First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
Post Reply Why is Shinn so hated by almost everyone?
Creator
3037 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / Canada
Offline
Posted 1/6/08
Well... If you have an idea, share it here!
Member
15387 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / why bother?
Offline
Posted 1/12/08
hard headed, no patience, uhmmmm....... I think thats it.... things they don't like in shinn
Member
15387 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / why bother?
Offline
Posted 1/12/08
ah.... stubborn also
Member
50750 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / mushroom kingdom...
Offline
Posted 1/15/08
he is a bad ass! :ph34r:

And good looking, and everybody who's ugly hates good looking people
Moderator
9631 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / 地球
Offline
Posted 1/24/08
Alright....I think this question is best answered by a Shinn-hater, It's mostly because he's one of the most loathesome types of people: Someone who blames their own problems on people who have nothing to do with it.
Moderator
257 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
41 / M / Earth
Offline
Posted 1/26/08
Maybe they are spoil to there own Kira theory.
Member
146 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / Somewhere in the...
Offline
Posted 1/26/08
1st of all,why does so many ppls like kira?hes kind,caring,hate violence(its dumb to think that way since he probably kill more than Shinn did)cool(Shinn is coolest!!)"undefeatable" in gundams,doesnt die(primary reason why he is "undefeatable")and gets new gundams when his old gundams got blowned.Shinn is kind,not very caring,VERY violence(cant blame him,they are in war,it means kill or be killed)Shinn isnt really undefeatable(watch last ep of GSD),Shinn didnt even get his cockpit slashed or shot by anyone(which means no one is even close to killing him)Shinn get Destiny by working for it,by defeating the freedom(btw his impulse is not even blowned up when he gets destiny)and kira?he gets his freedom by flirting with Lacus Clyne the "princess" of ZAFT during GS,i bet if Shinns the one who flirt with Lacus,he will have Impulse Destiny(sry cant think of a better name =P) now since Shinn is coolest.I must say that i DONT hate kira cuz he doesnt kill my whole family or sumthing,but i must speak up for shinn cuz of some idiots.
Moderator
32378 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Try guessing...
Offline
Posted 1/30/08

pro_or_noob wrote:

1st of all,why does so many ppls like kira?hes kind,caring,hate violence(its dumb to think that way since he probably kill more than Shinn did)cool(Shinn is coolest!!)"undefeatable" in gundams,doesnt die(primary reason why he is "undefeatable")and gets new gundams when his old gundams got blowned.Shinn is kind,not very caring,VERY violence(cant blame him,they are in war,it means kill or be killed)Shinn isnt really undefeatable(watch last ep of GSD),Shinn didnt even get his cockpit slashed or shot by anyone(which means no one is even close to killing him)Shinn get Destiny by working for it,by defeating the freedom(btw his impulse is not even blowned up when he gets destiny)and kira?he gets his freedom by flirting with Lacus Clyne the "princess" of ZAFT during GS,i bet if Shinns the one who flirt with Lacus,he will have Impulse Destiny(sry cant think of a better name =P) now since Shinn is coolest.I must say that i DONT hate kira cuz he doesnt kill my whole family or sumthing,but i must speak up for shinn cuz of some idiots.


Well, I do feel sorry for Shinn since he did lose his family, no matter how I look at, and he is skilled pilot, even though a lot of ppl can't admit it (especially hardcore U.C. fans), but some of the main reasons of Shinn that kind've ticked me off, (not saying I hate him cuz I still think he's cool in his own way) is that he's easily manipulated...he always eats up the words of Rey and Chairman Durandal and never really finds what he really wants in life...He never really has his own opinions even though he thinks he does(until the end of the Special Edition) Also, he never really takes responsibility for his actions...he becomes insubordinate easily since he knows he gets special treatment from Durandal, which pisses off a lot of ppl, and he is the kinda guy who gets his own teammates killed....but still, even w/ these faults, I can't really hate him...he pisses me off a lot of times but can't hate him...cuz he thought he was doing the right thing...and about how Kira and Shinn get their new machines, u took it way out of context...Shinn was given the Destiny was not that he worked hard (even though he did) but in order to fulfill Durandal's wishes instead of his own...and Kira didn't get the Freedom just cuz he flirted w/ Lacus...Lacus gave both Freedoms to him so that Kira can find and maintain his reason for fighting...So there's not really as much ppl who hate Shinn as u think...quite the contrary...they mostly like Shinn cuz of his good points....ppl who hate Shinn r mostly U.C. fans...(sorry to say this about U.C. fans, cuz I like a lot of U.C. seasons myself, but it's true)
Member
2982 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
36 / M / Earth
Offline
Posted 1/31/08
i dont know why they hated Shinn they should at least understand the way of his very aggressive and insane because the tragic of his parents and her younger sister blown up in front of his eyes staring horrify and shock.
I highly respect for Shinn.
Moderator
9631 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / 地球
Offline
Posted 1/31/08

CoudVanGiruet wrote:


pro_or_noob wrote:

