First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next  Last
Korea's Top 50 Vocals
3316 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / ~g00d oL' eNgLaNd~
Offline
Posted 3/11/09
why the hell isn't Wheesung in the top 50??
that man can freakin sing beautifully!!
i dnt like the list
42 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / guess what, earth
Offline
Posted 3/11/09

hime_chama wrote:


daesunglovers wrote:



well obviosly u pretty biased^^as much i love shinhwa too....but soory dear daesung pretty much sound more good to me...compare to hyesung...http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAauCla6cEA&feature=related on this vid...

Oh by d way, hyesung is not as same league as junsu...seriously....he is way much more better than hyesung....please prove me wrong !! Give me the best solo's from hyesung...( just let be honest, not a fan but just an honest answer even tho' i love BB)


Well i love daesung on this vid http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iogI9aNx3Vo but he is much more better now...in other hand hyesung ....sorry!!! he just an average.....for me dongwan sound much more better than he is..


http://www.haoting.com/htmusic/96391ht.htm -> hyesung's mirror in his first solo album.
i dont know how you define or appreciate good vocals, but hyesung is definitely not just average. read the comments here. i'm not the only one thinking hyesung shld go much higher on the list.
hyesung is definitely better than dongwan. having strong vocals and being able to scream to hit that particular high note doesnt define a good singer properly. it takes much more than just a strong voice to make a good singer. hyesung has the strength in his voice, no doubt. his voice has the identity. his voice has the charisma. from those males in the list, he definitely deserves to be in the top 3. he's the best out of those in the list for me anyway.... well, unless if you pull in hwanhee then perhaps hyesung shall go second?
and do know, a couple of years ago, hyesung was voted the number one voice females will like to have him sing to them during a proposal? pardon me for the horrible translation. it was said by the mc in one of the many variety shows shinhwa has gone on as a group.
anyway, it all boils down to individual preferences. there's absolutely nothing wrong in me feeling that hyesung is of the same level as xiah, and neither is it wrong for me to think that hyesung is better than daesung. you're entitled to your own opinions too, while i'm entitled to my own. Hyesung still tops everything in my opinion. His voice just hits all the right spot for me, as simple as that.


thanks for the link ..after listened to it , the voice pretty much didnt appeal to me like WOW or what so ever. but i agree on we entitled to our own opinion..i also agree about hwan hee...he is so much better for me to sing on my wedding,ahaks....
on my opinion, having strong vocals and being able to scream to hit that particular high pretty much a good singer ..look at celine dion and mariah carey for example....

people tend to pay attention to those who have a strong vocal rather than some kind of soft and etc...well look at fantasia from american idol ...

well as for daesung, he still have along way to go...but i will keep supporting him...it's not like i cant accept my idol not being on top5..

as i mention earlier....i think out of the list for me junsu pretty much fit his place....i repeat out of the list given.....

so i think we should stop replying and quoting because we 'll end up like no where...so i respect ur opinion and hopefully u 'll do too...

after all it is just some kind of list that come from thailand...that was their opinion on who have the best voice...music is universal after all...
by the way it is not based on popularity, i dun why people keep saying when it come to DBSK, nah....that 's just based on popularity vote..why not we accept that not everything that related to dbsk have to do wit popularity....it seem like they cant sing for shit....pretty much for me they r the best vocal among the group , huh hate to admit that...

anyway I love daesung
2076 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / WHO KNOWS?!
Offline
Posted 3/11/09
xD Was this list made by polls or...? xD It seems... not... realistic. :x HyoLee? Really?
47470 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / Birmingham
Offline
Posted 3/11/09
This list is quite off really, I agree with about 4.
22336 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23
Offline
Posted 3/11/09
GSP!* i love them all XD
JUNSU!!!! aww why's yunho not on! Dx the rest of dbsk are on! NO!!!!!
9860 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / Living in the US...
Offline
Posted 3/11/09
yay for Xiah. he's number one!! haha.
5578 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
AY-SH-UH
Offline
Posted 3/11/09
LOL, sorry ladies...#2 is TAKEN.
1103 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / Himitsu
Offline
Posted 3/11/09

midnite_silver wrote:

xD Was this list made by polls or...? xD It seems... not... realistic. :x HyoLee? Really?


that's what i'm thinking too. i didnt rmb solbi being a good singer at all, but seems like she got more popular due to wgm?
haha...
oh well, but certain fans are insisting it's not based on popularity but based on real talents because their idol(s) topped the list.
13914 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F
Offline
Posted 3/11/09
ehh.... the females list doesnt really make much sense...Solbi? i mean no offence but her singing is juz average...
Posted 3/11/09

daesunglovers wrote:



well obviosly u pretty biased^^as much i love shinhwa too....but soory dear daesung pretty much sound more good to me...compare to hyesung...http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAauCla6cEA&feature=related on this vid...

