Created by qwertyuiopz
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next  Last
Post Reply Who's fault is it?
7607 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / anywhere
Offline
Posted 12/23/09

kero_and_suppi wrote:

all of their faults!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I mean if sekai didn't interfere and ito wasn't a pervert and if kotonoha for being easily jealous


agree

Member
18173 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / right behind you
Offline
Posted 1/14/10
i'd say they're all equally retarded... makoto didnt have any willpower, sekai played around with people's feelings, katsura... well dunno, but it feels like she did something wrong aswell, however! it seems like she was acting in quite an ordinary way, given the circumstances and stuff. well ofc, after you get your heart broken in such an amazingly cruel way, ur supposed to be depressed, and with the whole thing going in circles and stuff, i mean cmon, even WE got depressed.

anyway, sekai's fault, mostly, since she started the whole thing, she was the first one to do something rather bad. She was supposed to help her friend get along with makoto, but instead she started helping makoto in getting along with katsura, while actually she wanted to get makoto for herself.
no, seriously, nobody. nobody at all in the whole anime did anything as complex and fucked up as that)
she, at the very same time, was betraying satsuna, katsura, and actually herself D= and all tht in a weird way

makoto was just unable to tell a girl he doesn't like her anymore. thats bad ofc, but its kind of natural to be afraid of breaking up, now isnt it
katsura, again, didn't do anything out of order, really. she just didnt have anyone to talk to, her classmates hated her, etc etc etc, dunno =\
setsuna actually did everything in the nicest manner, i mean yeah, they did show some stuff about flower that blah blah blah but still, she was the one who ORIGINALLY wanted to date makoto, before it all got screwed up by sekai

ofc the first one chronologically would be that girl from his grade school (dont remember the name and GOD NO IM NOT GOING TO CHECK. EVER! =P), and it did go in the most natural way with her, but lol lol lol it was all pretty much fcuked up already)

ok now, after writing all this i feel a bit less depressed, phew)
Member
25 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M
Offline
Posted 1/15/10
First of all, nobody deserved what they got @ the end.

For Makotos defense: He is just a guy who lives for the Moment, is hardly naiv and seems to has no experience with girls.

Against him stands that he never said a word when he should have done. He never made thinks clear.
He also needs to grow a pair.

Sekai: i dont know, she is just a girl. Girls do those thinks, but she never should have stabbed Makoto.
I mean she was a Mother alrdy , she needs to take some responsibility.

Kotonoha should just had broken up with him the first time.
24 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / The Netherlands
Offline
Posted 1/18/10
Think about that first time Makoto got invited to Kotonohas place.
Then Sekai told Kotonoha not to spoil Makoto like that, at that time it looked like a pun but that was where i saw the first mistake being made.
Sekai allowed this '' probably since she liked Makoto so didnt want to make him angry '

You see it later to when he says like '' i used to be nervous only sitting on an bench'' but now he is spoiled and it is like childs play like him'

So all three are at fault here altough the mistake was made on an rather innocent subject but this non the less triggered the events of Makoto not knowing anymore when or how to stop.

It is everyones mistake but no-one is at fault.
58352 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / M / UK
Offline
Posted 1/22/10 , edited 1/22/10
I personally think that Sekai Mokoto and Kotoha are at fault not once through the series did any of them really speak their mind or get help. basically i think the point of this series is miscommunication and how if taken to the extreme can lead to some pretty horrific consequences.
Member
130 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / On Earth
Offline
Posted 1/28/10 , edited 1/28/10
I think it's everybody's faults.

M4K070(MAKOTO)- now what is this??? A sex addicted machine??? he has sex with almost all the girls in this high school. now this guy is like totally crazy! well, *ahem* there was a reason for that I think, *ahem* *stares at SEKAI*

53K41(SEKAI)- the axis of doom. she has started all this discord and chaos (dissidia much?), because she knew that Setsuna and Kotonoha likes (LOVES) Makoto, but since she loves Makoto too (now who the f*** would like a sex addict who doesn't really look charming or nice), she does some stuff. (now why would she kill someone)

K070Z0H4 (KOTONOHA)- a pitiful girl who could not stand up for herself. she is weak, so she became the victim. now that's sad. but not sad enough to kill another girl *ahem ahem* (ok now why would SHE, a very "internal" and shy girl would kill somone, open their stomach, and see if there is a baby which she cannot see clearly, because it's dark and the egg is small!?!)

7H3 07H3R G1RL5 (THE OTHER GIRLS)- wind and wood for fire, and fuel and tire for cars. they provide the reasons and incidents for chaos (example: Kotonoha's Insanity), and they blow everything up.