1st of all,why does so many ppls like kira?hes kind,caring,hate violence(its dumb to think that way since he probably kill more than Shinn did)cool(Shinn is coolest!!)"undefeatable" in gundams,doesnt die(primary reason why he is "undefeatable")and gets new gundams when his old gundams got blowned.Shinn is kind,not very caring,VERY violence(cant blame him,they are in war,it means kill or be killed)Shinn isnt really undefeatable(watch last ep of GSD),Shinn didnt even get his cockpit slashed or shot by anyone(which means no one is even close to killing him)Shinn get Destiny by working for it,by defeating the freedom(btw his impulse is not even blowned up when he gets destiny)and kira?he gets his freedom by flirting with Lacus Clyne the "princess" of ZAFT during GS,i bet if Shinns the one who flirt with Lacus,he will have Impulse Destiny(sry cant think of a better name =P) now since Shinn is coolest.I must say that i DONT hate kira cuz he doesnt kill my whole family or sumthing,but i must speak up for shinn cuz of some idiots.


Well, I do feel sorry for Shinn since he did lose his family, no matter how I look at, and he is skilled pilot, even though a lot of ppl can't admit it (especially hardcore U.C. fans), but some of the main reasons of Shinn that kind've ticked me off, (not saying I hate him cuz I still think he's cool in his own way) is that he's easily manipulated...he always eats up the words of Rey and Chairman Durandal and never really finds what he really wants in life...He never really has his own opinions even though he thinks he does(until the end of the Special Edition) Also, he never really takes responsibility for his actions...he becomes insubordinate easily since he knows he gets special treatment from Durandal, which pisses off a lot of ppl, and he is the kinda guy who gets his own teammates killed....but still, even w/ these faults, I can't really hate him...he pisses me off a lot of times but can't hate him...cuz he thought he was doing the right thing...and about how Kira and Shinn get their new machines, u took it way out of context...Shinn was given the Destiny was not that he worked hard (even though he did) but in order to fulfill Durandal's wishes instead of his own...and Kira didn't get the Freedom just cuz he flirted w/ Lacus...Lacus gave both Freedoms to him so that Kira can find and maintain his reason for fighting...So there's not really as much ppl who hate Shinn as u think...quite the contrary...they mostly like Shinn cuz of his good points....ppl who hate Shinn r mostly U.C. fans...(sorry to say this about U.C. fans, cuz I like a lot of U.C. seasons myself, but it's true)


It isn't only U.C fans that don't like Shinn, I've seen ALOT of C.E. fans that don't like Shinn, and I've seen plenty of U.C. fans admit that he's a pretty good pilot. But, not the most awesome pilot ever to exist. You're starting to act like we U.C fans are completely U.C-biased, we're so knowledgeable about Gundam because we've actually watched things outside of the U.C, we just don't take SEED seriously because of how it got so crappy in Destiny and how over-saturated it was. >_>

So far....All I've seen are C.E-fans that try to force their opinions on the U.C fans who say that they like Amuro, or Char. You seem to be the only cool C.E-fan.


But, anyway Shinn is kinda hit and miss with me, sometimes he does the dumbest things, and other times he actually proves to me that he doesn't suck. But, what REALLY got me on bad terms with Shinn is how he was so blind thinking that Orb was at fault...That he actually ended up killing the same man that helped him cope with his family's deaths. Captain Todaka, that's what got me pissed off at Shinn at first.
Creator
3037 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / F / Canada
Offline
Posted 2/1/08
Ha ha ha...! You got a good point there Onii-san (mario_man)! XD
Moderator
32378 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Try guessing...
Offline
Posted 2/2/08

Dendetsu wrote:


CoudVanGiruet wrote:


pro_or_noob wrote:

1st of all,why does so many ppls like kira?hes kind,caring,hate violence(its dumb to think that way since he probably kill more than Shinn did)cool(Shinn is coolest!!)"undefeatable" in gundams,doesnt die(primary reason why he is "undefeatable")and gets new gundams when his old gundams got blowned.Shinn is kind,not very caring,VERY violence(cant blame him,they are in war,it means kill or be killed)Shinn isnt really undefeatable(watch last ep of GSD),Shinn didnt even get his cockpit slashed or shot by anyone(which means no one is even close to killing him)Shinn get Destiny by working for it,by defeating the freedom(btw his impulse is not even blowned up when he gets destiny)and kira?he gets his freedom by flirting with Lacus Clyne the "princess" of ZAFT during GS,i bet if Shinns the one who flirt with Lacus,he will have Impulse Destiny(sry cant think of a better name =P) now since Shinn is coolest.I must say that i DONT hate kira cuz he doesnt kill my whole family or sumthing,but i must speak up for shinn cuz of some idiots.


