First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next  Last
BOF characters, who portrayed it best???
1379 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / 12345 Rainbow Street
Offline
Posted 3/12/09

piggyinthemiddle wrote:

the taiwanese of course!!!!

love u jerry


love u venness


hate u vic


were the last two vaness from H.O.T.?
3567 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / bikini bottom
Offline
Posted 3/12/09

strangersuntold wrote:

It is nice to see everyones thoughts, though i think it is a bit early to decide since Korean version isnt even halfway done.

I have seen all of the anime and all of Meteor Garden and some of Hani Yori Dango and all over the BOys Over Flowers episodes so far. But for what I see so far and to compare:

JERRY YAN/Daoy - Taiwanese: He to me was the percfect Daoy. Mean,violent, childish and selfish in the beginning but then changed into a better person. Lee Min Ho was a close second, he played the charming charisma personality spot on but could have been more meaner. Matsumo is a fine actor and did great in the role but his phyiscal appearance of height and not having that wow factor made me never really find him to be Dom. I just could never take him seriously in fitting the role.

INUO MAO/Makino - Japanese: She played a fierce and likeable Makino and never came off as annoying. I do adore Barbie's potrayal, my only problem with her was her always being mad at Jerry's character and would make me frusrated. For Koo as Jan Di, she is cute but trying too hard on those facial expressions and being young and overacting.

VIC ZHOU/Lei- Tawainese: Vic when he was in his role as Lei, i could always feel the loneliness and distance he kept from everyone. He seemed to be on a different world with everyone and the chemistry between him and Barbie was amazing. At one point in the series I actually prefered him with Barbie into later on in the series of course. In BBF, i havent felt there is much of a strong love triangle or between Jan di, Joo Pyo, and Jo Hoo. There is barely a triangle and Kim Hyun needs to start falling in the role more, I think he is holding back because of not so great directing and coming off stiff, he is improving though.
Oguri shun/ Rui is really good as well and perfect too as the role.

KIM BUM/So Yi Korean: Has the charming, radiant smile, playboy act down to the T. I never though I would start liking him been I just ended up doing so. He plays the role wonderfuly, the manersim, gestures etc. Ken from the TW version wasnt bad either. Japanese was alright.

Toss up between VANNESS WU Taiwanese version and KIM JOON Korean version. Both were entertaining and good in the roles, loved how Vanness always played with is hair and how Kim Joon does those my brother yo lines. So funny. What I liked most about these two were how they showed the strong friendship between the F4. I can't pick.

KIM SO EUN/Chu Ga- Korean: Even though they changed her character in the Korean version to be not shy and timid as in the other versions, Kim so made it work. She is bright and so natural in her role unlike Koo who plays Jandi. I personally would have picked her as Jan Di but is what it is. She plays a true best friend.


i agree with your point of view.. though i really love jun matsumoto..
1778 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / rock bottom
Offline
Posted 3/12/09
i love all of them...

they have different attacks to the character that the are playing...
650 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
20 / F / Australia
Offline
Posted 3/13/09

Luvyoujamie wrote:


piggyinthemiddle wrote:

the taiwanese of course!!!!

love u jerry


love u venness


hate u vic


were the last two vaness from H.O.T.?


dunno got the pics from google
4415 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F
Offline
Posted 3/13/09
love junpyo<lee minho>
<333
41 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
35 / F / QuEzOn CiTy, Phil...
Offline
Posted 3/13/09
my turn:
The chemistry between Tsukasa Domyouji and Tsukushi Makino: is Japanese theirs alot of chemistry b/w them

Tsukushi Makino: Inoue Mao

Tsukasa Domyouji: This is tough. This is the most tough decision I ever made in my whole life coz I like them all. They have their own unique style to portrait this character but I think I will chose Jerry Yan. Why? because he's the 1st person who portrait Tsukasa plus I like the way he act, from heartless person to a very soft person who try his very best to please the girl he love in spite of his mother will. And there is something about Jerry that makes me feel comfortable to watch him.

