Inconsistency with Madara getting the Rinngegan towards the end of his life:
Member
67347 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / Glendale, AZ
Offline
Posted 4/24/12
Going with the assumption that Konohagakure was founded by Madara and Hashirama 65+ years ago, there are some inconsistencies with Edo Madara getting the Rinngegan towards the end of his life:

-If we go by the idea that Edo Madara is a clone of the real Madara and Tobi isn't Madara, "that end of his life" would likely be the idea that Madara was assumed to be dead after losing the fight with Hashirama.
-Going with the above, how could Edo Madara know about Nagato?

If we were to suggest Nagato was 30-35 when he died, there's another inconsistency. Sarutobi was only a teen when he became Hokage (http://www.narutoforums.com/archive/index.php/t-108055.html). The Sannin weren't born yet going with the mentions of the databook in the aforementioned link. Thus, Nagato not yet born.


4645 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / M / New York
Offline
Posted 4/24/12
it was proven that Madara did not die durning that fight, with statements from the manga but sometime later then the fight, you do not keep track of the information really well, also Databooks are sometimes and are often proven wrong later on in the manga, if that happens then the Databook's information is not correct even if Kishimoto wrote the Databook, he can always change something later on that makes the previous information recorded in the databook wrong.

Madara appears to be in his 40's based on his edo-tensai appearance, Hashirama's bloodline has the ability to lengthen ones life and has some curitive powers so you age slower then ussual, this would make Madara around 50-60 years old around the time of his death, Madara aquired Hashirama's DNA durning their fight and based on edo-Madara, Madara died sometime after aquiring the Rinnegan, odds are Madara's knowledge of Nagato would be when Nagato was an infant, and he made plans to use Nagato upon finding him, Tobi if my guess is correct is like an apperentice to Madara and being such was entrusted with Nagato and Madara's Rinnegan eyes which comes to the point that Tobi gave Nagato the Rinnegan, this most likely was planned by Madara, what wasn't planned was Nagato giving his life and siding with Naruto in the end, because of this Tobi had to take it upon himself to continue Madara's original plan that involved Nagato, hence why he needed the Rinnegan.

the only inconsistancy I've truely seen are how the Byukagan relates to the Sharingan base on Kakashi's statement durning the Chunnin exams and how Kakashi aquired the Mangekyou Sharingan. other then that the Manga shows information about all the other so called inconsistancies, but you are required to actually look for it with a more antilitical eye.
Member
67347 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / Glendale, AZ
Offline
Posted 4/25/12
Another theory it's also possible that Nagato naturally acquired the Rinnegan and the DNA of Hashirama with his own DNA caused that cause

My take on Tobi's identity: Could be Madara used a technique similar to the Living Corpse Reincarnation that Orochimaru used
4645 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / M / New York
Offline
Posted 4/25/12
how does Hashirama's DNA help Nagato awaken the Rinnegan? what Nagato really needs is the Uchiha DNA, since the Senju and Uzumaki are related he already possess the DNA of the Senju indirectly.

Tobi can't be that, Edo Tensai requires the soul to be in the afterlife, which Madara was raised by Edo Tensai, if Tobi truely did possess Madara's soul he wouldn't have been raised by Edo Tensai, the two of them are two seperate people, who Tobi is I don't know, but he can't be Madara....
Member
67347 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / Glendale, AZ
Offline
Posted 4/25/12
I said similar to the jutsu Orochimaru did. If Kishi had intended for Tobi to be just acting as Madara, then Tobi's mentioning he was Madara (http://www.narutoshippuudenfan.com/naruto-manga-chapter/the-man-who-knows-the-truth-naruto-manga-397/ for reference), then he intentionally was trolling/actually "false advertising" for over 3 years.
4645 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
32 / M / New York
Offline
Posted 4/26/12
we'll just have to wait and see how it goes.
Sailor Candy Moderator
Member
200577 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28
Offline
Posted 5/22/13
Spring forum cleaning! To keep the forums neat and tidy we only keep 6 months worth of threads since its May 22, 2013 [5/22/13] we will keep only keep posts open from December 22, 2012 [12/22/12]. Please feel free to recreate any thread closed, as long as someone else didn't open another similar one before you.
You must be logged in to post.