Oh by d way, hyesung is not as same league as junsu...seriously....he is way much more better than hyesung....please prove me wrong !! Give me the best solo's from hyesung...( just let be honest, not a fan but just an honest answer even tho' i love BB)


Well i love daesung on this vid http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iogI9aNx3Vo but he is much more better now...in other hand hyesung ....sorry!!! he just an average.....for me dongwan sound much more better than he is..


nah, hyesung is better than daesung and junsu. i'm saying for the case of ballads. hyesung can go much softer and soothier(?) than the two younger boys.
hyesung's voice isnt very flexible though. he can't handle r&b and fast-paced dancey songs as well as ballads.
but for ballads, he owns them.
3258 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / F / Lala Land
Offline
Posted 3/11/09
come on, the list is warped.
hyesung shld go further up the list, at least higher than andy, minwoo and junjin.
hyesung is also definitely better than se7en, hyunjoong and that... is that the suju guy? or some other sm band guy.
in other words, hyesung shld be on top 3.
and where the hell is fany FTTS?
and wth, hyori made it up to the list too? solbi?! sunmi better than sunye?
boa as number 1? boa has got talents yes, but her voice simply dont make a number 1 cut.
since it's 'top vocals', where is Lena Park, the singer who sang kummeh(pardon me for the horrible romanised version)?
this is a poll, right?
44 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / My room
Offline
Posted 3/11/09 , edited 3/11/09

daesunglovers wrote:


courtknee wrote:

Se7en sings better than Junsu and Jaejoong.
Wheesung and Park Hyo Shin sing better than them.
>___>

This list is stupid.

duh.....se7en sing better than junsu and jaejoong? ....even my daesung sing better than se7en lol.....Se7en cant even sing....he is just an average even tho he has american album or what so ever it is....



miamoro wrote:

I dont think the Ranking makes sense att all or is fair cause both Male & female top singers are wrong
there are way better & greater voices than them Even though i like DB & Boa but Xiah & JJ aren`t the best nor is boa
it seems as it was selected for most popualr than best vocals

None of FTTS are there nor SG wanna be , V.o.S ..etc ppl with great vocal
how can shin hye sung be in the bottom & xiah 1st totally weird
(being fair not bashing but this poll isnt fair at all)
same goes to female poll >< totally not fair alot of great vocalist arent there


