Created by veron05
Motion to Remove Anifile from the C.R Library and halt subsequent updates.
60315 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29
Offline
Posted 3/4/11 , edited 3/5/11
Hello Crunchy Roll and Crunchy Roll users. I am making a Motion To have The Video series "Anifile" Removed from the Crunchy Roll Library, and halt subsequent updates.
I believe that The show Anifile has a very bias attitude to anime and cannot critically Look at a series. In Part each anime needs to be reviewed under its subsequent category. I also feel that Videos of such nature such as his, is harmful to the community of Crunchy roll. Therefor be it moved that His videos be removed from C.R.





PLEASE VOTE.
69382 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
34 / M / Going crazy.
Offline
Posted 3/4/11
Even though I really hate that guy and don't like his review very much. I still think its fine to leave the videos on here. Some people do like his reviews and some people hate them.

I do agree that it would be better if the videos were just posted under each "Review" section of the specific anime, so they can be viewed with other reviews for the same anime. But I think everyone has a rite to put in their own opinions.

When it comes down to it people shouldn't be watching just his reviews anyway. Anyone real anime fan who is looking for input on an anime isnt just going to look at one single review and make a full judgement based off of it. But once again that is just my opinion.
Posted 3/4/11
You do realize this won't get far right? shinji makes the choice to remove them or not. I doubt if he'll read this and even consider thinking of changing his feelings about it.
63713 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / M / United States
Offline
Posted 3/4/11
Shinji's views and decisions have many times been swayed by the people of the site. If they had not, this site wouldn't be where it is today.

Sadly, this is one of the worst videos on the list, was voted for minimal times and yet we still see it in our recently added anime section over much better and highly regarded videos. So this proves one thing, money will make CR show anything!

58861 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
34 / M / Yarmouth Port, Mass
Offline
Posted 3/4/11
It's F***ing stupid but that's no reason to remove it.
61641 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M
Offline
Posted 3/5/11
I like listening to someone's opinion of how they rate a certain anime. IT'S HIS OPINION. I get good laughs on how he exaggerates certain scenes and plots. If you don't like MasakoX or his show (Anifile), then don't watch it or click on any of the links. In other words, IGNORE THE SHOW. Yet you have to rant and make a poll saying that you hate most of his opinions, and want his show taken off. This poll most likely will not get through, like most of the others.
19110 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / United Kingdom
Offline
Posted 3/5/11
I'd be concerned if the service I'm paying for doesn't listen to it's customers , but anyway one of his more recent reviews (namely kore wa zombie desu ka) I wasn't impressed with, seeing as at the time of review episode 3 had only just come out (posted on his blog earlier).

He did come up with some good points such as the cross-dressing/crotch positioning (I agree with it being unnecessary, but I think it brings more of a comedic value) but his opinion kind of flatlines when you compare to his other review of Kamper (praised as a guilty pleasure, despite the main character literally transforming from a male to female magical girl). So for future episodes I think he needs to relate to past opinions and watch the entire series before reviewing.
60315 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29
Offline
Posted 3/5/11

DevonWheels wrote:

I like listening to someone's opinion of how they rate a certain anime. IT'S HIS OPINION. I get good laughs on how he exaggerates certain scenes and plots. If you don't like MasakoX or his show (Anifile), then don't watch it or click on any of the links. In other words, IGNORE THE SHOW. Yet you have to rant and make a poll saying that you hate most of his opinions, and want his show taken off. This poll most likely will not get through, like most of the others.


I agree completely, However i just believe that content of that nature should not be on Crunchy Roll. You are correct on how it is his opinion, however when C.R hosts content such as Anifile They are also agreeing to the opinions that is reflected in the hosted content. Theoretically If Anifile had a review on an anime that cause a more drastic issue/statement (I'm not going to elaborate cause its getting to the extremes here, an this is just a "what if") C.R could be held liable. Im not saying the Lawrence should stop hosting anifile, He has the right to his opinion, I Feel that C.R should just not host his content. And The reason i made a poll is to see how many other people agree/disagree with me. If im the only member of C.R that thinks this way well then hey im crazy and wrong. However I do believe I'm not alone on this subject.
Yes this can be considered a rant, And the likely hood C.R listening to only one member is unlikely. But I too have the right to express my opinions.
Posted 3/5/11
I don't think CR should remove a series from their website just because a few users are offended by the content.

If that were the case, I don't think many series would be left on crunchyroll.
60315 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29
Offline
Posted 3/6/11
Again its one of the reasons i made a poll. To see how many other people agree with me. If say a large majority of people Vote to Keep the show, Then by all means keep it. but hey if a lot of people want to remove it. Then I feel that C.R should Remove it.
60315 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29
Offline
Posted 3/8/11
Not bad 10 - 7 - 7. Now if we can just get about 200 more people to vote
18 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / Adrian, Texas
Offline
Posted 3/26/11
Personally, I agree that everyone has right to their opinion, but this guy is calling himself a reviewer and getting money because of it! On not only blip, but that guy with the glasses as well! Yet he is so biased, hypocritical and not open minded at all except to his own experiences with Animes (which from the countdown was mostly girl shows; slice of life they're fine but that's not saying much), that whenever I watch his reviews I just feel like he's being disrespectful to the hard work that these animators do. True, I don't have to watch him, but then again that means I don't have to watch any show that's told to me by any reviewer it doesn't make it right to just say "oh despite him not doing a good job, it's okay." It's like having some random guy off the street teach my class about biology or something, but has no idea what they're talking about or doesn't do their research when it comes to it. I guess I shouldn't let him teach me or complain about it, but it's okay if he's still teaching others as long as no one else complains. They get the easy A and he gets his check I guess. Sorry I want a little more out of my class aka anime review! True you shouldn't listen to one reviewer, but the fact that he mostly jokes about the show rather than actually tell us anything other than what you can read from wiki does not make a good reviewer.
13053 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
104 / M / Oklahoma
Offline
Posted 10/23/11
I like his reviews. sure he can be biased & his tastes are way different than mine but he always goes into great detail about the anime and why he liked/disliked it. I don't have to agree with him. besides, he's funny to watch. I just tied your vote BTW
You must be logged in to post.