First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
Fairy Tail and One Piece
1901 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F
Offline
Posted 3/22/11

1. What do you think of Fairy Tail and One Piece?

Fairy Tail has alot of great action and the music is great as well. You get a real feeling of a connection with the story and characters. I only watched a couple ep of one piece wasn't really my thing.

2. Which is better? Fairy Tail or One Piece?
Fairy tail the plot line is much more interesting

3. Which main character do you like best? (Though, they seem similar)
Natsu or Happy

4. Is the story line becoming more interesting for both of these animes?
Fairy tail just gets better the more you watch it!

5. Any manga recommendation that is similar to the story style (and the humor) of these two? (Don't include Bleach and Naruto)
Rave Master ? I read the first couple manga it was okay, but it is pretty similar.
3180 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / Cali
Offline
Posted 3/22/11
yes im sure youd like rave master. i read the magna as well
132490 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / M / Philippines
Offline
Posted 3/22/11
1-5 Q: Both of these series are epic to watch and i like the main heroes of the series
91 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
21 / F
Offline
Posted 3/23/11 , edited 3/23/11
1. What do you think of Fairy Tail and One Piece?
fairy tail is more fast paced whereas one piece is pretty dragged out. i think one piece has more *epic* scenes.
2. Which is better? Fairy Tail or One Piece?
Depends. do you like short or long arcs? in my opinion, one piece much better by far. Sure, the first 20 episodes are a bit childish and *lol*, but it really improves. no joke. most people never get pass these episodes, and that's why a lot of them avoid it. the arcs are never the same, and are always original. you never get bored. especially the latest episodes/chapters; one piece volume 61 didn't sell 2 million + copies in 3 days for nothing. :P
3. Which main character do you like best? (Though, they seem similar)
i prefer luffy (one piece) cause he's much funnier, in my opinion.
4. Is the story line becoming more interesting for both of these animes?
i would say both of them gets more interesting as the story line progresses...
5. Any manga recommendation that is similar to the story style (and the humor) of these two? (Don't include Bleach and Naruto)
not any i read/watched so far. but then again, i'm really picky when it comes to "similar".
65031 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26
Online
Posted 3/23/11
I gotta say I truly enjoy both. I read and watch each one weekly. Fairy Tail is really going strong manga wise, and of course One Piece is still king of story/execution. Both are definitely worth reading and watching. Just be sure to stay the heck away from the 4kids dubs.
1115 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / Slovakia
Offline
Posted 3/24/11
1. What do you think of Fairy Tail and One Piece?
Fairy Tail
2. Which is better? Fairy Tail or One Piece?
Fairy Tail
3. Which main character do you like best? (Though, they seem similar)
Natsu Dragneel
4. Is the story line becoming more interesting for both of these animes?
Yeah, no doubt.
5. Any manga recommendation that is similar to the story style (and the humor) of these two? (Don't include Bleach and Naruto)
I should advise you Hitman Reborn! its great anime and manga (anime has ended, though)
31344 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / M
Offline
Posted 3/25/11
1. What do you think of Fairy Tail and One Piece?

I like them both although i have not seen as much of Fairy Tail



2. Which is better? Fairy Tail or One Piece?

One Piece no contest. It destroys all pretenders to the Shonen throne with it's incredibly well written storylines and memorable characters. There is a reason it's so big in Japan and it creates billions of dollars in revenue.

3. Which main character do you like best? (Though, they seem similar)

Luffy. And ALL Shonen characters are similar lol

4. Is the story line becoming more interesting for both of these animes?

I think the storyline of One Piece has been interesting for years though right now some major plotlines are hitting their peak and it's getting really good. Fairy Tail seems like it gets more interestiing as it goes along.

5. Any manga recommendation that is similar to the story style (and the humor) of these two? (Don't include Bleach and Naruto)

Just look for a list of shonen manga and pick one lol. They're all fairly similar it's a genre that doesn't really change much even since the days of Hokuto no ken and Dragonball
1512 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M
Offline
Posted 3/25/11
This argument is invalid
1887 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F
Offline
Posted 3/25/11

1. What do you think of Fairy Tail and One Piece?
Fairy tail is okay But i say One piece Is way better
and yes i too was put off one piece by its drawing and plot but once i watched i became such a big fan


2. Which is better? Fairy Tail or One Piece?
One piece Is 10000000% better than fairy tail


3. Which main character do you like best? (Though, they seem similar)
Luffy but if i could pick another character id say Zoro


4. Is the story line becoming more interesting for both of these animes?
The plot for one piece Becoming more interesting by the arc


5. Any manga recommendation that is similar to the story style (and the humor) of these two? (Don't include Bleach and Naruto)
Katekyo hitman reborn and hunterXhunter oh and D.gray man
929 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M
Offline
Posted 3/25/11 , edited 3/25/11
1. One Piece = great story and extremely well written
Fairy tail is Cliche but has epic music and animation
One Piece is like work hard and reach for your dreams while having great adventures where as Fairy tail is like friendship obliterates all the bad guys.
2. One Piece
3. Luffy>Natsu imo, Luffy is funny but when hes serious hes freaking badass. I guess ppl can say that about Natsu but meh I always felt Natsu was a crappy clone of Luffy. I actually don't like Natsu, I duno bout the manga but in the anime, tht transportation weakness thing is very annoying. So is Grey stripping. I just hope I'm not the only one that finds that stuff to be not funny but annoying and stupid. Zoro from One Piece getting lost tho is classic.
4. Yeah both of them are getting more exciting
5. Not really but if you are looking for anime I recommend Saint Seiya the lost canvas.

