First  Prev  1  2  3  4  Next  Last
Do You Think Itachi Was Right To Betray His Clan.
Member
231 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / M
Offline
Posted 5/31/10
The Uchiha's were too pissed to be captured and with the sharingan it would have been hard for members of the village to kill them all so only somoene like itachi or kakkashi could have taken care of this. Tho u gotta admit if they did convince them all to change and stay in the village Konoha would be way too powerful since they are already badass with 3 legendary sanin or w.e and all the sharingan users, byakugan i mean come on give the other countries a break. Itachi ftw but i do agree itachi should have wasted Sasuke in their last fight take his useless eyes and put them to good use to pwn madara which i think is planning on takin's sasuke once he is done making them powerful enough
Posted 6/9/10
nope he can just put a jutsu that will transport them all somewhere else
Member
73268 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
33 / M / Atlanta, GA
Offline
Posted 6/17/10
I think he made a horrible choice. It's like slaves working to protect their master or jews working to protect Hitler.

The people of Konoha were discriminating against the Uchiha for no valid reason. That's why the Uchiha were plotting and planning. They were just fighting for their civil rights which had been trampled on for generations.

Itachi genocided the victims so that the discriminators and racists wouldn't be hurt. Nothing about that is good. He did the wrong things for the wrong reasons.
Member
4162 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
20 / F / Earth Currently
Offline
Posted 6/17/10

xBlueCrayon wrote:

He made a horrible mistake.
An extraordinary clan was wiped out as the cost of fail ninjas from Konoha.


i agree he killed his girlfriend!! it would suck if my boyfriend killed me!!!!
Member
63184 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Richmond, VA
Offline
Posted 6/17/10

sickVisionz wrote:

I think he made a horrible choice. It's like slaves working to protect their master or jews working to protect Hitler.

The people of Konoha were discriminating against the Uchiha for no valid reason. That's why the Uchiha were plotting and planning. They were just fighting for their civil rights which had been trampled on for generations.

Itachi genocided the victims so that the discriminators and racists wouldn't be hurt. Nothing about that is good. He did the wrong things for the wrong reasons.


The reason Konoha discriminated against the Uchiha was because of the attack of the kyuubi 16 years before the main storyline, Konoha knew the fox was being controlled and they knew the Sharingan could do that, little did they know that Madara was still alive and he was the one controlling the fox, I think that Madara did that knowing the rest of the Uchiha clan would be blamed, and then managed to get his revenge on them when he and Itachi wiped them out.

And the main reason Itachi was involved because he knew the village was going to try and attack Uchiha and he knew that would only lead to more bloodshed.
Posted 6/18/10
for me no....!
"family first"

besides if were itachi im gonna killed those konoha people and the senju clan
the power of uchiha is amazing itachi can kill them all
Member
3038 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
19 / QC, PH
Offline
Posted 6/18/10

Vman410 wrote:


sickVisionz wrote:

I think he made a horrible choice. It's like slaves working to protect their master or jews working to protect Hitler.

The people of Konoha were discriminating against the Uchiha for no valid reason. That's why the Uchiha were plotting and planning. They were just fighting for their civil rights which had been trampled on for generations.

Itachi genocided the victims so that the discriminators and racists wouldn't be hurt. Nothing about that is good. He did the wrong things for the wrong reasons.


The reason Konoha discriminated against the Uchiha was because of the attack of the kyuubi 16 years before the main storyline, Konoha knew the fox was being controlled and they knew the Sharingan could do that, little did they know that Madara was still alive and he was the one controlling the fox, I think that Madara did that knowing the rest of the Uchiha clan would be blamed, and then managed to get his revenge on them when he and Itachi wiped them out.

And the main reason Itachi was involved because he knew the village was going to try and attack Uchiha and he knew that would only lead to more bloodshed.


I agree with this guy. Remember, Itachi had a pacifistic nature. If he had set the Uchiha free, then more bloodshed would have been wasted. So Itachi decided to kill of his clan, no matter how hard it is for him.
Member
65393 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
35 / M / Usually somewhere...
Offline
Posted 6/19/10
There is no correct answer on this one. He did what he thought would protect the most people and since his parents were in on it. They had to go as well.

But it it was me, I would not have done it. Life is to short to kill everyone and you really dont know what would have happened if he did not do it. For all we know the village could have been in better hands. There are always two side to everything.
Member
35771 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
20 / F / Destiny Island
Offline
Posted 6/21/10
yes he did
Member
73268 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
33 / M / Atlanta, GA
Offline
Posted 6/21/10
Yeah, he killed his own people to avoid the bloodshed of those who discriminated against his own people. Itachi was a troubled young man with intense issues of self-hatred that led him to commit genocide against his own race in order to protect those committing wrongs against them.

That was great for Konoha and saved them the head ache of having to stop discriminating against people but I don't consider it to be a good thing.
Member
18062 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Leaf Village
Offline
Posted 4/11/11
I Dont Get How He Could Wipe Out A Whole Entire Clan ,, Its Not Possible , The Uchiha Clan , Was Probably The Strongest Clan ,
968 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / M
Offline
Posted 4/11/11

ShadowSasukeHollow wrote:

I Dont Get How He Could Wipe Out A Whole Entire Clan ,, Its Not Possible , The Uchiha Clan , Was Probably The Strongest Clan ,


Itachi was a beast.
There were few who unlocked the Sharingan. There were less who unlocked the Mangekyo Sharingan.
Besides, who would expect one of their own to slaughter them within a blink of an eye.
Member
18062 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Leaf Village
Offline
Posted 4/11/11 , edited 4/11/11
But Sasuke Beat Itachi Without Mangekyo Sharingan , And I Don't Think That You Can Take A Whole Clan On Even If Madara Was To Help Him Out , He Would Eventually Run Out Of Chakra , And Using He's Mangekyo Sharingan Inflicts Some Pain .
Member
18062 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Leaf Village
Offline
Posted 4/11/11
But Sasuke Beat Itachi Without Mangekyo Sharingan , And I Don't Think That You Can Take A Whole Clan On Even If Madara Was To Help Him Out , He Would Eventually Run Out Of Chakra , And Using He's Mangekyo Sharingan Inflicts Some Pain .
968 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / M
Offline
Posted 4/11/11

ShadowSasukeHollow wrote:

But Sasuke Beat Itachi Without Mangekyo Sharingan , And I Don't Think That You Can Take A Whole Clan On Even If Madara Was To Help Him Out , He Would Eventually Run Out Of Chakra , And Using He's Mangekyo Sharingan Inflicts Some Pain .


Itachi allowed him to win. Don't forget that he was fighting while ill. Zetsu even pointed out that Itachi was taking hits that he should've been able to dodge.
I doubt he used the Mangekyo to eliminate the clan.
He was a prodigy.
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.