First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
Post Reply TOPIC | Athrun vs Shinn
Posted 3/11/09
Do u think Athrun is better or Shinn is better.

And i cant believe i made a stoopid topic in my group. i know alot would say athrun.... and i hate shinn.....
Why i hate shinn?
A: Thats my nature

and 4 starters, i say athrun coz athrun is more skilled. Athrun"John Cena"Zala and Kira"Chuck Norris" Yamato r my favourites......
Moderator
18276 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Orb Union
Offline
Posted 3/16/09
U had the question, and u had the answer. Athrun is definitely more skilled than Shinn. I think, a huge part played on whether anot u are willing to use the elements to ur advantage.

Shinn had been advised by AThrun multiple times, and he din take his advice, which is what leads him to his downfall. Futhermore, his action of not taking athrun's advice became something in him in which grew or cultivate that kind of "i am do everything by myself" or "i am the only one who can do anything in this world".

As for athrun, he had the advantage of the lessons of the past war, knowing how to pull himself out of a war-trance and also his skills are sharpened more.... i guess it is it.
Posted 3/27/09
yep, but i kno dat ppl think Shinn is better than kira and athrun.....
but, no matter how much shinn improves, Athrun is one of the strongest corrodinators along with Kira
Posted 3/30/09 , edited 3/31/09
okay heres wat i think

impulse vs savior , shin wins

justice vs destiny, athrun wins

i am going to say athrun he is experienced and yes shin did defeat kira but thats because he had rey come up with the tactics but without rey shin isn't as great on his own as shown in the last episode of see destiny. But i do expect shin do get better in the movie and to learn from his mistakes yeah he had a rough ride but so did athrun in season 1 of seed and he made up 4 it in destiny so why not shin as well
Moderator
17598 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / ...Philippines...
Offline
Posted 4/15/09
Well I say Athrun hands down.

Well, I'm probably biased coz I hate Shinn..
(if you're wondering why, the answer is pretty simple.. he's such a brat.. he bullies Cagalli-just coz he's mad at Orb-, thinks he's the most miserable person in the world-tho thats just my opinion-, and yeah, I hate his guts. *sigh* at least my hatest character in the first season died.. lol.)

Well, I kinda ranted a bit there.. But I get really fired up when its about Shinn. lol.

Athrun did improve compared to how he was in seed. Because of experience. And I agree that Shinn will probably still improve(though I'll still probably hate him.lol.). But at least Athrun was still very likeable even in seed when he was having rough times.. So I still say Athrun wins whatever happens. lol. But thats just me.
Moderator
18276 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Orb Union
Offline
Posted 4/29/09

3kawaii3 wrote:

Well I say Athrun hands down.

Well, I'm probably biased coz I hate Shinn..
(if you're wondering why, the answer is pretty simple.. he's such a brat.. he bullies Cagalli-just coz he's mad at Orb-, thinks he's the most miserable person in the world-tho thats just my opinion-, and yeah, I hate his guts. *sigh* at least my hatest character in the first season died.. lol.)

Well, I kinda ranted a bit there.. But I get really fired up when its about Shinn. lol.

Athrun did improve compared to how he was in seed. Because of experience. And I agree that Shinn will probably still improve(though I'll still probably hate him.lol.). But at least Athrun was still very likeable even in seed when he was having rough times.. So I still say Athrun wins whatever happens. lol. But thats just me.


it is not just u, u know.

as for ur comment that shinn bullied cagalli, i totally agree. he had never seen cagalli before, and he judged based on his own biased thoughts and emotions, so there is no reason there to blame cagalli then for his family's death. in truth, he is just another brat.
Moderator
17598 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / ...Philippines...
Offline
Posted 5/1/09

xlandar wrote:

it is not just u, u know.

as for ur comment that shinn bullied cagalli, i totally agree. he had never seen cagalli before, and he judged based on his own biased thoughts and emotions, so there is no reason there to blame cagalli then for his family's death. in truth, he is just another brat.


Yeah! He is a brat.. lol. Yay!! I'm glad its not just me. lol. XD
Moderator
18276 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Orb Union
Offline
Posted 5/1/09

3kawaii3 wrote:


xlandar wrote:

it is not just u, u know.

as for ur comment that shinn bullied cagalli, i totally agree. he had never seen cagalli before, and he judged based on his own biased thoughts and emotions, so there is no reason there to blame cagalli then for his family's death. in truth, he is just another brat.