Well, I do feel sorry for Shinn since he did lose his family, no matter how I look at, and he is skilled pilot, even though a lot of ppl can't admit it (especially hardcore U.C. fans), but some of the main reasons of Shinn that kind've ticked me off, (not saying I hate him cuz I still think he's cool in his own way) is that he's easily manipulated...he always eats up the words of Rey and Chairman Durandal and never really finds what he really wants in life...He never really has his own opinions even though he thinks he does(until the end of the Special Edition) Also, he never really takes responsibility for his actions...he becomes insubordinate easily since he knows he gets special treatment from Durandal, which pisses off a lot of ppl, and he is the kinda guy who gets his own teammates killed....but still, even w/ these faults, I can't really hate him...he pisses me off a lot of times but can't hate him...cuz he thought he was doing the right thing...and about how Kira and Shinn get their new machines, u took it way out of context...Shinn was given the Destiny was not that he worked hard (even though he did) but in order to fulfill Durandal's wishes instead of his own...and Kira didn't get the Freedom just cuz he flirted w/ Lacus...Lacus gave both Freedoms to him so that Kira can find and maintain his reason for fighting...So there's not really as much ppl who hate Shinn as u think...quite the contrary...they mostly like Shinn cuz of his good points....ppl who hate Shinn r mostly U.C. fans...(sorry to say this about U.C. fans, cuz I like a lot of U.C. seasons myself, but it's true)


It isn't only U.C fans that don't like Shinn, I've seen ALOT of C.E. fans that don't like Shinn, and I've seen plenty of U.C. fans admit that he's a pretty good pilot. But, not the most awesome pilot ever to exist. You're starting to act like we U.C fans are completely U.C-biased, we're so knowledgeable about Gundam because we've actually watched things outside of the U.C, we just don't take SEED seriously because of how it got so crappy in Destiny and how over-saturated it was. >_>

So far....All I've seen are C.E-fans that try to force their opinions on the U.C fans who say that they like Amuro, or Char. You seem to be the only cool C.E-fan.


But, anyway Shinn is kinda hit and miss with me, sometimes he does the dumbest things, and other times he actually proves to me that he doesn't suck. But, what REALLY got me on bad terms with Shinn is how he was so blind thinking that Orb was at fault...That he actually ended up killing the same man that helped him cope with his family's deaths. Captain Todaka, that's what got me pissed off at Shinn at first.


Well, I wasn't trying to make it seem like all U.C. fans were like that....sorry if it seemed like it was though...Well, I can't really speak for all the C.E. fans, but as someone who likes all the Gundam series that I've seen, I just find most of the Seed characters more believable whether they're cool people or complete douches....cuz I'm not so much into the Mobile Suits (I just think they're cool plain and simple) I just enjoy seeing the different characters interacting with older ones....(this goes for every season I've seen)...and about some of the other Seed fans, well the ones in my Gundam Seed group that I created, they're more like me....not so much as the Mobile Suits but more in touch w/ characters....mainly the romance in the season...well in my opinion, I think that Seed and Seed Destiny have the best romance among all the other seasons I've seen....and it is one of the main reasons that C.E. remains my favorite since I'm quite a romantic guy myself...(don't mean to sound weird)
Member
146 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / Somewhere in the...
Offline
Posted 2/5/08
There is lots of U.C fans that dont like shinn and i mean lots.well,i seriously didnt see plenty of U.C fans saying shinn is a pretty good pilot,in fact,i can say its less than 10.(pardon me if im wrong but seriously i dont see many of them.)well,for C.E fans,its Duh.Kira is their "hero" in terms of skills or characters.Naturally they will prefer him and say Shinn "sucks".Well,normally for U.C fans,u guys do like amuro or char dont u guys?Oo.btws,It is orbs fault to hold on to their ideals.it is not only Shinn's family who got blowned in that kinda pointless war,there might be thousands or even millions of people died becuz of their ideals.If orb did sign that treaty or sumthing,non of these will happen.tho,killing Captain Todaka isnt the right thing to do(in fact it is one of his worst mistakes),since he did save him or sumthing.
Moderator
32378 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Try guessing...
Offline
Posted 2/5/08

pro_or_noob wrote:

There is lots of U.C fans that dont like shinn and i mean lots.well,i seriously didnt see plenty of U.C fans saying shinn is a pretty good pilot,in fact,i can say its less than 10.(pardon me if im wrong but seriously i dont see many of them.)well,for C.E fans,its Duh.Kira is their "hero" in terms of skills or characters.Naturally they will prefer him and say Shinn "sucks".Well,normally for U.C fans,u guys do like amuro or char dont u guys?Oo.btws,It is orbs fault to hold on to their ideals.it is not only Shinn's family who got blowned in that kinda pointless war,there might be thousands or even millions of people died becuz of their ideals.If orb did sign that treaty or sumthing,non of these will happen.tho,killing Captain Todaka isnt the right thing to do(in fact it is one of his worst mistakes),since he did save him or sumthing.


well, I wouldn't say that Shinn sucks....like I said earlier, he still has all of his good points
Moderator
706 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
22 / M / the Dark Side of...
Offline
Posted 2/11/08
I think people hate him because he almost killed Kira in episode 34... That was the highly hated episode of Gundam Seed Destiny in my country's GSD fan community. Well, my friends also hate it that he's arrogant and spoilt. (Just because I'm a 'Shinn' doesn't mean I show the bad side of me to my friends)
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.