First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next  Last
Hana yori dango Vs. Boys before flower
1088 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
31 / F / next to the my se...
Offline
Posted 1/23/09

LovelesslyInPain wrote:

I love the Korean cast, period.
Makino always looked like an old grandma to me, don't give me that crap about how she's natural and shit, I know she isn't plastic, 'kay? I don't know if it's the lines around her mouth that make her look older, but yeah. Something about her bothers me. The Korean one isn't that much prettier, though it's obvious she's a cutie with sexy hair.

It's just that HYD is way too overrated; not in a good way, I bet if the Korean version came out first, it would dominate.



i agree with the last sentence.. if korean version came out first it would been so much more popular.. but japan bet them to it..but i cant agree with the korean girls hair cut.. its just soo ugly.. it looks like a bowl hair cut.
11560 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / here....Matsujun...
Offline
Posted 1/23/09

LuvMi7 wrote:


G_lalam wrote:

I love Hana Yori Dango, everything about it was perfect.
The cast, the story, the music, it was perfectly executed.

BBF feels more like Meteor Garden and I feel MG was more subtle and believeable.
The over acting and the crazy music drives me batty...
Don't get me wrong, I am still addicted to it and wait patiently for every new episode.

As far as looks go....Korean cast may be better looking but the Japanese HYD made me believe in F4, their friendship and their genuine concern for Makino.
I don't care how short you think MatsuJun is...he was Doumyoji.
GJP is just too nice and a perfect gentleman to be the bratty and spoiled Doumyoji.



maybe thats why i liked joon pyo.. he wasnt bratty.. although i know jun did a good job acting bratty.. i just hate bratty guys.. sorry i deal with them at school.. and so from my aspect.. i see jun acting like one of those guys at school so i hate him.. i prefer gentleman like joon pyo


and Domyouji suppose to be bratty....so Matsujun's acting is superb, right?
Jun Pyo can't bring Domyouji's character
i respect ur opinion tho
687 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / F / USA
Offline
Posted 1/23/09

LuvMi7 wrote:

Hana Yori Dango VS. Boys Before Flower

ok so i know that the series Boys Before Flowers isnt done quite yet (well as of today that i am writing this) but it already has my friends and i debating which cast members we prefer

so tell me which one you would prefer for each f4 member and some of the main girls


VS

~ i prefer the korean version of domyoji. in the series he is called goo joon pyo out of the (korean) f4 goo joon pyo is much taller and bigger in size and this makes him look more tougher which is the character that he is supposed to play. While the Japanese version domyoji is actually shorter then some of the (japanese) f4 members and he isnt as strong looking as goo joon pyo. Over all The korean goo joon pyo has a more masculine face and therefore looks more intimidating, i personally think he looks much better.



VS

~ i prefer the japanese rui.. anyday.. everyday oguri shun!!!



VS

~ i prefer the korean version.. he is sooooo cute!!! he is sooooo cute.. u cant see it in his picture but when u watch the drama



VS

~ i prefer the korean guy.. tho it was hard to decide.


VS


~omg the korean version girl is sooo ugly.. i mean here its ok.. but in the drama her hair is sooo ugly! how can goo joon pyo fall for her!!! and like makino is so much prettier.. she doesnt have a elegant pretty but a natural pretty...


VS

~korean version much better!!! her friend is so cute and pretty i can imagine the tea/ceramic guy falling for her. not saying that the japane version friend is ugly.. but i like the korean version friend more..


Tell me what u think! and by the way.. dont take the things i said personally




METEOR GARDEN RULE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
9442 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / Long Beach, Calif...
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
i really really like the Boys Before Flower cast right now.
1218 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / Canada
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
KOREAN HYD ALL THE WAY!!!
79512 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / dubai
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
guys..u forgot the first hanayori dango and boys over flowers...its - METEOR GARDEN..if u compare it to hanayori and boys over flowers-for me, its meteor garden....coz in that time- IT IS MOREEE POPULAR....:D ^_^ but,, i guess- its old aready..but, for me- its like the 1st and the best..when i watch hanayori and boys over flowers- i feel like- i KNOW whats going to happen..its juz different version..and its not exciting anymore..
11560 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / here....Matsujun...
Offline
Posted 1/23/09

joreen95 wrote:

guys..u forgot the first hanayori dango and boys over flowers...its - METEOR GARDEN..if u compare it to hanayori and boys over flowers-for me, its meteor garden....coz in that time- IT IS MOREEE POPULAR....:D ^_^ but,, i guess- its old aready..but, for me- its like the 1st and the best..when i watch hanayori and boys over flowers- i feel like- i KNOW whats going to happen..its juz different version..and its not exciting anymore..


