heres mine im hoping this will help people find an anime that anyone can enjoy
5 Uraboku
4 Gurren lagan
5 Kuroshitsuji (black butler)
5 D.gray-man
3 Soul eater
3 Blood +
3 Shugo chara
4 No.6
1 d.n.angel
5 naruto
5 fullmetal alchemist
5 ao no exorcist
2 inuyasha
1 clanned
5 one piece
5 fairy tail
5 black cat
5 darker than black
2 shakugan no shana
4 durarara
5 death note
5 bleach
5 code geass
3 vampire knights
5 ouran high school host club
4 samurai champloo





extra anime (-I hear all these animes are good-)
shaman king
tsubasa chronicles
fruit basket
special A
nabari no ou
lucky star
fate stay night
black blood brother
trinity blood
katekyo hitman reborn
kaichou wa maid-sama
loveless
jigoku shoujo
toradora
angel beats
zatch bell
myself yourself
air
zombie loan
midori days
Pandora hearts
Rozen maiden
Elemental gelade
Kiba
07 ghost
Chrome shelled regions
True tears
Murder princess
The world god only knows
Yumekui merry
Natsume yuujinchou
Neo Angelique abyss
Psychic detective
Earl fairy
When seagulls cry
Valkyria chronicles
Requiem for the phantom
Pita ten
Heroic age
Tegami bachi
Canvas 2 nijiiro no sketch
Munto
Shiki
Kobato
Hidan no aria
Ika musume
Tales of the abyss
Witch hunter
Tactics
Kyo kara maoh
Jing king of bandits
aru majutsu no index
inu x boku ss

all ive seen. Mostly 5

Think I will just copy your list

4 Gurren lagan
3 Kuroshitsuji (black butler)
3 Blood +
1 Shugo chara
5 naruto
3 fullmetal alchemist - the 1st series
4 ao no exorcist
2 inuyasha
5 clannad + After Story
5 one piece
2 fairy tail
5 darker than black - 1st season
4 durarara
3 death note
3 bleach
5 code geass
1 vampire knight
3 ouran high school host club
4 samurai champloo
5 Natsume yuujinchou
4 Lucky Star
4.5 Angel Beats - I can't give it a 4 and I can't get it a 5 >.<
4 Toradora
3 Chrome Shelled Regios
3 Black Blood Brothers
3 Fruit Basket
4.5 Spice and Wolf

I also have a MAL account but I go by more with what the words say like "good" = 7
http://myanimelist.net/animelist/funnyginsan

That's why I have a MAL account. Almost every show I've watched is listed there.
http://myanimelist.net/animelist/deadpanditto

I've watched about 340+ diffrent anime titles, so here's my completed list on MAL
http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Des&status=2&order=0

Every anime seen; i would give 4's and 5's.

2 Kuroshitsuji (black butler)
3 D.gray-man
5 Soul eater
3 Blood +
4 naruto
5 fullmetal alchemist
4 inuyasha
4 one piece
5 fairy tail
5 black cat
4 darker than black
3 shakugan no shana
4 durarara
5 bleach
5 code geass
3 vampire knights
5 ouran high school host club
5 samurai champloo
5 spice and wolf
5 angel beats
5 kobato
4 tegami bachi
5 the law of ueki
5 kimi ni todoke
5 tales of the abyss

There are more, I'm making a MAL account and will list mine there : D

Maaaan! I've seen only a small part of these lists. Though all of the watched are rated 5

so..... I"'veseen over 1000 series and you know this isn't showing off or anything nor bragging

but two people post their mal accounts so i might as well post

http://myanimelist.net/animelist/AnimeKami

Like AnimeKami my watched list is massive and ever-expanding so I'm just going to link to it.

http://www.anime-planet.com/users/Kruszer/anime?include_types=8,2,7,4,1,6,3,5&include_tags=none&exclude_tags=none&include_status=1

Currently 1,057 titles, even longer if I included the hentai, which I didn't.

Well, since my list would take forever to write, and I don't think I'll bother to link my MAL account (it's on my profile but I won't link it here since nobody would probably read it anyway) I'll just list my ratings for the shows I've seen that are on CR (ones I've seen at least 4-5 episodes of).

These ratings are based on HOW MUCH I ENJOYED THEM; the ratings don't necessarily represent whether they are actually "good" or "bad" shows.

I'll just sort them by rating:

1 - Felt like I totally wasted my time
Deadman Wonderland
Uraboku

2 - Only enjoyed a few parts
A Dark Rabbit Has Seven Lives
Brave 10
Fortune Arterial
Gintama
Sacred Seven
Un-go

3 - Worth watching to pass the time, but not awesome
Another
Code Geass
Hunter x Hunter
Kamisama Dolls
Ozma
Mysterious Girlfriend X
No. 6
Nyarko-san Another Crawling Chaos
Recoder and Randsell
World's Greatest First Love
You and Me
07 Ghost

4 - Really enjoyed it!
Beelzebub
Blue Exorcist
Chihayafuru
Dusk Maiden of Amnesia
Gosick
Inu x Boku SS
Otome Youkai Zakuro
Space Brothers
Star Driver
Tegami Bachi
The Diary of Tortov Roddle
Tsuritama

5 - Loved it!!!! <3 <3 <3 <3
Black Jack
Eureka Seven
Gankutsuou
Wandering Son
Kids on the Slope
Level E
Moribito
Natsume Yujincho
Pale Cocoon
Time of Eve
Usagi Drop

