Do you think Skip Beat should be made into a drama?
792 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F
Offline
Posted 5/30/09 , edited 5/30/09
I know it's long, but please read it!!
Ok.
You guys should have heard by now that the brilliant Skip Beat! is gonna be made into dramas.
What are your thoughts on that?
I'm not Jap, so I can't really comment on the Japanese version, but apparently there's gonna be a taiwanese version as well...
It would be starring Jerry Yan and Ariel Lin...
Unfortunately, I think that would ruin the whole perception the audience has on Skip Beat!
Before the fans of those two actors decide to hunt me down, let me explain.
Ren and Kyoko's personalities totally do not match the profiles of Jerry and Ariel.
As the two main characters, the personality traits are extremely important.
Based on their previous roles from their dramas, I don't think they can play anything but the roles with those certain traits.
In the real world, there's no such thing as the perfect acting from Skip Beat! (there probably are, but that's like one in a million).
Anyway, my point is that it'd be wiser for the director to choose actors closer to the external personality traits of the characters.
That way, it would greatly increase the number of Skip Beat! fans.
If people decide to watch the drama first, that is basically what they will think of the original work (believe me, I use to be one of those people).
If you ask me, if they HAVE TO make a drama out of the original works, they'd probably be better off using someone like Jiro Wang (from Fahrenheit), Mike He, and Hebe Tian (from S.H.E) as the 3 main characters.
Don't say I'm biased to those actors, coz I'm not.
I'm basing my judgement on their acting abilities and how much I believe they would be able to make it similar to the original works. (if I wasn't being fair, I would've suggested using Arron Yan (from Fahrenehit) - I'm a major fan ^_^)
Anyways.
That's just my perception on this topic.
What are your thoughts?
Posted 5/30/09

zozogoescyco wrote:

I know it's long, but please read it!!
Ok.
You guys should have heard by now that the brilliant Skip Beat! is gonna be made into dramas.
What are your thoughts on that?
I'm not Jap, so I can't really comment on the Japanese version, but apparently there's gonna be a taiwanese version as well...
It would be starring Jerry Yan and Ariel Lin...
Unfortunately, I think that would ruin the whole perception the audience has on Skip Beat!
Before the fans of those two actors decide to hunt me down, let me explain.
Ren and Kyoko's personalities totally do not match the profiles of Jerry and Ariel.
As the two main characters, the personality traits are extremely important.
Based on their previous roles from their dramas, I don't think they can play anything but the roles with those certain traits.
In the real world, there's no such thing as the perfect acting from Skip Beat! (there probably are, but that's like one in a million).
Anyway, my point is that it'd be wiser for the director to choose actors closer to the external personality traits of the characters.
That way, it would greatly increase the number of Skip Beat! fans.
If people decide to watch the drama first, that is basically what they will think of the original work (believe me, I use to be one of those people).
If you ask me, if they HAVE TO make a drama out of the original works, they'd probably be better off using someone like Jiro Wang (from Fahrenheit), Mike He, and Hebe Tian (from S.H.E) as the 3 main characters.
Don't say I'm biased to those actors, coz I'm not.
I'm basing my judgement on their acting abilities and how much I believe they would be able to make it similar to the original works. (if I wasn't being fair, I would've suggested using Arron Yan (from Fahrenehit) - I'm a major fan ^_^)
Anyways.
That's just my perception on this topic.
What are your thoughts?


Well, That make sense... Me totally agree !
13136 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Europe
Offline
Posted 5/30/09 , edited 5/30/09
No.

the anime was already a feeble one, if there's a drama coming from this anime, the world will surely end.

Also, Yes No threads are forbidden, Wrong section and Duplicate.

To sum it up, what you've written is worthless shit.
Posted 5/30/09

Baka-God wrote:

No.

the anime was already a feeble one, if there's a drama coming from this anime, the world will surely end.

Also, Yes No threads are forbidden, Wrong section and Duplicate.

To sum it up, what you've written is worthless shit.


AS EXPECTED FROM SOME ONE HAVE YOUR NAME AND YOUR AVII !!

13136 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Europe
Offline
Posted 5/30/09 , edited 5/30/09

Rima888 wrote:


Baka-God wrote:

No.

the anime was already a feeble one, if there's a drama coming from this anime, the world will surely end.

Also, Yes No threads are forbidden, Wrong section and Duplicate.

To sum it up, what you've written is worthless shit.


AS EXPECTED FROM SOME ONE HAVE YOUR NAME AND YOUR AVII !!



Lay off the caps.

Why does my name and my avi have business with my opinion. You have no right to base my view on this topic, on my Account name and Avatar.
11894 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
76 / M / Windy City
Offline
Posted 5/30/09
if the anime go on ..... then NO

if the anime not going to continue then YES .... coz i want to know how the problem gonna be solve =D
79837 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
104 / M / close to u closer...
Offline
Posted 5/30/09
hmmmm let see i dont really care because i dont like skip beat
Posted 5/30/09
You must be logged in to post.