First  Prev  1  2  3  4  Next  Last
To be APPROVED or NOT to be APPROVED
20230 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / California
Offline
Posted 1/17/08

redgarnettk wrote:

Some mods refuse to approve these videos for the sake of quality of videos on CR. Some will. Technically we are supposed to allow some of the YouTube videos onto the site. Where is the line though? It's difficult to judge. In the end, it is entirely up to the mod who is approving at that time.

The rules have NOT been defined yet.


Please read this.

I was the mod who approved that video.

The rules of personal videos have not been defined yet because there have been other, more important issues the moderators have needed to discuss.

Does approving that video mean that all personal videos will be approved onto the site? No.

First off, that was a tribute-esq video. If you take a video of yourself on your cellphone and upload it onto CR, it will NOT be approved by ANY moderator.

It is entirely up to the video (the effort the person put into the video, the quality, the format, the uploader, and the content) and the moderator who is going through the Member section.
7692 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M
Offline
Posted 1/17/08

maybe ,well.... let we all just say let Crunchyroll had , like a personal videos in your PROFILE because your Profile is a personal file only your friend's can see it , but not all the people . if you want people to see it ,put it on YouTube .


So think about GUY 's if Crunchyroll had this
Posted 1/17/08
You shouldn't your not a show nor a music video and random videos are just for youtube so post it there not here!
28685 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / F / Michigan, USA
Offline
Posted 1/17/08
Personally I think "youtube-style" videos shouldn't be approved here on CR. It'll just turn the Member section into an even bigger jumble of videos, and hardly any of them have real entertainment value anyway (no offense to the makers). CrunchyRoll is for Asian media, not some kid in France lip-synching to Britney Spears -_-. That was just an example, not a real video I saw XD. That kind of stuff would just slow down the encoders and take up bandwidth =/.

Edit: Note I said "personally". Like Red is saying, there's no official rule. It's up the media mods discretion. Some are allowed, some aren't, but there's no official criteria or anything.
7718 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
76 / M / Florida, US
Offline
Posted 1/17/08

redgarnettk wrote:

Some mods refuse to approve these videos for the sake of quality of videos on CR. Some will. Technically we are supposed to allow some of the YouTube videos onto the site. Where is the line though? It's difficult to judge. In the end, it is entirely up to the mod who is approving at that time.

The rules have NOT been defined yet.


Just wondering, is this site owned by 1-2 people? So, they can technically even just shut down the site or allow whatever they felt like?(which I find great since it reminds CR users that it's something someone actually put effort into while we reap the benefits of it while we all argue amongst each other) I was just thinking about it since so many people argue about what or how CRs policies and decisions are. And as a mod, do you think that personal videos might be bad for the site since if everyone starts to submit random videos not pertaining to the Asian Media, it'll clutter up the site and lose it's CR identity? Not to mention causing a strain on the bandwidth. (As stated in my earlier post unless you guys allow members with vip donation status to post personal media under some guidelines.)
5003 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Philippines (Coun...
Offline
Posted 1/17/08



First off, that was a tribute-esq video. If you take a video of yourself on your cellphone and upload it onto CR, it will NOT be approved by ANY moderator.

It is entirely up to the video (the effort the person put into the video, the quality, the format, the uploader, and the content) and the moderator who is going through the Member section.


its been answered....
thank very much for this post i really appreciate it ^.^
Posted 1/17/08
What's the big deal?? When I first joined I went to member vids n this guy and his friends made a vid of them together. It was funny so they got a lot of good comments, but at the same time it was really a personal vid. So, just because this one wasn't funny, it's not acceptable? Please.
1644 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / M / Planet Novus: Any...
Offline
Posted 1/17/08
Well I think thats why we had a member section for the members to upload their own videos.. But I think it will gonna be a waste of bandwidth if they allow members personal vid..

How about this suggestion only the Star supporters can upload their own personal vid in the members section.. With that they can save some bandwidth..

