in F4 but...he had the attitude of being 'the Almighty ME'his acting was superb dat it juz overshadow his lacking in physical appearances


i'm not a fan of Rui...even the Japanese one...but the korean Rui really ruin Rui's character...
correct me if i'm wrong...aren't Rui suppose to be a mysterious guy?? and carefree.....
the Korean make me see him as a normal super COOL guy ~ he is cute...the cutest among korean F4
acting-wise...i think Shun did it better...

Jan Di...ugh!! she really annoys me....
esp wif dat 'stupid' attitude...i dun know how she interpret 'tough girl' but to me...she seem so dumb.
i totally can't understand her. and dat flying kick is too ridiculous!! i really dun get it. ~ but well..i enjoy dat scene
WTH wif dat hair...ugh!!! change it!!! Makino is a poor-plain-tough girl...not poor-dumb-ugly girl...hope she'll improves in upcoming ep.
i hate it, when she yelled at Jun Pyo each time she saw him...lyke she didn't hv any fear of him...
idk..but i think there's limit of being fearless/tough.
Mao's Makino...she only act tough whenever Domyouji did sumthing ridiculous/mean..but when he's being nice..makino didn't yell at him...i dun get it...WTH wif all the yelling.

as for Soujiroh...i'm Matsuda Shouta's fan
erm..the korean is cute... and looks innocent...do not really fit as playboy
and the korean Mimasaka...i hvn't see much of him...so i'll skip on him

i love Korean Shizuka a lot better!! she's pretty!!!omg!! she's soooooo PRETTY!!!
i love the whole scene at her party...up to when she brought Jan Di to her room.
i love it when she stood up for Jan Di and teach those 3 girls a lesson...
the jap one kinda ridiculous...WTH wif dat smiling face and making those girl get wet in her pool?
i dun get it...korean version give ,e the feelong dat she's a tough girl...the girl dat went against her family will and stood on her own...


sorry for this long ranting...
i juz had so much more to say...but...kversion juz started..i think i shld give it more time
268 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
I'm picking the actors according to who most follows the images of the characters in the manga.

The Korean version of Domyuoji is taller and has a stronger build. His curly hair looks better. His face does resemble Domyuoji quite a lot. Overall, sometimes he looks like a big idiot like how Domyouji is supposed to look. XD

My head is hurting over who wins Hanazawa Rui. This is a tough call, but I must say that the Korean version better suits Rui. He looks more timid, gentle, and zoned out, while Oguri Shun seems a little more tough and active, just a little.

I think that the Japanese version of the guy who is obsessed with tea ceremonies or pots, Soujiro, gets this one. He looks very traditional, and, at the same time, he looks like a playboy. The Korean guy looks cute and has an amiable atmosphere, but that doesn't suit the image of the character.

Abe T., the Japanese actor, better acts the guy who likes older women.

And now, for Makino...umm...well, Inoue Mao has the look and correct hair style. Yes, I think Inoue Mao gets this one, because the Korean girl acts a character with some odd personality and awkwardness through her expressions and actions. I don't think Makino was odd in the manga; she was just a tomboy.

If you were to ask about preference of looks I would pick Matsumoto Jun, Oguri Shun, the Korean Soujiro (so cute), Abe, and Inoue Mao.



11560 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / here....Matsujun...
Offline
Posted 1/23/09

sasgrace wrote:

Too Bad with "BOF" the only word is "look". Talk about acting LMAO (especially the bad executed Kversion).

omg!! agree...
esp the 2 leading roles

1036 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
The korean version is interesting~ Instead of makino's (Jandi) friend being in love with Soujiro (Kimbum) it looks like its the oppsite? Aiya donnoe la~ See first~~~
Japanese and Korean, i think i have to give them the same score.
Coz both are amazing~ Taiwanese one... havent watch and dont want watch... LOL srry ah.. if u like the tw version.
268 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31
Offline
Posted 1/23/09

clangwee wrote:

i think the f4 korean cast are indeed hotter but the japanese f4 are cuter.

mao is waaaaaaay better than the korean girl. the korean girl reminds me more of nodame.

i still like the story of hana yori dango. the korean version is more meteor garden-ish. i prefer the cute light-hearted story of HYD.

BUT. i really like the pairing of the korean soujiroh and yuki. HAHA. they look good together! i'm even more interested on their pairing than the main casts. :))


You are so right about the pairing between Korean Soujiroh and Yuki. I'm really interested in the progress or outcome of their relationship.
528 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
I LOVEEEEEEEEEEE HYD but I also LOVEEEEEEEEEEEEE BBF!!

The korean version of Makio acts too much like a savage when she eats and she does a lot of manly things which was not like makino.. She's supposed to act like a Poor girl, not a tomboy/manly girl,who has never eaten rice before.


I like both F4 casts but the korean version of F4 is soo much hotter and i agree that Goo Joon pyo is more manly then Mats but still there all good!

I LOVE KIM BUM AND THE BEST FRIEND THERE GOING TO BE SOO CUTE TOGETHER AND I CANT WAIT FOR THEM TO GET TOGETHER!
431 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
I'm actually torn between the two.
I prefer the Japanese Akira, but all the others I think are equal, because they're not exactly the same. Joon Pyo is a different character from Domyouji, etc etc, and only the Korean Akira hasn't been given a chance to show any original or real personality.

It's hard to compare most of them, because I feel that the Korean characters aren't just a copy of earlier incarnations.
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.