Remove this ad
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next  Last
Should there be a season 2?
Member
6656 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
38 / F / Down the Rabbit Hole
Offline
Posted 2/11/09 , edited 2/11/09

RonBurgundy wrote:

Here we go again.... one of those "Lord of the Rings movies vs. the books".

It's time like this it's better to have seen the movie before reading it, else you will just be disappointed because of outrageous expectations or subjective differences, you have to understand some very important things about movies and books, just the same goes with manga and anime.

It's almost in every way impossible to create a worthwhile movie if you follow the book by every grain of corn. There are different forms of climaxes and such which counts more important at different times. Same with anime and manga.


See below.


RonBurgundy wrote:
Before i go on, you have already spoiled yourself when you read the book/manga before watching the movie/anime, which in itself is your own demise, unchangeable perhaps, but still your own fault. There won't be many surprises through that and obviously you'll be not as "whoa this rocks!" , about it


Actually I think the opposite is true for me. It's because I am so into the manga that I enjoy the series so much. But I've always been a shade weird like that.


Yuri256 wrote:

aha, to hate the anime obviously Even though it does make more skip beat fans, i don't even think they r the good fans that actually knows what a good anime means ^.^ either way i hate the anime especially the drawing and the stupid voice sactors and actresses. When i first saw it, i was "this totally sucks compare to the manga" than when i think back to the manga, it shouldn't even be compared! the people who only likes the anime are total idiots who doesn't know a thing about the manga and definitely not skip beat's real fan!


And how does that make you the authority? Just because you say so? And we all are idiots because we don't agree?

I think Dragonball Z is horrific and Lucky Star is extremely overrated. If someone asks me why I will tell them, in detail, but that doesn't mean I call fans of those series idiots.

I have read the manga. I've known about it for more then two years. I read the fan trans on-line and buy the official Viz release. I prefer the manga, but I appreciate the anime for what it is. (I even edit a guide for the animated series!) I find it to be entertaining and extremely funny. The problem is that many 'purests' can't comprehend that the two are not the same and were never meant to be the same. Animation is an extremely different medium to be told in a different way. It's the same basic story, but has to be altered for the medium.
Member
13427 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / F / East of the Sun a...
Offline
Posted 2/11/09

the-nishikaze wrote:


kyrissanean wrote:

...what I meant by the double posting thing...that you shouldn't, if you've posted just minutes/hours ago, start another reply when in fact you could just go and edit what you just wrote...because currently you're the last person to post something in the thread... that's all... IF it was an error made by the site... then mark it as spam and maybe it will eventually be removed by the moderator or whoever does cleanup... and yes I mainly meant it for mainly not choosing to edit the last post (which is yours) and just posting right after it anyway...


That's incredibly offensive. You are not a moderator and should not be talking down to other members on this board. You really should be a litttle more careful and re-read what you post before you post it. Unless you meant to offend the other members on this board.


...I'm not trying to offend anyone ... I was just trying to explain the way I was seeing a double post - not the clicking 2x but the posting of something... and then starting a whole new post just minutes/hours later... when you could edit the post - and this was not aimed at anyone... just a general comment that its easier to follow the conversations when the people aren't putting something up and then putting something else up right after... it would be more easy to follow the interaction between commenters when there are other people's responses interspersed between yours...

- and I am using "you" as in people out there in the forum, not one specific person...

...and I don't see this as talking anyone down...since I am not targeting anyone... just trying to keep things organized... sorry if you found issue with it... seeing as so far only one person has made a big deal out of it I don't know if it would be considered as something really offensive or just an attempt to keep things going in a certain direction that makes the whole conversation we're sharing easy to follow... and since I was the one who started this post... I kind of feel responsible for it... at least a little...so that is why I made that observation...
279 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
20 / F / Kansas City, MO
Offline
Posted 2/11/09
Yes, there should. After I heard about the taiwanese version of Skip Beat, thought were running through my mind. If the drama sucks, there is always the anime to fall back on. n_n
456 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / Akatsuki Base
Offline
Posted 2/11/09
25 episodes is definitely not enough for skip beat, i mean, the manga is not yet finish
There's no way they're gonna end the anime in a stupid way >_<
Member
27964 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / In HeR BeauTiFuL...
Offline
Posted 2/12/09