If we have similar tastes and you want to exchange recommendations, get in touch

If I gave out a list of every anime I've seen, we'd be here for days. So here's a list of animes I've FINISHED. lol

5-Tiger & Bunny
5-Uta-no Prince-sama
5-Monochrome Factor
5-The World God Only Knows
5-Princess Jellyfish
5-NANA
5-Junjou Romantica
5-Sekai-Ichi Hatsukoi
5-Un-Go
5-Fruits Basket
5-Ouran High School Host Club
5-Persona 4
5-Okane Ga Nai
5-DearS
5-Gravitation
5-Oreimo

4-Nichijou
4-Usagi Drop
4-Student Council's Discretion
4-Midori Days
4-Inu x Boku: Secret Service
4-FLCL
4-Blue Exorcist
4-Zakuro
4-Sasameki Koto

3-Baka and Test: Summon The Beasts
3-Panty and Stocking with Garterbelt
3-Another
3-Pani Poni Dash
3-Nyanpire: The Animation
3-Indian Summer
3-Magical Nurse Witch Komugi
3-Morita-san wa Mukuchi
3-A Dark Rabbit Has Seven Lives
3-High School Of The Dead
3-Papa To Kiss In The Dark
3-Phantom Thief Reinya
3-Yuru Yuri
3-Star Driver
3-No.6
3-Sukisho!

2-Yumeria
2-Chu-Bra
2-Cosplay Complex
2-Kanamemo
2-Boku no Pico
2-Level C
2-Modern Magic Made Simple

1-Chaos;HEAd
1-Maria Holic
1-CubexCursedxCurious

2 Akane-iro ni Somaru Saka
4 Black Lagoon
5 Blood+
5 Bokura Ga Ita
3 Clannad
5 Death Note
5 Detective Academy Q
5 Ef - A Tale of Melodies
5 Ef - A Tale Of Memories
2 Fortune Arterial: Akai Yakusoku
4 Fruits Basket
5 Full Metal Alchemist
1 Full Metal Panic
4 Full Metal Panic! Fumoffu
0 Fushigi Yuugi
5 Gakuen Alice
3 Ginban Kaleidoscope
5 Gokusen
5 Hunter X Hunter
4 Itazura Na Kiss
3 Junjou Romantica
3 Junjou Romantica II
1 Kaichou Wa Maid-sama
4 Kamichama Karin
2 Kimikiss Pure Rouge
5 Kino No Tabi
5 Kuroshitsuji
5 Kuroshitsuji II
5 La Corda D'oro
5 NANA
5 Naruto
5 Nodame Cantabile
5 Ouran High School Host Club
5 Prince of Tennis
5 Rurouni Kenshin
5 Shaman King
2 Shinrei Tantei Yakumo
3 Shugo Chara
5 Skip Beat!
5 Slam Dunk
3 Special A
4 Tenjou Tenge
5 The Law of Ueki
5 Toradora
5 Vampire Knight
5 Vampire Knight Guilty
4 Welcome to the NHK
5 xxxHolic
5 xxxHolic: Kei
5 Yamato Nadeshiko Shichi Henge
2 Zero No Tsukaima

All the anime I've watched I give 5 stars, it takes a lot of work to make something and I appreciate their efforts no matter how it turns out. I also don't have a favorite anime, I like them all in their own ways. Also you spelt Rating wrong, just a heads' up.

Elfen Lied
Birdy the Mighty: Decode
Angel Beats!
FLCL
Evangelion
Ef - a tale of memories/melodies
Chobits
Heaven's Lost Property
Black Lagoon
Cromartie High School
Ghost in the Shell
Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom
Gurren Lagann
Okami-san and Her Seven Companions
Chrono Crusade
B Gata H Kei
School Rumble
Baccano!
Fruits Basket
The World God Only Knows
Baka and Test
Gundam
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
K-On!
Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Summer Wars
The Girl Who Leapt Through Time
Spirited Away
Bakemonogatari/Nisemonogatari/Kizumonogatari
Clannad/After Story
Ga - Rei: Zero
5 Centimeters Per Second
Claymore
Ergo Proxy
Listen to Me, Girls. I'm Your Father!
School Days
The Familiar of Zero
Dragon Ball Z
High School of the Dead
Naruto
Figure 17
Astro Boy
Deadman Wonderland
My Little Sister Can't Be This Cute

5 Code Geass
5 Death Note
2 Ouran High School Host Club
5 Cowboy Bebop
5 Trigun
5 Neon Genesis Evangelion
4 Afro Samurai
3 Gunsmith Cats
3 All Purpose Cultural Catgirl Nuku Nuku (OVA)
3 Rozen Maiden
3 Blue Submarine No. 6
3 Slayers
4 Blue Seed
4 The Irresponsible Captain Tylor
5 Gurren Lagann
4 All Purpose Cultural Catgirl Nuku Nuku (TV Series)
3 Gunslinger Girl
5 Spirited Away
4 Howl's Moving Castle
5 Ghost in the Shell
4 Cowboy Bebop: The Movie
3 The End of Evangelion
1 Evangelion 1.0: You are not alone
5 Grave of the Fireflies
4 Akira
(3) 5 centimeters per second
4 Ranma 1/2
5 Yu Yu Hakusho
5 Rurouni Kenshin
4 Samurai Champloo
4 Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood
3 Dirty Pair Flash
3 Ghost Sweeper Mikami
1 Marmalade Boy
3 Nadia: The Secret of Blue Water
3 The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
2 Cardcaptor Sakura
3 Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam
5 Mobile Suit Gundam Seed
4 Lucky Star
3 Saber Marionette J
4 Mushishi