Post Reply Ask || Honest peerage of your work!
Posted 1/24/09 , edited 1/24/09
Feel unsatisfied with what you've created? Then you've come to the right thread! Now featuring the "Ask || Honest peerage of your work!" thread at Stardust Designs, you can ask about your work and get tips on how to improve. 100% improvement guarenteed!


Guidelines:
*Either myself or another mod will HONESTLY critisize your work
*A rating will be given from 1-10 (1 being the lowest)
*Negative things will be pointed out (tell you what to exclude)
*Positive things will be pointed out
*We'll tell you what to include & tips for improvement


Form:
-What program you used [i.e. - Photoshop CS3 Extended]
-What YOU feel about your own work [i.e. - I don't think I did it very well]
-Your edited photo [in a spoiler tag]


Don't worry if the review seems harsh, it just means you need to improve alot more. The more you improve, the better you'll be at graphic making. And one day, you'll be thanking us for the harsh critisism ;3
Posted 1/26/09
-What program you used photoshop elements
-What YOU feel about your own work - i think i need improvement
-Your edited photo
Posted 1/26/09

Starlight_lily wrote:

-What program you used photoshop elements
-What YOU feel about your own work - i think i need improvement
-Your edited photo


Honestly, I give you a 3. Your rendering skills need improvement, the text needs to be more "decorated", and black/gray-ish bg doesn't suit the avvie (through my eyes). Try setting the text size bigger and do a pattern overlay (on the text). For the girl in the bg, try setting the blending mode to multiply or color burn. You might wanna try grid lines for a basic pattern. Textures are super helpful, too. But I do like how you put "Vivid Designs" over & over again in the bg ^w^

P.S. - Don't take my opinion personally. I judge harshly cuz I think that's how ppl improve the most. But don't worry, you can always try again & again :3
Posted 1/27/09

Silmeria42696 wrote:


Starlight_lily wrote:

-What program you used photoshop elements
-What YOU feel about your own work - i think i need improvement
-Your edited photo


Honestly, I give you a 3. Your rendering skills need improvement, the text needs to be more "decorated", and black/gray-ish bg doesn't suit the avvie (through my eyes). Try setting the text size bigger and do a pattern overlay (on the text). For the girl in the bg, try setting the blending mode to multiply or color burn. You might wanna try grid lines for a basic pattern. Textures are super helpful, too. But I do like how you put "Vivid Designs" over & over again in the bg ^w^

P.S. - Don't take my opinion personally. I judge harshly cuz I think that's how ppl improve the most. But don't worry, you can always try again & again :3


Thx for da advice^^ and well i did cosider doing grid lines but I totally forgot about it because i was searching for the bouncy ball i lost=.=.
1820 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F
Offline
Posted 7/20/09 , edited 7/20/09
-What program you used photoshop cs3
-What YOU feel about your own work - There is definitely rm for improvement !~
-Your edited photo

Stardust Creator
8419 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Wonderland
Offline
Posted 9/6/09 , edited 9/6/09

iPanda- wrote:

-What program you used photoshop cs3
-What YOU feel about your own work - There is definitely rm for improvement !~
-Your edited photo



Sry for late reply.
For the first and 2nd avii i'll give u a 7.
u could have used another font >.<
A more decorating one xD
And maybe some brushes or a polaroid-effect???
But they are really good anyway ^-°


For the 3rd i'll give u a 6.

Nice colours, nicce bg
but could have used more effects, for example u could have faded the girl in the bg or something ^-°
And also a more decorating Font x3
And the pink outline of the girl doesnt really suite.

But you are definetely on the right way ^-°
i hope i could help =3
25790 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
20 / F / in mars im a mart...
Offline
Posted 10/4/09
Form:
-Photoshop CS3 Extended
- I don't think I did it very well
-Your edited photo [in a spoiler tag]


Posted 9/29/10 , edited 9/29/10
-What program you used: GIMP 2.6 (mostly used) // Photoscape (only for decoration)
-What YOU feel about your own work: idk...
-Your edited photo [in a spoiler tag] The first 3 i made it recently. the last one i made that last week.



You must be logged in to post.