Yuri256 wrote:


Princessa77 wrote:

definitely !! based on the manga !! the anime will even get more and more interesting !


the manga is already interesting as it is, and the anime is ruining by the drawing's and how voice actor's feelings and voices don't match the characters! my god isn't there anybody who understands what i'm saying!? i'm telling u, the anime sucks! it just keep on ruining the manga!!


i do understand , but isn't the same with each and every anime ?! Mangas r always way better =)
165 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 2/12/09
definitely. season 2. awesome.
Member
4032 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / New York
Offline
Posted 2/12/09 , edited 2/12/09

Yuri256 wrote:

aha, to hate the anime obviously Even though it does make more skip beat fans, i don't even think they r the good fans that actually knows what a good anime means ^.^ either way i hate the anime especially the drawing and the stupid voice sactors and actresses. When i first saw it, i was "this totally sucks compare to the manga" than when i think back to the manga, it shouldn't even be compared! the people who only likes the anime are total idiots who doesn't know a thing about the manga and definitely not skip beat's real fan!


I would like to disagree ^^;;
I think the girl who did kyouko's voice is a genius really! I think she portrayed kyouko's personality pretty well =)
kyouko, sometimes a bit crazy yet sweet ^^
this is the voice actress: http://myanimelist.net/people/158/Marina_Inoue
As you can see, she did many other awesome voices! ^^

Anyway, aside from kyouko, I thought shou's voice is genius too!
I can totally imagine his snobby self to sound like that xD

All in all, I really think they did a wonderful job even though it might differ from your point of view of how they should sound like @.@
That's the beauty of books or mangas, you get to imagine what they sound like and how they would be...
So for them to translate it into an anime, it's incredible because I know many people that are pleased with the voices =)

What I'm trying to say is, they are awesome! and if you compare it to english dubbed animes, they are like... super awesome *-*
Seriously, english voice dubbers need some lessons =P

one more thing ^^ you can't really compare manga to anime... the anime is the way it is, how the producers and directors pictured it, so you might disagree, doesn't mean it sucks >_> I think the voice actors/actress' are super talented. Voicing is actually harder than it looks *points at english dubbed animes*

[edit] I do follow the anime and manga... i think they are both awesome =)
2293 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / Over the rainbow
Offline
Posted 2/12/09
HELL YEAH i want another season!

..i want to see the dark moon arc!!!!
Member
1104 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Singapore
Offline
Posted 2/13/09
of cuz there's should be, it's quite hilarious!
Member
13427 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / F / East of the Sun a...
Offline
Posted 2/13/09

swtcakes wrote:


Yuri256 wrote:

aha, to hate the anime obviously Even though it does make more skip beat fans, i don't even think they r the good fans that actually knows what a good anime means ^.^ either way i hate the anime especially the drawing and the stupid voice sactors and actresses. When i first saw it, i was "this totally sucks compare to the manga" than when i think back to the manga, it shouldn't even be compared! the people who only likes the anime are total idiots who doesn't know a thing about the manga and definitely not skip beat's real fan!


I would like to disagree ^^;;
I think the girl who did kyouko's voice is a genius really! I think she portrayed kyouko's personality pretty well =)
kyouko, sometimes a bit crazy yet sweet ^^
this is the voice actress: http://myanimelist.net/people/158/Marina_Inoue
As you can see, she did many other awesome voices! ^^

Anyway, aside from kyouko, I thought shou's voice is genius too!
I can totally imagine his snobby self to sound like that xD

All in all, I really think they did a wonderful job even though it might differ from your point of view of how they should sound like @.@
That's the beauty of books or mangas, you get to imagine what they sound like and how they would be...
So for them to translate it into an anime, it's incredible because I know many people that are pleased with the voices =)

What I'm trying to say is, they are awesome! and if you compare it to english dubbed animes, they are like... super awesome *-*
Seriously, english voice dubbers need some lessons =P

one more thing ^^ you can't really compare manga to anime... the anime is the way it is, how the producers and directors pictured it, so you might disagree, doesn't mean it sucks >_> I think the voice actors/actress' are super talented. Voicing is actually harder than it looks *points at english dubbed animes*