Conclusion: Sekai and Makoto's fault (Kotonoha wouldn't have fell into this love triangle if it wasn't for sekai and makoto)

Conclusion for Anime: Best Ending of all Anime existing. (about 99999% Sarcasm)
12 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M
Offline
Posted 1/28/10 , edited 1/28/10
i hate kotohana when she got sex with other guy that not really related to him T_T...
1735 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / sweden
Offline
Posted 2/5/10 , edited 2/5/10
All of em was involved but it was mostly Makotos fault, if he just had choosen 1 girl and explained hes feelings to her in the beguinning nothing more could possible have happened, like if he was seriously dating Kotonoha and Sekai got jealous he could simpely just tell her -Now this is how it is, im in love with Kotonoha--end of discussion... or as in the serie hes getting tired of Kotonoha and turning to Sekai then why not just tell Kotonoha about hes feelings and how she wasnt a good match for him, but no he is just a weak pereverted idiot so it just growing more and more problems from a little love triangle form start so in my opinion its MOSTLY Makato to blame....
Member
4578 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
116 / Christmas Island
Offline
Posted 3/9/10
i lol at this topic

/troll success
950 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M
Offline
Posted 7/15/10
It's easier to say, the only one NOT at fault is that blue haired athletic girl. She did nothing wrong, and actually had undeserved embarressment about her and her boyfriend, or rather, going down on him. She didn't deserve it.

Everyone else was damn responsible.

Though I do think, Makoto became an asshole, yes, insensitive, manipulative, immoral, liar, impersonal, cold.
Yet, honestly that's how the girls treated him one way or another.
Sekai manipulated, and was immoral, even insensitive.
Otome engaged in impersonal sex, as did other like the 4some squad and present-bow-head girl.
Setsuna manipulated him extensively, and lied repeatedly instead of letting him get stuck in a corner so that he'd have to break up with Kotonoha. She even encouraged it, she also had an affair with him even though her best friend was with him.

Hell, before he met the girls, in episode 1, I thought he was a pretty cool guy, just shy. If he were real I'd have hung with the man. At least, until episode 6... He was dead inside by that point.
950 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M
Offline
Posted 7/15/10
By the way, just to clear up anything, it's not like he had a right to act like that just because it was done to him.
He was just a very weak man. And that, if anything, is unforgiveable.
Member
1241 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / Bay Area
Offline
Posted 8/11/10 , edited 8/11/10
Mmm.... I voted Mokoto.. buht I think its sekai ANDDD mokotos faultt !

wait wait .. wait NO!

All of their faultss . yes.. Mokoto is tooo horny...and unfaithful and MEAN..

while sekai is manipulative and cant control her emotions / feelings -__-''

and Kokohatsu wats her namee LOL shes too.. forgiving? Until the last end she finally explodedd akaa killed her friendd.

Buht shes stupid because she still liked Mokoto.. (hugging his head on the boat) LOL !
52030 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M
Online
Posted 8/13/10 , edited 8/13/10

lildevilxxangel wrote:
Buht shes stupid because she still liked Mokoto.. (hugging his head on the boat) LOL !
The ending is what makes Kotonoha my favorite. That's the kind of psycho nonsense that gets you put down into legend; I like to think that Kotonoha's story is only beginning. I can imagine her sitting at some vender's cart, setting Makoto's head next to her, as they begin a lovely adventure.

That said, everyone was a frustratingly terrible person up to the end. Kotonoha's only props are for the extent to which she leaves the realm of the sane. There's an almost supernatural degree of "broken" that she achieved.
Member
1241 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / F / Bay Area
Offline
Posted 8/14/10

ascottbay wrote:


lildevilxxangel wrote:
Buht shes stupid because she still liked Mokoto.. (hugging his head on the boat) LOL !
The ending is what makes Kotonoha my favorite. That's the kind of psycho nonsense that gets you put down into legend; I like to think that Kotonoha's story is only beginning. I can imagine her sitting at some vender's cart, setting Makoto's head next to her, as they begin a lovely adventure.

That said, everyone was a frustratingly terrible person up to the end. Kotonoha's only props are for the extent to which she leaves the realm of the sane. There's an almost supernatural degree of "broken" that she achieved.


I see x] Nicee explaination
306 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F
Offline
Posted 8/15/10
Mostly to me is always between Makoto and Sekai but I'll say is both of their fault! If Makoto haven't act so pervert and Sekai wouldn't act so crazy of her pregnancy. Makoto would have fallen for Katsura first and leave Sekai all alone I mean who cares about her anyway I don't! So it between them and that all their fault Katsura never done anything and Makoto would have care for her more than Sekai
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.