and u also almost forgot..
way before meteor garden....there Hana Yori dango ~ jap version released in 1997
not to mention abt the manga and anime..
if it's abt the same storyline....den whatever remake come out will be a flop..
i dunno abt u...but i enjoy every little differences dat each version has....
totally my opinion ~ dun get me wrong
79512 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / dubai
Offline
Posted 1/23/09

imanuraisha wrote:


joreen95 wrote:

guys..u forgot the first hanayori dango and boys over flowers...its - METEOR GARDEN..if u compare it to hanayori and boys over flowers-for me, its meteor garden....coz in that time- IT IS MOREEE POPULAR....:D ^_^ but,, i guess- its old aready..but, for me- its like the 1st and the best..when i watch hanayori and boys over flowers- i feel like- i KNOW whats going to happen..its juz different version..and its not exciting anymore..


and u also almost forgot..
way before meteor garden....there Hana Yori dango ~ jap version released in 1997
not to mention abt the manga and anime..
if it's abt the same storyline....den whatever remake come out will be a flop..
i dunno abt u...but i enjoy every little differences dat each version has....
totally my opinion ~ dun get me wrong


wow..1997...im juz 2 yrs old then...hehhe~ hai- senpai:D hehhe....gomen ~ne:D heheh^^
3106 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / USA
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
definitely bbf. they're much better-looking.
Posted 1/23/09
Looks wise: Boys Before Flowers

However looking at both casts as whole ones, I have to say I prefer the Japanese one. The cast had great chemistry and I was actually able to believe that F4 had been friends since they were kids. They all just "clicked". The acting seemed natural and I never felt that "unintentionally awkward" vibe.
119 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
46 / M / US
Offline
Posted 1/23/09

huangtonsoup wrote:

I'm picking the actors according to who most follows the images of the characters in the manga.

The Korean version of Domyuoji is taller and has a stronger build. His curly hair looks better. His face does resemble Domyuoji quite a lot. Overall, sometimes he looks like a big idiot like how Domyouji is supposed to look. XD

My head is hurting over who wins Hanazawa Rui. This is a tough call, but I must say that the Korean version better suits Rui. He looks more timid, gentle, and zoned out, while Oguri Shun seems a little more tough and active, just a little.

I think that the Japanese version of the guy who is obsessed with tea ceremonies or pots, Soujiro, gets this one. He looks very traditional, and, at the same time, he looks like a playboy. The Korean guy looks cute and has an amiable atmosphere, but that doesn't suit the image of the character.

Abe T., the Japanese actor, better acts the guy who likes older women.

And now, for Makino...umm...well, Inoue Mao has the look and correct hair style. Yes, I think Inoue Mao gets this one, because the Korean girl acts a character with some odd personality and awkwardness through her expressions and actions. I don't think Makino was odd in the manga; she was just a tomboy.

If you were to ask about preference of looks I would pick Matsumoto Jun, Oguri Shun, the Korean Soujiro (so cute), Abe, and Inoue Mao.





I am sooooo agree with you on Domyuoji and Rui, known as Jun Pyo and Ji Joon in the Korean version. They are both way hotter and cutter, and better suits the characters.
6499 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / Minnesota
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
Korean version for me :)
idk i'm being bias because i never
watched the japanese version
2306 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / F / US
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
I have enjoyed all of the cast from both dramas. Well, three dramas...MG's cast...eh. Was kinda boring, excluding Jerry Yan's antics.

I actually prefer GJD's attitude more than Makinos (except the part where she doesn't seem to like GJP at ALL) - but I prefer Makino's looks and acting over GJD.

Prefer Rui's attitude over...the Korean guy, I can't remember his name - but the Korean guy's looks over Rui.

And weirdly enough, I prefer Tsukasa's attitude more than GJP - as for the looks department, MatsuJun was rockin it sooo bad in HYD2, he was amazingly handsome...but LMH, oh man. Episode 6 where he takes his clothes off at the beach??? And the forceful almost-kisses? I was wishing Tsukasa would have done that more in HYD...

It's hard to choose. So, I've just kinda decided to enjoy both dramas as equally as possible. I just love HYD so much that I don't believe anything can replace it.

But Lee Min Ho, boy...
1292 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / A-toWn
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
BOYS BEFORE FLOWERS ALL THA WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
THE ONE WHO I ONLIE RELLIE LIKE IN THA JAP VERSION WAS RUI...
3625 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / QUEEN city of the...
Offline
Posted 1/23/09
ok..

Here's my pick!

I"M so confuse on who to pick between matsujun & lee minho

i love jun"s acting & aura while i love the looks of lee minho as tsukasa< so manly & handsome<tall too>

oguri shun"s acting is soooo way bettterrrr!hyun joong is too silent<i barely even notice him in some scenes>

i love shota"s acting but hey!kim bum is justttt soooo cute>>he"s character is more on being cute then a playboy>>hahaha

& akira in the korean version is way more good_looking>>:))

& the girl lead>>inoue mao is the greatest actress who can pull it off so good>>

& the bestfriend>>korean version is sooo pretty><love him with kim bum together>>:))

ciao*
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.