In conclusion, for me Fairy tail is juss no where near One Piece. One Piece>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Fairy tail and always will be.
The only reason I watch Fairy Tail is because of the great music and animation. The art is great as well but way to similar to One Piece.
12455 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27
Offline
Posted 3/25/11
One piece.

Most successful manga in Japan EVER.It regularly breaks a few million copies in sales for each volume released.It's one of the highest rated anime in Japan every week it airs.

Hmm,doesn't that automatically make it better than fairy tail by default? Being popular doesn't mean it's better you say?I guess that's true.But it sure as hell means that there are tons of people who would vouch for it being the best thing since sliced bread.

Fairy tail.

No where near one piece in sales.No where near one piece in ratings.No where near one piece in popularity.I've even forced myself to watch a few of the episodes (for certain reasons I cannot explain in public).And I can tell you that its absolute garbage.

To be fair,I was a fan of the author's previous work,Rave.It was back in a time when I was still a kid who was still debating whether pro-wrestling was fake.I thankfully realized that it was indeed fake and that Rave was actually a sub-par anime and generic manga.In my heart,a part of me wished it wasn't garbage and if that's the case with fairy tail for you,fine.

One piece may be using the same shounen formula that never fails,but there is a certain strange charm in Oda's story telling and art that speaks to people of all ages.And as long as your inner child isn't dead and gone,you will enjoy the ride he has in store for you more often than not.
18704 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / Northwest
Offline
Posted 3/26/11
I haven't seen One Piece that much but I will soon. But I have been watching Fairy Tail and at first I thought the anime was a joke but I really got into it and like it alot lol.
52064 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 3/26/11 , edited 3/26/11

giannelli_07 wrote:

I'm not updated with Animes and Mangas anymore but I do try my best to keep up with both of these manga series. I use to read Naruto and Bleach but I'm way behind now. Anyway, here are a few things I wanted to ask:

1. What do you think of Fairy Tail and One Piece?
2. Which is better? Fairy Tail or One Piece?
3. Which main character do you like best? (Though, they seem similar)
4. Is the story line becoming more interesting for both of these animes?
5. Any manga recommendation that is similar to the story style (and the humor) of these two? (Don't include Bleach and Naruto)

P.S. Please recommend short manga series. It doesn't matter what genre. But I like the manga series "Absolute Boyfriend". Short but good. So, I would really appreciate some new ones to read.



Thanks



1. Fairy Tail - Epic! Funny characters, incredible story, awesome magic! One Piece - Beyond Epic! Well defined cast, Original, very well planned story, amazing battles. Both - Amazing powers, that don't go out of their limits, but do things you don't expect within them.
2. One Piece. I love both series, to the point that I await them every week, but One Piece is better.
3. Do I have to choose? I love all of them! Fine. I'll list my fave from each! OP - Luffy! FT - Happy! Aye! What better sidekick than a talking winged cat! Especially from Mashima-sensei, who created Rave Master (If you look closely, you notice cameo's from characters other than Plue! Griff appears in the first chapter!)
4. Amazingly so. Fairy Tail has entered a point where the story is becoming more clear. Before, it was awesome, and the arcs were incredible, but the plot itself didn't seem to be shown. I still don't know what the ultimate goal of Fairy Tail is. One Piece... Well, to say it ever declined is a lie. Every piece of the story adds onto the plot, and keeps making it better.
5. Rave Master is a must. Full Metal Alchemist, Soul Eater (Give Soul Eater time. It starts kind of... odd. Hard to start), Other Jump manga and anime. (There are many. Most all of them are incredible.) Other than that, I got nothing to suggest. A good short manga from Jump would be Waq Waq. Kind of a strange one, but it is good. Maybe Blue Dragon Ral Grad as well.
104 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
19 / F / Somewhere... On E...
Offline
Posted 3/28/11
I LOVE TIS TWO ANIME! XD oh oh! i found tis totally awesome manga story blog! it's damn hell nice. it's http://www.soly-la-luna.blogspot.com/ . u wont regret readin it! it's manga in terms of words! the description is superb!! an all time fav!
2322 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / California, Hawai...
Offline
Posted 3/28/11
Fairy Tail is so much better than one piece. The characters are funny and well put together with very emotional back stories. The arcs are very good in both story and theme songs. Plus, the fillers have a bunch of laughs. One Piece just get extremely annoying and I find no character extremely compeling except Zolo. Fairy Tail is way better than One Piece. Some good manga that are kind of short but still ongoing, hundred year love and Iris Zero. Recommend both.
First  Prev  1  2  3  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.