[edit] I do follow the anime and manga... i think they are both awesome =)


I agree with you on the voices - I think the effort put in by the voice actors really made the characters believable and this is what makes the story even more believable because you can hear the character's feeling in their voice.
I also completely agree with you on the horrid attempts at dubbing by companies in the US... oh my god those are horrible... its like they don't even CARE about what they're doing the voice for... nor do I think they actually play clips of the Japanese voice actors for the American voice actors to get an idea of the emotion needed for that character... its really sad... and that is why I enjoy subbed anime
Member
4032 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / New York
Offline
Posted 2/13/09

kyrissanean wrote:


swtcakes wrote:


Yuri256 wrote:

aha, to hate the anime obviously Even though it does make more skip beat fans, i don't even think they r the good fans that actually knows what a good anime means ^.^ either way i hate the anime especially the drawing and the stupid voice sactors and actresses. When i first saw it, i was "this totally sucks compare to the manga" than when i think back to the manga, it shouldn't even be compared! the people who only likes the anime are total idiots who doesn't know a thing about the manga and definitely not skip beat's real fan!


I would like to disagree ^^;;
I think the girl who did kyouko's voice is a genius really! I think she portrayed kyouko's personality pretty well =)
kyouko, sometimes a bit crazy yet sweet ^^
this is the voice actress: http://myanimelist.net/people/158/Marina_Inoue
As you can see, she did many other awesome voices! ^^

Anyway, aside from kyouko, I thought shou's voice is genius too!
I can totally imagine his snobby self to sound like that xD

All in all, I really think they did a wonderful job even though it might differ from your point of view of how they should sound like @.@
That's the beauty of books or mangas, you get to imagine what they sound like and how they would be...
So for them to translate it into an anime, it's incredible because I know many people that are pleased with the voices =)

What I'm trying to say is, they are awesome! and if you compare it to english dubbed animes, they are like... super awesome *-*
Seriously, english voice dubbers need some lessons =P

one more thing ^^ you can't really compare manga to anime... the anime is the way it is, how the producers and directors pictured it, so you might disagree, doesn't mean it sucks >_> I think the voice actors/actress' are super talented. Voicing is actually harder than it looks *points at english dubbed animes*

[edit] I do follow the anime and manga... i think they are both awesome =)


I agree with you on the voices - I think the effort put in by the voice actors really made the characters believable and this is what makes the story even more believable because you can hear the character's feeling in their voice.
I also completely agree with you on the horrid attempts at dubbing by companies in the US... oh my god those are horrible... its like they don't even CARE about what they're doing the voice for... nor do I think they actually play clips of the Japanese voice actors for the American voice actors to get an idea of the emotion needed for that character... its really sad... and that is why I enjoy subbed anime :D


Yes that's the reason I enjoy subbed anime too =3
I wish there was a way I can buy subbed anime on dvd o.o
hm... anyone has any idea where they might sell it?
Member
50130 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / United Kingdom
Offline
Posted 2/13/09
oh come on!no need to think about it...there should be season 2!many skip beat fans are craving for it (obviously, including me)...hakhak...

and on what u guys are talking about...i think skip beat fans have their own preferences...either its on anime or manga version, skip beat is really great!i think it's one of the best anime/manga i've ever known...and please, skip beat fans should unite and agree with each other not arguing unless u are comparing it with other animes/manga....

and by the way, i agree with the 'dub' thing...no offense but English dubbing is quite lame...it gets me irritated and i think my eardrums just wanted to explode! therefore i prefer the subbed ones...japanese are simply geniuses!they're really great doing this kind of stuffs about animes and technology....n_n
Posted 2/13/09
Naww i think 25 is enough so the buisnesses slow down and start making other animes like Kamichama Karin and Kamichama Karin CHU which said was gonna be released but it been i think years now :/
Member
1018 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
19 / F / Where the music t...
Offline
Posted 2/13/09
For this anime?! Absolutely! :]!
Member
10697 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / In your closet...
Offline
Posted 2/13/09
They should have a 2nd season!!! This anime is one of my favorites!!!!
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.