Personal Vid in means of a video of themselves made just for fun..
Posted 1/17/08
no offense but it was really a shitty video. The music sucked and all the video was, was a slide show of your friends. Like everybody else said go upload this on youtube. Because frankly, I don't think anybody cares about your friends.
20230 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / California
Offline
Posted 1/17/08

tobydiah wrote:

Just wondering, is this site owned by 1-2 people? So, they can technically even just shut down the site or allow whatever they felt like?(which I find great since it reminds CR users that it's something someone actually put effort into while we reap the benefits of it while we all argue amongst each other) I was just thinking about it since so many people argue about what or how CRs policies and decisions are. And as a mod, do you think that personal videos might be bad for the site since if everyone starts to submit random videos not pertaining to the Asian Media, it'll clutter up the site and lose it's CR identity? Not to mention causing a strain on the bandwidth. (As stated in my earlier post unless you guys allow members with vip donation status to post personal media under some guidelines.)


Bandwidth is not a problem. There has been a bandwidth limit for a long time now and users who do not have a limit have donated to the site are allowed to watch more media because of shinji's thankfulness for donations. Besides, most member videos use up considerably less bandwidth than full on episodes of anime or drama.

As a mod, I personally would like to not see personal videos on a website dedicated to one thing: asian media. However, I understand that the site is broadening and must accept more as it grows. There are deeper reasons as to why the site allows some videos and some not that are not appropriate to discuss however. I believe the personal videos are not needed for the general population of CR but can hold more meaning for a smaller group of users. But as I said earlier, the site is growing less into an asian media site and more into a community with all of the functions shinji has added (such as the chat and more customizations a user can do with his/her profile) so special care must be taken to ensure that what is being put onto the site is what, at the time, the site should hold.
7801 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
34 / M / Pinsnotch2
Offline
Posted 1/17/08
i personally think crunchyroll should remove the member video section just because it is mostly amvs (super gay by the way obviously since it is a amv) and dmvs (even gayer since it is a girl obsessed with a foreign guy)

removing the member video section would solve many problems and wouldn't it increase bandwidth too?
5003 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Philippines (Coun...
Offline
Posted 1/17/08

wolzen wrote:

i personally think crunchyroll should remove the member video section just because it is mostly amvs (super gay by the way obviously since it is a amv) and dmvs (even gayer since it is a girl obsessed with a foreign guy)

removing the member video section would solve many problems and wouldn't it increase bandwidth too?


dont be so narrow minded .... our forum moderator is already explaining why there has been an approval for that vid .... please be broadminded dude.... ahehehe
1644 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
29 / M / Planet Novus: Any...
Offline
Posted 1/17/08
Hmm just wonderin what would the user feel about CR members when he/she reads about this thread.. I mean its not only her who uploaded this kind of video but we focuses our discussion on her video which is not fair.. I suggest closing this thread and let the moderators and shinji decide if they still approve personal videos like that..
7801 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
34 / M / Pinsnotch2
Offline
Posted 1/17/08

mydeathcurse wrote:


wolzen wrote:

i personally think crunchyroll should remove the member video section just because it is mostly amvs (super gay by the way obviously since it is a amv) and dmvs (even gayer since it is a girl obsessed with a foreign guy)

removing the member video section would solve many problems and wouldn't it increase bandwidth too?


dont be so narrow minded .... our forum moderator is already explaining why there has been an approval for that vid .... please be broadminded dude.... ahehehe


didn't even watch the vid i just hate amvs and dmvs in general all those should stay in youtube since youtube is crap now because of them

btw can't determine if you're a girl or guy

5003 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / Philippines (Coun...
Offline
Posted 1/17/08

wolzen wrote:


mydeathcurse wrote:


wolzen wrote:

i personally think crunchyroll should remove the member video section just because it is mostly amvs (super gay by the way obviously since it is a amv) and dmvs (even gayer since it is a girl obsessed with a foreign guy)

removing the member video section would solve many problems and wouldn't it increase bandwidth too?


dont be so narrow minded .... our forum moderator is already explaining why there has been an approval for that vid .... please be broadminded dude.... ahehehe


didn't even watch the vid i just hate amvs and dmvs in general all those should stay in youtube since youtube is crap now because of them

btw can't determine if you're a girl or guy



hahaha FYI .. em a GUY its just happen that i became a big fan of DBSK ... DBSK Hwaiting~!!! LoL
no once is forcing to watch every vid uploaded here in CR ryt ???
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.