Yeah! He is a brat.. lol. Yay!! I'm glad its not just me. lol. XD


hey, u are too influenced by those shinn supporters! where did u meet so many, that u are soo depressed and hopeless?
Moderator
17598 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / ...Philippines...
Offline
Posted 5/1/09

xlandar wrote:

hey, u are too influenced by those shinn supporters! where did u meet so many, that u are soo depressed and hopeless?


Yeah, I'm depressed and lonely. lol. XD

My best friends!! lol. XD

She adores Shinn. Really loves him. lol. And my other best friend likes him.(her fave is Kira though).

Well, I rant about Shinn to them but it always ends in debate. lol. XD They don't understand my feelings.. XD
So you see, I don't really have a comrade in real life..
Moderator
18276 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Orb Union
Offline
Posted 5/1/09

3kawaii3 wrote:


xlandar wrote:

hey, u are too influenced by those shinn supporters! where did u meet so many, that u are soo depressed and hopeless?


Yeah, I'm depressed and lonely. lol. XD

My best friends!! lol. XD

She adores Shinn. Really loves him. lol. And my other best friend likes him.(her fave is Kira though).

Well, I rant about Shinn to them but it always ends in debate. lol. XD They don't understand my feelings.. XD
So you see, I don't really have a comrade in real life..


hmm... u know u got a real power team.. u support athrun, ur best friend support shinn and the other one supports kira... all the best pilots. but athrun is the ultimate best.
Moderator
17598 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / ...Philippines...
Offline
Posted 5/1/09

xlandar wrote:

hmm... u know u got a real power team.. u support athrun, ur best friend support shinn and the other one supports kira... all the best pilots. but athrun is the ultimate best.


lol, yeah, I agree. XD Athrun is the BEST!! Yay!
Guess my friends and I have good taste.. XD

*sigh* if not for Shinn's hateful attitude..
Moderator
18276 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Orb Union
Offline
Posted 5/1/09 , edited 5/1/09

3kawaii3 wrote:


xlandar wrote:

hmm... u know u got a real power team.. u support athrun, ur best friend support shinn and the other one supports kira... all the best pilots. but athrun is the ultimate best.


lol, yeah, I agree. XD Athrun is the BEST!! Yay!
Guess my friends and I have good taste.. XD

*sigh* if not for Shinn's hateful attitude..


haha, yup, u nid to see it that way.
Member
13092 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / In a corner .
Offline
Posted 6/3/09
Athrun cuz my nature is hating Shinn sadly I just hate him...
cuz he's snobby and he doesn't even respect his elders!!!
Also he's too naive he doesn't think strategically and is short tempered whereas Athrun actually thinks of what he's doing. Proving there that Athrun would win in a mobile suit battle
Posted 6/4/09

Well I am an Athrun lover but I also like Shinn alot and know where he comes from with his attitude, I don't think u can just blame Shinn for just about everything. He is short-tempered I know but you have to realise that Shinn is ACTUALLY trying his best to protect the ones he cares for. He only has another way of doing, I am not saying that everything that he does is right, but its also that he doesn't always does something wrong. he is young, saw horrible things, lost his dear family, he makes mistakes like any other person.

and only hating him because he bullied Cagalli?? come on >__>


3kawaii3 wrote:

](if you're wondering why, the answer is pretty simple.. he's such a brat.. he bullies Cagalli-just coz he's mad at Orb-, thinks he's the most miserable person in the world-tho thats just my opinion-, and yeah, I hate his guts. *sigh* at least my hatest character in the first season died.. lol.)




thinks he is the most miserable person in the world?? What the hell? he doesn't even think that at all on the contorary, he believes that he is strong ^^ Well it comes to this. I love both Shinn and Athrun, they both have flaws but thats what making them human!!!! I am probably alone on this one, but I will stand up for Shinn whenever needed >w<

And.... he is NOT a brat =.=
Moderator
17598 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / F / ...Philippines...
Offline
Posted 6/19/09 , edited 6/19/09


Well now.. I can't help hating someone who directs his stupid anger at my favorite character. >_>
I mean, come on... You love Shinn right? You're saying all these coz I hate him..

Same here.
I love Cagalli and that's one of the reasons I can't stand Shinn.
To each her own.. I guess. ^^

About the miserable thing, I said in my post that its just my opinion.
I hate it when he's all emo and stuff. (but then again, that's just me)

lol, you're not alone.
MY best friend LOVES Shinn.
XD

But I think she only likes his looks. lol.
But yeah, you're not alone. XD

But I still believe he's a brat. XD
lol, sorry sorry..
First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.