I did a female version of this thread, now it's time for the males! Lets start:
Ick-kuto (Shugo Chara)
Le-douch (Code Geass)
Porchas D. Ace (One Piece)
Harima (School Rumble)
Seiji (Midori Days)
Everyone from Vampire knight and Shugo Chara.
Every male in Naruto.
L. Yeah, I said it.
Wanyuudou from Jigoku Shoujo.
The guy with the afro (Aizawa or something like that) from Death Note.
*deep breath* oookay, here we go
-Zero and Kaname from Vampire Knight
-Ichigo and Byakuya from Bleach
-L from Death Note
-Lelouch from Code Geass
-Edward Elric and Roy Mustang from FMA
-Tamaki and Hitachin twins from Ouran
-Fai from Tsubasa
-Ryuji from Toradora
-Spike from Cowboy Bebop
-Ikuto from Shugo Chara
-Vegeta from DBZ
-Tamahome from FY
-Vash from Trigun
-Duo Maxwell from GW
-Allen Walker from DGrayman
-Ginko from Mushishi
-Dr. Tenma from Monster
-Shinji from NGE
-Kyoya from Ouran
-Tieria Erde from Gundam 00
-Jet from Cowboy Bebop
-Koyuki from Beck
To be honest, I really think there's no need for you OP to create a thread for this when you can actually post here:
Overrated/Popular Anime Characters That You Can't Stand
No need to create one thread for males and another for females. However, that just speaks of Overrated Anime characters.
As for the underrated ones, I only found this one:
Based on the thread title itself, it's not asking for characters. But I guess that thread will suffice, instead of making threads that are quite close to being duplicates. I'll just edit the opening post for the Underrated Anime link, so you guys can talk about how underrated a certain character from a certain anime is.