Hanazawa Rui :Oguri Shun. So smooth acting, and between shun and Mao they also have this chemistry. They also look good together.

Nishikado Sojiro: Kim Bum and makino bestfriend is Kim So Eun. They look so good together.

Mimasaka Akira: Vanness Wu
943 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F
Offline
Posted 3/13/09 , edited 3/13/09
Makino- Inoue Mao does a WAYYY better job then Goo Hye Sun, i DO NOT see the makino in Goo Hye Sun's portrayal.....no offence

Domyouji- Jun Matsumoto and Lee Min Ho, i love both!

Hanazawa Rui- Oguri Shun, he has a better acting skill then Kim Hyun Joong, Hyun Joong is kinda stiff and don't have much of that mysterious vibe, but his forgiven cos his a rookie and his hot

Nishikado Sojiro -Kim Bum because he seems to be a 'pottery' person and well....his HOT + CUTE!

Mimasaka Akira - i suppose Abe Tsuyoshi has a little bit more mimasaka akira because i see him as the player whereas Kim Joon is like hardly noticeable..i suppose??

Makino's best friend- Kim So Eun-SHE'S FREAKIN AWESOME!!! i support SoEul couple and she's really pretty

i havn't seen the taiwanese version and im not planning to....so yh i'll just compare tha jap and kor versions. =)
2501 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / Chansung's ♥
Offline
Posted 3/13/09
You read my mind.
1379 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F / 12345 Rainbow Street
Offline
Posted 3/13/09

piggyinthemiddle wrote:


Luvyoujamie wrote:


piggyinthemiddle wrote:

the taiwanese of course!!!!

love u jerry


love u venness


hate u vic


were the last two vaness from H.O.T.?


dunno got the pics from google


LOL okay hahahaha
3044 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / lala land.
Offline
Posted 3/13/09
Japanese FTW.
10694 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / USA
Offline
Posted 3/13/09
tsukushi: definitely inoue mao. the other two i don't like so much.

tsukasa: jerry yan did a really good job with him. lee min ho comes in second.

rui: oguri shun for sure on this one. shun's portrayal of rui is still my fav drama character of ALL TIME

sojirou: kim bum does a pretty good job with him.

akira: vanness wu is a no brainer for me on this one. although the korean one is funny, vanness does the best job at portraying the son of a mafia boss.
1241 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Beautiful British...
Offline
Posted 3/13/09
Well, right now I think Inuoe Mao portrays Makino the best, no contest.
Matsumoto Jun & Lee Minho are on a thin line! I can't decide which of them portrays Domyoji better...they're all so goofy and cute XD
52745 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / New Orleans
Offline
Posted 3/13/09
agreed agreed!!! ahahh
45801 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / F / new york city
Offline
Posted 3/13/09
Tsukushi : INOUE MAO..i think she brought out the makino character the best...nd i also like GOO HYE SUN..i thought she wud suck in da beginning but 4rom sum recent episode, i really like her.
Tsukasa: of course JERRY YAN...his expression nd arogant behavior nd everythin remind me of tsukasa nd 2nd is LEE MIN OH...he might hav the perfect appearance of TSUKASA but i had to go with JERRY
Rui: mmmm this was difficult, cuz i liked all three of them..OGURI was awesum, HJ made me luv the Rui character wen i didnt actually like him 4rom the manga or the taiwanor japanese version.
Sojiro:KIM BUM..he's the sexiest player out there nd sort of tooo innocent Ken was more out there, kissin random girl nd all.
Akira: ...not sure abt this 1..i liked all of the motherly figure friend..they all did a gudd job portrayin the role
Matsuoka Yuki: thts obviously KIM SO EUN...i didnt really like any of the other version yuki or noticed them..kinda found them annoyin

12924 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / look behind you. (:
Offline
Posted 3/13/09
i love the korean guys. (:
they are HOTT
Kim Hyung Joong , hes so SEXY ! >: D
and Kim bum has an AMAZING smile, that can like literally kill you. (: ♥
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.