well based on the list given, i believe junsu and jj deserve to be on the top....no one better than they r on the list to be on the top....as much as i love daesung, just let's not be bias ...i have to admit after sbs gayo , junsu has d best vocal out of the list....JJ also can be on the top...
wish if it was daesung ...but hey maybe next time...







~~~~~~~~~~~
Don't double post. Use the edit button, next time.
~ edited by edsamac



Okay i love Daesung`s voice & wish him to sing more ballad plus have alot of solos as tae yang but i guess he enjoys himself , Junsu has such soulful voice but JJ 2nd O_o where did VOS performing & lots of others go Whee sung isnt there either ! i`m not bias but to be fair there are many who deserves to be there but i guess fans voted to make their idols up U_U

PS : Shin hye sung`s voice isnt average ! are you sure you saw or listened to him alot , no offense but i know that guy for years been listening to shinhwa & his solos too ! you cant say average i like junsu but Shin hye sung is one of my fav singers & can beat Junsu easially not to mention DaeDae too



hime_chama wrote:


miamoro wrote:

I dont think the Ranking makes sense att all or is fair cause both Male & female top singers are wrong
there are way better & greater voices than them Even though i like DB & Boa but Xiah & JJ aren`t the best nor is boa
it seems as it was selected for most popualr than best vocals

None of FTTS are there nor SG wanna be , V.o.S ..etc ppl with great vocal
how can shin hye sung be in the bottom & xiah 1st totally weird
(being fair not bashing but this poll isnt fair at all)
same goes to female poll >< totally not fair alot of great vocalist arent there


yes, that's why i think this is a voted list. it's not in terms of real talent, but popularity.


True even HwanHee who has an amazing voice isnt here neither is Wheesung as i said i guess Fans voted for their idols cause it doesnt make sense if even SG wanna be members arent ther JinHo deserves being there too


nabah wrote:

for me, in order to judge for best vocal for an artist i must watch their live perf....it's unrealistic for us to listen to the 'edited one' and judge them bcoz at this super duper technology time alot of thing can be done...the worst can be 'polished' and makeover to be the best. until now i can say that some artist deserve to get the rank and some don't. for me hwanhee(ftts) and VOS should be at least in top 10. for SG wannabe i never watched their live perf so...can't tell. howl should be in d list too. i can say xiah n jj got the voice...

dont know for female...i think i dont agree w most of 'em...

okay i do agree not seeing hwanhee nor any of VOS shocked me + pissed me off
since you never saw any Sg wanna be i`ll select random live performance With their old Member & one with the current one i`m sure you`ll love them cause they are great ! & they showed that they`re not only ballad singers too anyway here`s the links
from old to new (sorry if some vids are low quality )
Saldaga perf
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3OQFhGemvLc&feature=related
Cactus
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BNHqpbcur-k&feature=related#
SG Wannabe-Sarangga
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aYtZAO3E4is&feature=related
ARIRANG Per
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n-GDX9rWQlQ&feature=related
Now With the New Member
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CmAEp0kKr0A&feature=related
i hope you know why i said they should`ve been on the list Espcially JinHo :)Enjoy

ringo_seijin wrote:

come on, the list is warped.
hyesung shld go further up the list, at least higher than andy, minwoo and junjin.
hyesung is also definitely better than se7en, hyunjoong and that... is that the suju guy? or some other sm band guy.
in other words, hyesung shld be on top 3.
and where the hell is fany FTTS?
and wth, hyori made it up to the list too? solbi?! sunmi better than sunye?
boa as number 1? boa has got talents yes, but her voice simply dont make a number 1 cut.
since it's 'top vocals', where is Lena Park, the singer who sang kummeh(pardon me for the horrible romanised version)?
this is a poll, right?


i SO Agree with you ! Lena Park , Baek Ji young ,lee soo young , Oak Ju hyun ,See ya gals , Gavi nj ,Davichi ,brown eyed girls....etc most of the chosen are dissapointing O_o sorry but how can they choose for best korean vocal like tht *weird poll *
102 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / somewhere here
Offline
Posted 3/12/09
Hyesung just an average for me. I don't care if he is Shinhwa or not. Shinhwa of course the legend because the stay together like 10 years now but their vocal is just an average . For me people tend to assume that there are awesome because of the fact that they are still together.
But minwoo and eric is one of the best dancer. I prefer listen to FTTS rather than SHINHWA even though they are like senior in this case.

Same as HOT, they are the apprentice to kpop, but their voice is just OK, i only like kangta's voice. But saying this i might get bash, because they are legend same as SHINHWA too.

But as a group , Shinhwa can be consider as a good vocal compare to other group that come from the same generation . SM somehow produced a talented group unlike some other companies.

Overall if they are not SHINHWA, people will realize the fact that their voice is just OK.
48429 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / Boredom Wonderland
Offline
Posted 3/12/09
the best vocal in SS501 - main vocal - heo young saeng and kim hyung joon.. not in list? this can't b true, why hyun joong in list either i think he got the worst vocal in that group..[/red ] my opinion.. sorry 4 hyun joong big fans..
102 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / somewhere here
Offline
Posted 3/12/09

alizaraf wrote:

the best vocal in SS501 - main vocal - heo young saeng and kim hyung joon.. not in list? this can't b true, why hyun joong in list either i think he got the worst vocal in that group..[/red ] my opinion.. sorry 4 hyun joong big fans..


agree on hyun joong is the worst for ss501 even though i love when he was on WM and BOF. But that doesn't change that the fact he is worst
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.